Semmens, the party's candidate for the winnable seat of Albert Park, posted the remark on Facebook on March 1, set against images from the aftermath of a lethal missile strike in Iran early in the war. The post questioned whether the war was 'the world's greatest change of subject', an apparent reference to disinformation promoted by far-right groups that the strikes were timed to distract from the Jeffrey Epstein sex-trafficking scandal.
The Greens candidate, who previously stood in the 2022 and 2025 federal elections, did not explain what she meant by 'new world order ruled by child rapists' when asked by The Age. The Greens' position is that Semmens's comments were solely directed at US President Donald Trump and the Australian government's support for the war in Iran. 'It's well established that Trump is a friend of Jeffrey Epstein, and still hasn't explained why he is on the Epstein list,' Semmens said. 'It is vile that Albanese continues to buddy up with Trump, even today.'
Joshua Roose, a Deakin University expert in political extremism and the director of research and policy at the Dor Foundation, said Semmens's comments were 'embedded in a wide array of conspiracy theories' that feed into tropes about Jews controlling global affairs. Roose said one reference was the concept of a new world order, the idea of a global elite pulling the strings from behind the scenes, which has antisemitic undertones; the other was the concept of child rapists. He said Semmens was clearly referring to Jeffrey Epstein and his alleged links with the Trump administration, and that this went back to the idea that the war was to distract from the Epstein scandal. In the absence of any other material, he said Semmens was on a concerning path.
Victorian Greens leader Ellen Sandell backed Semmens's criticism of Trump and the Albanese government when asked whether she would take any steps in response to the post.
Jewish community leaders condemned the post. Zionist Federation of Australia president Jeremy Leibler declared that anyone who promotes such conspiracy theories has no place in public office. 'The idea that the Prime Minister is for a world order ruled by child rapists is not just ridiculous, it's wrong,' he said. Executive Council of Australian Jewry president Daniel Aghion said the post was 'very disturbing, but far from surprising,' noting that antisemitic tropes of Jewish secretive influence over international politics appear on both the far-left and far-right.
The controversy comes as the Greens face a strained relationship with Melbourne's Jewish communities. On Thursday night, the party's candidate for the neighbouring seat of Caulfield was excluded from a community election forum hosted by the Jewish Community Council of Victoria and Zionism Victoria, with CEO Naomi Levin saying the Greens had spent much of the past parliamentary term 'obsessed with bashing Israel.'
Semmens, a community fundraiser who has a realistic chance of winning Albert Park, held by Labor for 76 years but now a tight three-way race, previously vowed to improve relations with Jewish voters. In an April 2025 interview with the Jewish Independent, she said she saw it as 'my role and responsibility to be that voice of care and concern for the Jewish community.'