Hayden Flinn, co-chief executive of a large Hong Kong law firm, filed a lawsuit in 2024 claiming he was unlawfully detained for two weeks in a Richmond hotel in May 2021, after returning to Melbourne following his daughter's death. At the time, there were no local transmissions of COVID-19 in Melbourne and Hong Kong was not on the government's list of virus danger zones.
Flinn argued officials failed to properly assess his personal circumstances, vaccination status and the low risk presented by travellers from Hong Kong. His lawyer, Alex King of King and Collins, said that when the government's pleadings were finally filed, the decision by then-chief health officer Brett Sutton to detain Flinn had never been written down.
"In court proceedings for false imprisonment, the usual position is wanting money in damages for that false imprisonment. As part of his settlement with the state, though, Hayden sought no financial compensation. He did not want a dollar for his pocket," King said. Flinn is donating every cent received from the government to help young people struggling with mental health.
In a statement seen by this masthead, Secretary of Health Jenny Atta said the state regrets the impact mandatory hotel quarantine had on Flinn's family but denies any allegation of wrongdoing. "The state acknowledges that Mr Flinn's detention caused him and his family significant personal distress and regrets this," Atta said. "At Mr Flinn's request, the state has agreed to make a monetary contribution to be used by Mr Flinn for charitable purposes focusing on Victorian youth mental health."
King estimated the state would have spent over $2 million in taxpayer funds defending its case had it gone to court. Hugh de Kretser, president of the Australian Human Rights Commission, thanked Flinn for bringing his case and ensuring some accountability for detention decisions that impacted many others in similar circumstances. “Your actions will help to ensure a more compassionate and humane response to future public health emergencies,” de Kretser said.
Flinn and his wife Dr Sarah Whorlow plan to find a charity they hope to work with long term, where they hope to share their lived experience of youth mental health when the time feels right. Flinn noted that suicide is the leading cause of death for people aged 15 to 24 in Australia. “What is disturbing is the number of suicides that are happening in the community and they're getting younger,” he said.