Inquest into Russell Island house fire to probe domestic violence claims and faulty smoke alarms

Mother had flagged improperly installed smoke alarms before blaze killed father and five sons, court hears

edit
By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources8 outlets
A coronial inquest will examine whether domestic violence contributed to a house fire that killed a man and his five sons on Russell Island in 2023, and why the home's smoke alarms did not sound, after triple-zero callers alleged frequent fighting at the property and the mother reported faulty alarms to the landlord.

The inquest into the deaths of Wayne Godinet Jr, 34, and his five sons—Zackary, 11, Harrison, 10, four-year-old twins Kyza and Koah, and three-year-old Nickolas—is set to begin in Brisbane in November. The six died of smoke inhalation when their Russell Island home caught fire in the early hours of August 2023. The children's mother, Samantha Stephenson, and her sister escaped unharmed.

At a preliminary hearing on Tuesday, counsel assisting the coroner, Corinne Leach, told the court that triple-zero callers had reported hearing frequent fighting and screaming from the home. One caller claimed "there was domestic violence in there all the time," while another said "we knew that one day they would kill these kids, but nobody has done anything." The court heard 20 calls were made to the Queensland Fire Department, and those callers will be called to give evidence. Ms Leach stated that whether domestic violence contributed to the fire would be explored at the inquest.

Separately, Deputy State Coroner Donald MacKenzie heard that the landlord had been repeatedly warned about improperly installed smoke alarms. Witnesses reported they did not hear any smoke alarms during the fire. Ms Stephenson had previously flagged the faulty alarms to the landlord, according to the court.

Ms Stephenson told investigators that she and Mr Godinet Jr had been sleeping in a makeshift entertainment area under the house the night before the fire. She recalled waking to black smoke, seeing Mr Godinet Jr run up a burning internal staircase, and then flames near a generator and workbench. She escaped outside and saw the external stairs on fire. Her sister jumped from the verandah on her instruction, but Mr Godinet Jr and the children did not emerge.

The inquest will also examine the circumstances of the fire's ignition and the adequacy of safety measures at the property.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The inquest will determine whether systemic failures—domestic violence reporting, landlord-tenant safety obligations, and fire alarm enforcement—contributed to Australia's deadliest house fire in recent years.
  • The case underscores gaps in how domestic violence concerns raised by neighbours are acted upon, and puts pressure on Queensland's rental safety regulations.
  • The outcome could influence policy changes around smoke alarm compliance and mandatory reporting of family violence.

Background

The fire occurred on Russell Island, a semi-rural community in southern Moreton Bay, approximately 45 kilometres east of Brisbane. The property was a rental home. Queensland law requires landlords to ensure smoke alarms are installed and maintained—a requirement that appears to have been unmet here. The inquest will be the first full public examination of the tragedy, nearly three years after the deaths.

Key Perspectives

Samantha Stephenson and the children's family: The mother survived the fire and has reportedly said she flagged the faulty smoke alarms. The family seeks answers about why no alarms worked and whether more could have been done to prevent the fire. The landlord: Accused of ignoring repeated warnings about improperly installed smoke alarms. The inquest will examine legal responsibilities for rental property safety. Neighbours and community: Multiple triple-zero callers reported domestic violence at the home, claiming authorities had been notified before. They argue that warnings were ignored, contributing to the tragedy.

What to Watch

  • Whether the inquest identifies specific failures by police or child safety services to act on domestic violence reports.
  • The landlord's defence regarding smoke alarm installation and maintenance.
  • Any recommendations for tightening Queensland's residential tenancy fire safety laws.

Sources

newspaper

Zotpaper

Articles published under the Zotpaper byline are synthesized from multiple source publications by our AI editor and reviewed by our editorial process. Each story combines reporting from credible outlets to give readers a balanced, comprehensive view.