Greens put Gaza at centre of fight for Starmer's former seat

By-election in Holborn and St Pancras tests Labour's grip as Green leader Zack Polanski campaigns on boycott and divestment

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Voters in Holborn and St Pancras go to the polls on Thursday in a by-election triggered by the resignation of former prime minister Keir Starmer, with Green Party leader Zack Polanski seeking to end Labour's decades-long hold on the seat by making Gaza the defining issue of the campaign.

At a meeting organised by the Camden Muslim Network in London, Polanski and Liberal Democrat candidate Patrick Stillman made their cases to residents beside empty seats. Their Labour and Conservative counterparts did not attend. Labour candidate Sagal Abdi Wali, a Somali-Muslim woman who leads Camden council, told The Guardian she had a prior obligation and the invite had come too late. The organiser pushed back, saying she had been invited earlier.

Fifteen candidates are contesting the seat, which Labour has held since it was created in 1983. Starmer first won it in 2015 and held it until his resignation. The meeting's conversation ranged from housing to Israel and Palestine. Stillman said his party had long called for Palestinian statehood but would not support a full boycott. Polanski drew applause arguing that the Labour government's position is "deeply cynical": apologising over Gaza while continuing to sell arms to Israel, a country he said is committing a genocide. The Greens, who recently voted to describe Zionism as racism, support a full boycott.

Green leaflets sent to constituents target Abdi Wali, who became leader of Camden council in May. One reads: "Bring change, Replace Labour, Vote Green" and claims every Camden Labour councillor refused to sign the Palestine solidarity pledge or support pension fund divestment. Abdi Wali told the Camden New Journal the claim was "obviously inaccurate", saying the council did feel strongly about the issue and that she wants to focus on the message of Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband's government on Palestine, Israel, Gaza and the West Bank.

In January, Camden Friends of Palestine presented a petition with 4,000 signatures calling on the council to divest.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The by-election is an early test of whether Gaza solidarity can break Labour's hold on a constituency it has represented since the seat was created in 1983.
  • A win for Polanski would give the Green leader a seat in the House of Commons, changing the dynamics of opposition politics.
  • The campaign's focus on arms sales and divestment could pressure Labour to revisit its stance on Israel regardless of the result.

Background

Holborn and St Pancras has been a Labour stronghold since its creation in 1983. Starmer represented the seat from 2015 until his resignation triggered Thursday's poll. The local campaign has become a flashpoint over party positions on Gaza, with Green leaflets accusing the local council of refusing to sign a Palestine solidarity pledge or support pension fund divestment, and Labour defending its record.

Key Perspectives

Labour, Sagal Abdi Wali: Rejects the Greens' characterisation of the council as indifferent, calling the leaflets inaccurate, and points to Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband's work on Palestine, Israel, Gaza and the West Bank. Greens, Zack Polanski: Argues Labour's apologies over Gaza are hollow while arms sales to Israel continue, and backs a full boycott including divestment. Liberal Democrats, Patrick Stillman: Supports Palestinian statehood but stops short of endorsing a full boycott. Critics and sceptics: The absence of Labour and Conservative candidates from the community meeting risked ceding the issue to rivals, and the practical effect of boycott and divestment campaigns as tools for change remains contested.

What to Watch

  • The by-election result on Thursday and the size of Labour's margin of victory or defeat.
  • Whether the Green vote draws enough support to deny Labour a comfortable win, and what that signals for other seats facing similar campaigns.
  • Any shift in Labour's position on arms sales to Israel in the weeks after the vote.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.