Immigration New Zealand has released guidelines to its officers clarifying the visa rules for customary adoptions of children born overseas, saying such adoptions must occur at an early age and involve extended family in the child's home country, not New Zealand residents.
The guidelines, issued to immigration officers last week, come after the Government closed a loophole last year that allowed some international adoptions to circumvent Family Court checks, following revelations that some adopted children had become victims of sexual or physical abuse, or forced labour.
Among adoptive parents were some who had adopted more than 10 children each, who had previous convictions for violence or sexual abuse, and in one case a family investigated by police for people trafficking. The closure has left prospective parents in New Zealand unable to adopt from countries that have not ratified the Hague Convention, with a small number of exceptions.
INZ deputy chief operating officer Jock Gilray said the guidelines were aimed at improving the understanding of immigration requirements on customary adoptions, which INZ identified as an area requiring further clarification for staff and stakeholders.
“Periodically INZ has seen New Zealand residents applying for visas for children living overseas involving a customary adoption. However, we are not able to provide more specific data as the information isn't held in a reportable format,” Gilray said. “We would need to manually review all dependent child applications to determine whether they involved a customary adoption.”
The advice to staff says that for visas to be granted, children must have been adopted overseas and at an early age, and that immigration officers should not rely solely on a written declaration from adoptive parents. “At a general level, an age of 10 or over would not be considered an early age for the purposes of the relevant instructions,” the guidelines state.
Customary adoptions must also be to extended family members who are not New Zealand residents when the adoption takes place, and must occur in the dependent child's home country following established cultural practices. “If an adopting parent was habitually resident in New Zealand at the time of the adoption, then it is unlikely that this would meet the standard of the adoption occurring in the child's home country,” the guidelines say.
INZ said providing financial support to a child and family members looking after them overseas does not by itself establish a parent-child relationship. Officers may request other evidence such as school or health records to show a child has been in the adopting parents' care from an early age.
The agency said customary adoptions must meet specific criteria to be recognised for immigration purposes, meaning they “will not be a viable alternative to a legal adoption for families that do not meet these criteria.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The guidelines affect prospective parents in New Zealand who seek to bring children from overseas into their families through customary adoptions, a pathway now more tightly restricted.
- The clarification follows a government crackdown on a loophole that allowed some adoptions to bypass Family Court oversight, amid concerns about child abuse and trafficking.
- INZ cannot provide data on how many children are involved, leaving the scale of the practice unknown.
Background
Customary adoptions are informal arrangements involving extended family and are meant to occur in the child's home country according to cultural practices. The New Zealand Government closed a loophole last year after revelations that some adopted children had been victims of sexual or physical abuse, or forced labour. Among the adoptive parents were people with multiple adoptions and prior convictions for violence or sexual abuse, and one family investigated for people trafficking. Since the changes, many prospective parents have been unable to adopt from countries that have not ratified the Hague Convention on inter-country adoption.
Key Perspectives
Immigration New Zealand: Says the guidelines are intended to improve staff and stakeholder understanding of the requirements, and that customary adoptions must meet specific criteria to be recognised, including adoption at an early age and transfer of parental responsibility to extended family in line with customary practice.
What to Watch
- Whether the guidelines lead to more consistent visa decisions or further restrict adoptions from non-Hague countries.
- Any further data INZ may release after manual reviews of dependent child applications.
- Potential legal challenges or calls for reform from families affected by the tighter rules.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedGilray said INZ had periodically seen New Zealand residents applying for visas for overseas children involving customary adoption, but could not provide more specific data because it was not held in a reportable format.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “"Periodically INZ has seen New Zealand residents applying for visas for children living overseas involving a customary adoption. However, we are not able to provide more specific data as the information isn't held in a reportable format."”
- SupportedGilray said INZ would need to manually review all dependent-child applications to determine whether they involved customary adoption.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “We would need to manually review all dependent child applications to determine whether they involved a customary adoption.”
- SupportedThe guidelines say an age of 10 or over would not be considered an early age.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “"At a general level, an age of 10 or over would not be considered an early age for the purposes of the relevant instructions," said the advice to staff.”
- SupportedThe guidelines say that if an adopting parent was habitually resident in New Zealand at the time of adoption, it is unlikely the adoption would meet the standard of occurring in the child's home country.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “If an adopting parent was habitually resident in New Zealand at the time of the adoption, then it is unlikely that this would meet the standard of the adoption occurring in the child's home country.”
- SupportedINZ said customary adoption would not be a viable alternative to legal adoption for families that did not meet the criteria.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “This means it will not be a viable alternative to a legal adoption for families that do not meet these criteria.”
- SupportedImmigration NZ issued guidelines on customary adoptions of overseas children.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Guidelines on customary adoptions of overseas children issued by Immigration NZ.”
- SupportedStaff were told not to rely solely on written declarations from adoptive parents.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “In guidelines released to immigration officers last week, INZ said that they should not rely solely on a written declaration from adoptive parents”
- SupportedThe summary says children must be adopted at an early age by extended family in the child's home country, with those family members not resident in New Zealand at the time.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “INZ said customary adoptions must meet specific criteria, including that it occurred at an early age and to extended family members who are not New Zealand residents when the adoption takes place.”
- SupportedThe guidelines were issued to immigration officers last week.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “In guidelines released to immigration officers last week”
- SupportedThe Government closed a loophole last year that had allowed some international adoptions to circumvent Family Court checks, following revelations of abuse or forced labour involving some adopted children.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “The Government last year closed a loophoole which allowed some international adoptions to circumvent Family Court checks. It followed revelations that some adopted children had become victims of sexual or physical abuse, or forced labour.”
- SupportedSome adoptive parents had adopted more than 10 children each and had previous convictions for violence or sexual abuse; one family had been investigated by police for people trafficking.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “Among adoptive parents were some who had adopted more than 10 children each, who had previous convictions for violence or sexual abuse, and in one case a family investigated by police for people trafficking”
- SupportedThe closure left prospective parents in New Zealand unable to adopt from countries that have not ratified the Hague Convention, with a small number of exceptions.RNZ New Zealand Headlines: “It has left prospective parents in New Zealand unable to adopt from countries that have not ratified the Hague Convention, with a small number of exceptions.”