A fourth irreplaceable racing trophy has been stolen within a week, with thieves breaking into Caulfield Racecourse to snatch the 1948 Caulfield Cup from a secure display; the theft was confirmed on Wednesday.
The cup was on loan from a private collector, who bought it for $55,000 at auction in March, and was displayed in a secure section of the course for the spring carnival. The thieves also stole bottles of wine during the break-in last week.
Three Melbourne Cup trophies won by Makybe Diva were allegedly stolen from Flemington Racecourse early Monday morning. The three cups were worth an estimated $1 million each. A 36-year-old Malvern East man was arrested on Monday night as part of the investigation but released pending summons; the cups have not been found.
The Melbourne Racing Club said police had asked it not to speak to media during the investigation, but news leaked out Thursday morning. “As this is an active police investigation, the club can make no further comment at this stage,” an MRC spokesperson said.
The club has informed the cup’s owner, whom it declined to name, and indicated it was insured against theft.
Makybe Diva’s owner Tony Santic told this masthead it was believed the thieves were wearing high-vis clothing. “They (the VRC) told me the alarm went off and five minutes later security arrived, and they [the trophies] were gone,” Santic said.
The Victorian Racing Club, which governs Flemington, is insured against the theft of fine art.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Racing trophies carry immense heritage and sentimental value; the losses are a blow to the sport's history.
- The theft of four major cups within a week signals a serious security breach at two of Australia’s premier racecourses.
- The cups may be untraceable on the black market, reducing chances of recovery.
Background
Racing trophies are prized collectables, with historic cups like the 1948 Caulfield Cup and Makybe Diva’s Melbourne Cups fetching high prices at auction. The recent spate of thefts has prompted police investigations at both Flemington and Caulfield.
Key Perspectives
Melbourne Racing Club: has been asked by police not to comment, but confirmed the theft is under investigation.
Tony Santic (Makybe Diva’s owner): said the thieves were likely wearing high-vis clothing and that the alarm at Flemington triggered a five-minute response, but the trophies were gone by the time security arrived.
What to Watch
- Police investigations into both thefts, with possible links between the heists.
- Whether the insurance payouts cover the full value of the stolen trophies.
- Any changes to security protocols at major racecourses.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe Caulfield theft was the fourth racing-trophy theft in a week.WA Today - Latest News: “Fourth Cup stolen within a week.”
- SupportedThieves targeted Caulfield Racecourse, stealing a trophy from a secure display.WA Today - Latest News: “thieves had stolen a Caulfield Cup from a secure display at Caulfield Racecourse.”
- SupportedThe trophy was the 1948 Caulfield Cup, snatched from the secure display.WA Today - Latest News: “The 1948 Caulfield Cup was won by Red Fury and was on display in a secure section of Caulfield Racecourse for this year’s spring carnival. It was snatched by thieves who broke into the course last week.”
- Partly supportedThe three stolen Melbourne Cups were worth $3 million in total.WA Today - Latest News: “The three cups were worth an estimated $1 million each.”
- SupportedThe theft was confirmed on Wednesday.WA Today - Latest News: “it was confirmed on Wednesday that thieves had stolen a Caulfield Cup”
- SupportedThe cup was on loan from a private collector.WA Today - Latest News: “Melbourne Racing Club said the 1948 Caulfield Cup was on loan to the organisation from a private collector”
- SupportedThe collector bought the cup for $55,000 at auction in March.WA Today - Latest News: “who bought the vintage collectable for $55,000 at auction in March.”
- SupportedThe thieves also stole bottles of wine during the break-in last week.WA Today - Latest News: “It was snatched by thieves who broke into the course last week. They also stole bottles of wine.”
- SupportedThree Melbourne Cup trophies won by Makybe Diva were allegedly stolen from Flemington early Monday morning.WA Today - Latest News: “Makybe Diva’s three cups were allegedly stolen by two men who smashed into a display cabinet about 6.30am on Monday morning”
- SupportedA 36-year-old Malvern East man was arrested Monday night and released pending summons.WA Today - Latest News: “A 36-year-old Malvern East man was arrested on Monday night as part of the investigation but was released pending summons.”
- SupportedAn MRC spokesperson said: “As this is an active police investigation, the club can make no further comment at this stage,”WA Today - Latest News: ““As this is an active police investigation, the club can make no further comment at this stage,” an MRC spokesperson said.”
- SupportedTony Santic said: “They (the VRC) told me the alarm went off and five minutes later security arrived, and they [the trophies] were gone,”WA Today - Latest News: ““They (the VRC) told me the alarm went off and five minutes later security arrived, and they [the trophies] were gone,” Santic said.”