Hundreds of protesters sought to block the entrances of Oriel College, Oxford, on Tuesday evening, opposing a talk by Nathan Cofnas, the self-described 'race realist' who first raised plagiarism allegations against the late professor Jason Arday. The event, organised by the university's Reform UK student society, went ahead despite opposition from students, staff and local politicians.
The protest saw demonstrators chanting 'Say his name, professor Jason Arday' and holding signs bearing his name. Police appeared towards the end of the event to clear protesters from the entrances.
Cofnas earlier this year was the first to raise accusations of plagiarism against Prof Jason Arday. Arday resigned from his post at the University of Cambridge and died weeks later amid sustained media scrutiny which began with the claims.
Inside the lecture theatre, about 40 people attended, with less than a third of the space filled. Cofnas spent the majority of an hour talking about the history of what he called the 'race equality thesis' and his reasons for questioning it. When asked if he wished to apologise to Arday's family, he declined, saying the implication behind the question was 'we shouldn't criticise powerful figures'. Cofnas added that he would ask people at Cambridge University who he said had protected Arday for three years and suppressed all criticism these questions, earning a brief round of applause.
Anneliese Dodds, the MP for Oxford East, said she had written to Oriel College after receiving complaints. She said Cofnas's views 'are both repellent and contrary to the facts' and asked the college what it was doing to act on students' concerns about the meeting, including on safety grounds.
Misan Harriman, the photographer and former chair of trustees of the Southbank Centre, attended the protest because he was concerned by the 'damaging' rhetoric Cofnas espoused. 'The university has failed all the students, not just the black students, by having them see this as something that could be remotely seen as part of the course of free speech,' Harriman said.
Tommy, a second-year maths student, said the event was part of a 'nasty pattern' of 'Oxford societies pandering to the far right'. Hannah, a first-year law student, said the size of the protest showed that 'even if Oxford won't listen to us and won't cancel the event, we're still going to show up' and demonstrate opposition.
Oriel College, which allowed the Reform society to use a lecture theatre, declined to cancel the booking, saying it had a 'statutory duty' to allow Cofnas to appear.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The protest highlights ongoing tensions between free speech and campus safety at UK universities.
- The death of Jason Arday after plagiarism accusations has made cases like this more sensitive.
- The event raises questions about the role of student societies in giving platforms to controversial figures.
Background
Nathan Cofnas is a blogger and academic who describes himself as a 'race realist' and has argued that under a meritocratic system black people would 'disappear from almost all high-profile positions outside of sports and entertainment'. He first raised plagiarism allegations against Prof Jason Arday, a prominent academic and author, earlier this year. Arday resigned from Cambridge and died weeks later. Cofnas's talk at Oriel College was organised by the university's Reform UK society.
Key Perspectives
- Protesters and critics: They argue the event created a hostile environment and that Oxford should not platform Cofnas, given the circumstances of Arday's death.
- Nathan Cofnas: He defended his appearance, suggesting the push to have him apologise was an attempt to suppress criticism of powerful figures.
- Anneliese Dodds (MP): She called Cofnas's views 'repellent and contrary to the facts' and pressed the college on safety measures.
- Oriel College: It stated it had a 'statutory duty' to allow the event and declined to cancel it.
What to Watch
- Any official statement from Oxford University on its policy regarding controversial speakers.
- Potential disciplinary action or policy changes by Oriel College or the Reform society.
- Further protests or debates on similar events at other universities.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedHundreds protested against Nathan Cofnas’s talk at Oriel College in Oxford.World news | The Guardian: “Hundreds of protesters filled the cobbled streets around Oriel College, Oxford, to voice their opposition to an appearance by Nathan Cofnas”
- SupportedCofnas was the first to raise plagiarism accusations against Jason Arday and spoke at an Oriel College event despite opposition.World news | The Guardian: “Earlier this year, Cofnas was the first to raise accusations of plagiarism against Prof Jason Arday.”
- SupportedThe event was organised by the university’s Reform UK student society and went ahead despite opposition.World news | The Guardian: “The event organised by the university’s Reform UK student society [...] went ahead on Tuesday evening despite opposition from students, college staff and local politicians”
- SupportedProtesters sought to block Oriel College’s main entrances.World news | The Guardian: “The crowds outside sought to block the college’s main entrances”
- SupportedProtesters chanted “Say his name – professor Jason Arday”.World news | The Guardian: “with hundreds chanting “Say his name – professor Jason Arday””
- SupportedArday resigned from his Cambridge post and died weeks later amid sustained media scrutiny that began with Cofnas’s claims.World news | The Guardian: “Arday died weeks later, having resigned from his post as professor at the University of Cambridge, amid sustained media scrutiny which began with Cofnas’s claims”
- SupportedPolice appeared towards the end of the event to clear protesters from the entrances.World news | The Guardian: “a group of police appeared towards the end of the event to clear protesters from the entrances.”
- SupportedAbout 40 people attended, and less than a third of the lecture-theatre space was filled.World news | The Guardian: “About 40 people made it into the venue, with less than a third of the space filled.”
- SupportedWhen asked if he wanted to apologise to Arday’s family, Cofnas declined and said the implication was “we shouldn’t criticise powerful figures”.World news | The Guardian: “Inside the lecture theatre, Cofnas was asked if he wanted to apologise to Arday’s family, but he declined. He said the implication behind the question was that “we shouldn’t criticise powerful figures”.”
- SupportedDodds said Cofnas’s views were “both repellent and contrary to the facts”.World news | The Guardian: “Dodds said: “Cofnas’ views are both repellent and contrary to the facts.”
- SupportedHarriman said the university had failed all students by presenting Cofnas’s rhetoric as something that could be part of free speech.World news | The Guardian: ““The university has failed all the students, not just the black students, by having them see this as something that could be remotely seen as part of the course of free speech,” Harriman said.”
- SupportedOriel College declined to cancel the booking, saying it had a statutory duty to allow Cofnas to appear.World news | The Guardian: “Oriel, which allowed the Reform society to use a lecture theatre, declined to cancel the booking, saying it had a “statutory duty” to allow the blogger and academic to appear.”