Immigration and Customs Enforcement is re-arresting immigrants who have won release from detention through habeas corpus petitions, sometimes within days and in one set of cases before detainees had left the building, according to court records, attorneys and media reports gathered by the Guardian, which identified at least 20 such cases nationwide in the past year.
Immigration attorneys say the re-arrests often appear to defy the court orders that freed their clients. “We've seen a very, very sharp increase in people who are released on habeas petitions, only to be very rapidly re-detained, often in violation of the federal court's order,” said Bridget Pranzatelli, an attorney with the National Immigration Project.
A habeas corpus petition, Latin for “you shall have a body,” challenges in federal court the government's right to hold someone in custody while their main legal case proceeds. Filings have surged: more than 91,000 habeas petitions have been lodged, with more filed since 25 January than during the past three presidential administrations combined, according to research by ProPublica.
One of Pranzatelli's clients, Akram Mahmoud Omar, a 77-year-old Palestinian man who suffered a heart attack while detained in “Camp 57,” the ICE facility inside Louisiana's Angola state prison, was arrested again within 10 days of his release. In Minnesota, seven immigrants were re-detained before they had even exited the Whipple federal building detention facility outside Minneapolis. “I don't think being taken out of a building and directly into the arms of four or more officers complies with the court's order,” said Daniel Suitor, an attorney to two of the men.
Courts are taking notice. In October, the 10th US circuit court of appeals in Colorado denied the government's attempt to dismiss a habeas petition on the grounds that it had the power to re-detain the petitioner, noting the government had a previous “demonstrated pattern of re-detaining” non-citizens who had been granted habeas relief. A federal judge in Louisiana held a senior federal immigration official in contempt of court for violating orders, demanding Ibrahim Mohammed's release after he had been re-arrested three times by ICE, and judges in Pennsylvania and Minnesota have held or threatened to hold federal immigration authorities in contempt.
Attorneys say some re-detentions are tied to the Trump administration's push to deport people to third countries. “It's really tethered to the explosion of third country agreements with primarily African nations in the past four months,” said Susanna Booth, senior attorney at the Amica Center for Immigrant Rights. The administration is increasingly sending immigrants who cannot be removed to their home countries, because those countries will not accept them or because they hold protections from deportation there, to countries where they do not hold citizenship and often have no ties. More than 25,000 non-citizens have been deported to countries that are not their own despite potentially facing torture or persecution. Often, they are incarcerated in prisons or detained in secured hotels and pressured to return to their home countries, which human rights experts say violates the Convention Against Torture.
Withholding of removal means people cannot be removed to the countries listed on their orders, but they can be removed to third countries, one attorney quoted in the report said. He said that had always been the law but was not practiced. In September, an appeals court ruled the administration had to give sufficient notice of third-country deportations and allow immigrants to contest them; the Supreme Court's six-justice conservative majority then granted an emergency stay of that ruling, allowing fast-track deportations to continue.
A court overruled a Biden-era policy prohibiting most people who crossed the border unlawfully from obtaining asylum, making some immigrants eligible for asylum. Joseph Giardina, a Louisiana immigration attorney, had two Egyptian clients protected under withholding of removal who were re-detained weeks after release, threatened with deportation and then granted asylum. “The Trump administration knows [the Biden-era rule] was the only reason they were not granted asylum,” Giardina said, “and they are doing their damnedest to deport them as quickly as they possibly can to another country.”
Many people, however, are being re-arrested with no apparent deportation plans and left in detention indefinitely, attorneys say. According to an analysis by Bolts, the Lens and the Texas Tribune, courts are taking months to decide the thousands of habeas cases, particularly in Louisiana and Texas. “We can sort of win the battle, but we're going to lose the war,” said Jonah Eaton, an UnLocal litigation attorney who has filed habeas suits for immigration detainees, “because in the long run, they're still going to be able to do what they want to do, which is arrest people and hold them for long periods of time.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Court-ordered release is supposed to end detention, but rapid re-arrest can leave the habeas remedy hollow for immigrants.
- Some re-detentions are tied to a fast-expanding third-country deportation program that sends people to nations where they have no ties and may face danger.
- Judges' responses, including contempt findings, are testing whether federal courts can enforce their orders against immigration authorities.
Background
Habeas filings have surged under the current administration, with more petitions lodged since 25 January than during the previous three presidential administrations combined. The policy backdrop is an accelerating third-country removal program, an appeals court ruling requiring notice and the right to contest removals, and a Supreme Court emergency stay that allowed deportations to continue quickly.
Key Perspectives
- Immigration attorneys: say re-arrests of people released on habeas petitions have increased sharply and often violate federal court orders.
- Susanna Booth (Amica Center for Immigrant Rights): links some re-detentions to the expansion of third-country agreements, primarily with African nations.
- Joseph Giardina, Louisiana immigration attorney: says the administration is trying to deport protected clients as quickly as possible before they can claim asylum.
- Trump administration: argued in the 10th Circuit that it had the power to re-detain people granted habeas relief.
- 10th US circuit court of appeals: rejected that argument, citing a demonstrated pattern of re-detaining non-citizens granted habeas relief.
What to Watch
- Whether the Supreme Court keeps its emergency stay allowing third-country deportations without the notice and contest rights ordered by the appeals court.
- Whether more federal judges follow the contempt findings in Louisiana, Pennsylvania and Minnesota if ICE re-arrests released detainees.
- Whether habeas cases in Louisiana and Texas, where many detention centres are located, move quickly enough to prevent people being stranded in detention.
Checked
10 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 7 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedPranzatelli said there had been a “very, very sharp increase” in people released on habeas petitions and rapidly re-detained, often in violation of a federal court order.World news | The Guardian: ““We’ve seen a very, very sharp increase in people who are released on habeas petitions, only to be very rapidly re-detained, often in violation of the federal court’s order,” said Bridget Pranzatelli”
- SupportedSuitor said taking someone out of a building directly into the arms of four or more officers might not comply with the court’s order.World news | The Guardian: ““I don’t think being taken out of a building and directly into the arms of four or more officers complies with the court’s order,” Daniel Suitor, attorney to two of the men, said”
- SupportedThe Guardian identified at least 20 cases nationwide in the past year involving people detained again after release on habeas petitions.World news | The Guardian: “The Guardian has identified at least 20 cases nationwide relating to people who were detained after being released on habeas corpus petition in the last year”
- Partly supportedAt least 20 released detainees were re-detained in the past year.World news | The Guardian: “The Guardian has identified at least 20 cases nationwide relating to people who were detained after being released on habeas corpus petition in the last year”
- SupportedMore than 91,000 habeas petitions have been filed, with more filed since 25 January than during the past three presidential administrations combined.World news | The Guardian: “Increasing arrests and detentions have led to immigrants filing more than 91,000 habeas petitions as they seek to challenge their detentions, according to research by ProPublica. More petitions have been filed since 25 January than during the past three presidential administrations, including Trump’s first term, combined”
- SupportedICE is re-arresting immigrants who won court-ordered release through habeas petitions, according to lawyers and records.World news | The Guardian: “Immigrants who have been granted release from detention after winning habeas corpus petitions in court are being re-arrested by US Immigration and Customs Enforcement ( ICE ).”
- SupportedBooth said the re-detentions were tied to the increase in third-country agreements, mainly with African nations, over the previous four months.World news | The Guardian: ““It’s really tethered to the explosion of third country agreements with primarily African nations in the past four months,” said Susanna Booth”
- Partly supportedA court overturned a Biden-era policy barring most people who crossed the border unlawfully from obtaining asylum, making some immigrants eligible for asylum.World news | The Guardian: “some immigrants facing third country removals who won withholding of removal are now eligible for asylum after a court overruled a Biden-era policy prohibiting most people who crossed the US-Mexico border unlawfully from obtaining asylum.”
- Partly supportedAttorneys say many people are re-arrested with no apparent deportation plans and left in detention indefinitely.World news | The Guardian: “Yet many people are being re-arrested with no apparent plans for deportation, leaving them stranded in detention indefinitely.”
- SupportedGiardina said the Trump administration was doing its “damnedest” to deport his clients quickly to another country.World news | The Guardian: ““and they are doing their damnedest to deport them as quickly as they possibly can to another country”.”