Florida Democrats gained more ground than in most states this year despite falling short in the two biggest races, an Axios analysis found.
The findings challenge the idea, held by some Democrats, that Angie Nixon’s Senate loss is a warning against running too far left; Florida is seen as a Republican stronghold. “There definitely was a broad blue shift, it just wasn't deep enough,” Daniel Smith, a University of Florida political science professor, told Axios.
The analysis shows Florida swung further toward Democrats this year than Georgia's gubernatorial race or Ohio's Senate race. Democratic gubernatorial nominee David Jolly improved on the 2022 margin by over 18 points, nearly 6 points above the median gain across 36 states. Senate nominee Angie Nixon improved by nearly 14 points.
Nixon's gains were particularly stark in Hispanic areas. In Hispanic-majority precincts, her margin improved by 22 points over Val Demings in 2022 and 21 points over Kamala Harris in 2024. The shift appeared across demographics: heavily Cuban precincts moved from R+34 to R+14, mostly Puerto Rican precincts from D+16 to D+35, and Mexican and Central American precincts from D+3 to D+44.
Jolly outperformed Nixon statewide, but only because he had stronger support among white voters and in the most Jewish precincts of Miami-Dade, Palm Beach and Broward counties. Nixon held her own among Hispanic voters, running slightly ahead of Jolly in Hispanic-majority precincts, where she lost by 2.8 points to his 3.2. Smith said, “The sentiments are still there, but it'll be interesting to see if [the results] were a wholesale move away from the Republican Party for those who turned out to vote or a backlash against the overzealous anti-immigration efforts by the Trump administration.”
Democratic strategist Steve Schale cautioned that the data does not provide “the full picture” of who voted. Ballots cast in Miami-Dade precincts where most voters were born in Cuba fell 3% from 2022, while rising 7% countywide. Schale said the party’s focus must be on “the gap”: what it takes to lose a Hispanic precinct by 20 points instead of 30.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The results offer Democrats a potential roadmap back to competitiveness in Florida, a state crucial for the Electoral College that has been written off in recent cycles.
- The swing in Hispanic precincts challenges the assumption that progressive economic messaging is toxic with this demographic, a central strategic debate for the party.
- Understanding whether the shift is genuine conversion or decreased Republican turnout will determine if the gains are durable.
Background
Florida was long the nation's biggest swing state but has tilted heavily Republican in recent cycles, with Hispanic voters, particularly Cuban-Americans, cited as a key driver of the rightward shift. The 2026 elections featured a moderate Democrat for governor, David Jolly, and a progressive, Angie Nixon, for Senate, providing a clear test of competing party strategies.
Key Perspectives
Daniel Smith (University of Florida political science professor): The state saw a broad blue shift that was not deep enough to overcome the Republican advantage. He suggests it could be a backlash against the Trump administration's immigration policies.
Steve Schale (Democratic strategist): The data lacks the full picture of turnout. A drop in voting in heavily Cuban precincts means some of the swing could be due to Republican voters staying home. The party's goal should be closing the gap.
What to Watch
- Whether Democrats can turn improved margins into actual victories in 2028, particularly if Donald Trump is on the ballot.
- The durability of the shift: whether it is a permanent realignment of Hispanic voters in Florida or specific to the 2026 political environment.
- The internal party debate over whether moderates or progressives are better positioned to lead the Florida comeback.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedHispanic-majority Florida precincts swung more than 21 points toward Democrats from 2024.Axios: “Hispanic-majority precincts that some feared would reject her politics swung more than 21 points toward Democrats from 2024”
- SupportedThe Hispanic-majority precinct shift challenges fears about Angie Nixon’s politics.Axios: “Some Democrats see Angie Nixon's Senate loss in Florida as a warning about running too far left. But her results with Hispanic voters challenge that idea”
- SupportedFlorida Democrats gained more ground than in most states this year despite falling short in the two biggest races.Axios: “Democrats gained more ground in Florida than in most states this year despite falling short in the two biggest races.”
- SupportedDaniel Smith said, “There definitely was a broad blue shift, it just wasn't deep enough.”Axios: “" There definitely was a broad blue shift, it just wasn't deep enough," Daniel Smith, a University of Florida political science professor, tells Axios.”
- SupportedFlorida swung further toward Democrats than Georgia’s gubernatorial race or Ohio’s Senate race.Axios: “Florida swung further toward Democrats than Georgia's gubernatorial race or Ohio's Senate race”
- SupportedDavid Jolly improved on the 2022 margin by more than 18 points, nearly six points above the median gain across 36 states.Axios: “Democratic nominee David Jolly improved on the 2022 margin by more than 18 points, nearly 6 points above the median gain across 36 states”
- SupportedAngie Nixon improved on the 2022 margin by nearly 14 points.Axios: “Nixon improved on the 2022 margin by nearly 14 points”
- SupportedNixon’s margin improved in Hispanic-majority precincts by 22 points over Val Demings in 2022 and 21 points over Kamala Harris in 2024.Axios: “Nixon's margin improved in Hispanic-majority precincts by 22 points over Val Demings in 2022 and 21 points better than Kamala Harris in 2024.”
- SupportedThe shift appeared across Cuban, Puerto Rican, Mexican and Central American precincts, with the stated margin changes.Axios: “in mostly Cuban precincts (R+34 to R+14), mostly Puerto Rican ones (D+16 to D+35) and Mexican and Central American ones (D+3 to D+44).”
- SupportedJolly outperformed Nixon statewide because he had stronger support among white voters and in the most Jewish precincts of Miami-Dade, Palm Beach and Broward counties.Axios: “Jolly outperformed Nixon statewide, but only because he had stronger support among white voters and in the most Jewish precincts of Miami-Dade, Palm Beach and Broward counties.”
- SupportedSmith said it remained unclear whether the results reflected a wholesale move away from Republicans among voters who turned out or a backlash against the Trump administration’s anti-immigration efforts.Axios: “"The sentiments are still there, but it'll be interesting to see if [the results] were a wholesale move away from the Republican Party for those who turned out to vote or a backlash against the overzealous anti-immigration efforts by the Trump administration," he said.”
- SupportedSteve Schale said the results do not provide “the full picture” of who voted.Axios: “The results still don't have "the full picture" of who actually voted on Election Day, Democratic strategist Steve Schale told Axios Monday.”