The applications, filed on 2 October, seek variations to wastewater discharge consents at Fonterra's Clandeboye, Darfield and Studholme sites. The variations would allow surplus raw milk to be incorporated into existing wastewater systems or applied directly to land. A Fonterra spokesperson said the consent variations would allow the co-operative to dispose of milk when events "out of its control" prevented it being processed.
Fonterra said it had not needed to dispose of milk this season and was already through the peak processing period, nor did it foresee needing to do so next season. The spokesperson said the company had considerable flexibility to shift processing to the North Island or adjust products, and that the disposal option was a contingency.
The Environmental Law Initiative (ELI) called on the council to reject the application. Senior researcher Anna Sintenie said the proposal represented a "vast" change from the original consents, both in substance, raw milk instead of washdown water, and in scale. "Twenty-two million litres is more than four litres of milk for every person in New Zealand. That's an extraordinary volume of food to waste, especially with so many households experiencing cost-of-living pressures," she said. ELI argued Fonterra should be required to submit a full new consent application.
Federated Farmers national dairy chair Karl Dean welcomed the move, calling it "good, prudent business practice" and noting that other milk processors may not have similar provisions in their consents. He said scenarios such as an earthquake could require milk disposal, and that the application was a risk management measure.
Greenpeace freshwater campaigner Rhiannon Mackie warned of harmful environmental impacts, saying Canterbury's porous soil made it easier for fluids to reach water tables, as with cow urine and synthetic fertiliser linked to nitrate contamination, and that lakes and rivers could see increases in toxic algal blooms. “Not only are New Zealanders subsidizing the dairy industry through the pollution of drinking water and lakes and rivers, we're also paying huge amounts of money at the supermarket for dairy products and meanwhile Fonterra is talking about dumping these raw milk products because they've just got so much of it,” she said.
Victoria University research fellow Dr Mike Joy said even routine dairy losses had a big impact, and dismissed Fonterra's claim that the environmental effects would be "less than minor". "Every application claims the impacts are less than minor but the cumulative effects of a whole heap of less than minors is major," he said.
Canterbury Regional Council general manager of regulatory implementation Paul Hulse said the council "do not and cannot take business constraints into account" when assessing consent applications and that the council's role was to determine whether the proposed changes fell within the scope of existing consents.