In communities across India, especially among the urban poor and religious minorities, the removals have left people unable to vote and fearful of losing access to government services.
Kanchan, a single mother living under a flyover in New Delhi, said about 500 adults in her community were struck from the rolls after an election official visited and had her sign a form. She and others were removed on the grounds that they had relocated. "The government is choosing the people that support them," she told NPR, accusing the BJP of engineering the voter rolls to disenfranchise communities opposed to the party.
The Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP), however, has defended the exercise. In a video posted on its YouTube channel in early October, it said the deleted names belonged to people who had died, had duplicate entries, had moved residences, or were otherwise absent from their constituencies.
Critics point to systemic problems. Activists say many voters were removed because they could not provide documents proving that their parents or grandparents voted in elections more than two decades ago, a requirement never demanded before. Others said they were told to reconcile spelling discrepancies between how their names appeared on voter rolls and on newly distributed enumeration forms. One notice was handed to Nasir Malik, a community activist in Mustafabad, who said: "This makes no sense. If this was a problem, how did I vote in elections before this?"
Lawyer Kaustubh Chaturvedi, who has filed multiple petitions against the revision, called it "the largest disenfranchisement exercise in human history" and said the burden of proof had been shifted onto citizens: "What you've really done is you've purged the right to the vote from almost all of those who need it most."
Former chief election commissioner SY Quraishi, who served from 2010 to 2012, said: "Normally voters choose the government, here the government was choosing the voters." He and other critics accuse the current election commission, led by chief commissioner Gyanesh Kumar, of being partisan to the BJP.
The election commission has said it works with "complete integrity" and that officers would help those deleted to be reinstated. Sunil Kumar, a senior election official in the constituency of Chandi Chowk, told NPR his department was working to get Kanchan's community back onto the lists.
For those like Malika, a Muslim widow in Mustafabad, the deletion threatens more than voting rights. She fears being accused of being an illegal migrant, a concern amplified by Interior Minister Amit Shah, who said the revision would help detect, delete, and deport infiltrators, a term often used to target Muslims from Bangladesh. Malika lost her voter ID after moving two hours away following communal violence that killed her husband. She said no election officer ever visited her new home. "They like to sit in their air-conditioned offices and make certain rules," she said. "But they really need to come to the ground."