After more than two weeks of negotiations that spilled two days into overtime, making it the longest COP on record, Turkey’s conference president Murat Kurum said at the closing plenary that he could see there was no agreement and confirmed he would not advance any new text. “There is nothing to do, we did all that we could,” he said. “There will be no new text from now on.”
Bowen, who served as president of the COP31 negotiations in Antalya, Turkey, said disagreements over fuels and climate finance had been the dealbreakers. He commended delegations for pulling all-nighters to try to reach a deal, but said “the situation coming into this COP was the most complicated and fraught geopolitical environment in living memory”. “An obvious issue is the transition away from fossil fuels, where some parties insisted that must be mentioned, other parties insisted that if it was mentioned they would veto.”
Environment Minister Murray Watt denied the summit was a failure and defended Bowen. “I think what this shows [is] it’s a very challenging international environment at the moment,” Watt told Radio National. “If you’re a negotiator and you’ve got different parties who are incredibly far apart, it is very difficult to be able to bridge that divide. We didn’t have some veto power or some ability to decide on behalf of the rest of the world what would go in the text of that cover decision.”
Deputy Liberal leader Jane Hume questioned whether Bowen should have played a leading role. “It’s pretty extraordinary, isn’t it? We’ve spent $150 million to get Chris Bowen to COP, to host COP. Then we found out it was actually a co-host deal. Now we’re walking away without a deal at all,” she told News24. “It should be something that Australia should be concerned about. Perhaps Chris Bowen wasn’t necessarily the best choice to be the co-president of COP this year.”
One Nation MP Barnaby Joyce said the failure proved Australia should abandon green energy policies and embrace coal-fired power. “We want to rebuild coal,” Joyce said on Sunrise. “We want to get away from your policy which is destroying this nation.” Joyce could not answer repeated questions about how much the plan to rebuild coal-fired power stations would cost.
Industry Minister Tim Ayres called the outcome “disappointing” and said Australia stands to lose more from a failure to act on climate change than almost any other country. “Obviously it’s a disappointing outcome … It is very challenging, but it’s also very clear climate change is a real thing. It requires global action in order to be effective,” he told Nine’s Today show. “Our region, the Pacific regards this as the number one question for their security.”
Liberal senator Michaelia Cash laid the blame squarely on Bowen and accused him of ignoring economic pressures being faced by Australians. “Whilst Australians are doing it tough at home and living an economic nightmare … Chris Bowen was overseas negotiating for countries like Australia to spend billions more in providing international climate financing.”
Separately, Home Affairs Minister Tony Burke said One Nation’s plan to slash Australia’s humanitarian refugee intake would make it more likely for people smugglers to attempt to enter the country. He told News24 the government’s humanitarian refugee program is a pillar of its “anti-people smuggling messaging”. “Our argument has always been there is a right way to come to Australia, and there is a wrong way to come to Australia. The right way is to apply for a visa … But, if you try to come here without a visa, we will be turning you around, and that’s what we’ve continued to do. If you give away the humanitarian program, which effectively is what One Nation policy does, you give away one of our key arguments against people smuggling.” Last week, Pauline Hanson announced a proposal to cut Australia’s annual refugee intake by 90 per cent. She also said the party would bar parent and grandparent visas.