Sunday 4 October 2026
Afternoon EditionRSS
ZOTPAPER

News without the noise

ZOTPAPER
Australia

Greens hope new leader David Shoebridge can replicate global populist wave

Party stalls in polls as left-wing movements succeed overseas

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
The Australian Greens have elected hard-left senator David Shoebridge as their new leader in a rare contested ballot, following Larissa Waters' shock resignation due to health issues. The party is wrestling with why it has failed to capture the same populist energy that has propelled left-wing candidates like New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani and UK Greens leader Zack Polanski, despite Labor's vote slipping in the polls.

On the first day of this year, socialist US senator Bernie Sanders stood alongside newly sworn-in New York Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who had won a million votes on a platform of free childcare, free transport and higher taxes for the rich. A month later in the United Kingdom, Greens leader Zack Polanski declared that Labour could no longer take progressive voters for granted after his party seized a seat from the government in a byelection, promising to tax the super-rich.

The Australian Greens have been making similar pledges for most of this year, but polls show they have gone nowhere.

"There's eternal frustration that we haven't cracked through more," one Greens insider said.

The party's stagnation has become a source of head-scratching even outside the Greens, as Labor's primary vote declines while the minor party fails to pick up the slack. Meanwhile, One Nation's support has surged.

These questions came into sharp focus this week when Larissa Waters, a well-liked consensus-builder, resigned as Greens leader for health reasons. The party quickly moved to elect Senator David Shoebridge, a hard-left figure, in a contested ballot, hoping his energy can replicate the Mamdani wave. The party has long hovered at around a 12 per cent share of the federal vote, and some within the party wonder whether a more unashamedly populist approach could break that ceiling.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The Greens' struggles affect the balance of power in federal politics, potentially keeping Labor competitive even if its own vote softens.
  • The party's inability to convert Labor dissatisfaction into gains suggests structural issues or messaging problems that may persist under new leadership.
  • The rise of One Nation highlights that disaffected voters are moving right, not left, raising questions about the Greens' appeal to working-class voters.

Background

The Australian Greens have been a minor party since the 1990s, typically polling between 8 and 12 per cent federally. While they have won lower-house seats and hold the balance of power in the Senate at times, they have struggled to break into a broader electorate. Larissa Waters' resignation this week created a leadership vacuum, and David Shoebridge's election signals a shift to a more confrontational style. Internationally, left-wing populists such as Mamdani in New York and Polanski in the UK have found success with similar platforms of taxing the wealthy and expanding public services.

Key Perspectives

[Greens leadership]: David Shoebridge and the party's left faction believe a more aggressive, unashamedly populist message can finally break through, mirroring the success of Mamdani and Polanski. [Traditional Greens voters]: The base is broadly progressive and may welcome a sharper attack on inequality, but some moderates worry about alienating swing voters. [Critics and political analysts]: They argue the Greens' focus on cultural issues and a perceived radicalism limits their appeal, and that One Nation's rise shows that economic populism in Australia is being captured by the right, not the left.

What to Watch

  • Polling in the next few months to see if Shoebridge's leadership changes the Greens' trajectory.
  • The party's strategy in the next federal byelection or general election campaign.
  • Whether One Nation's continued growth forces the Greens to recalibrate their messaging on cost-of-living and economic security.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workReport an errorSubscribe