Inquiry told 'blue code of silence' deters reporting of police sexual violence in Tasmania

Advocates say victims fear retaliation and believe police protect their own

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
A Tasmanian parliamentary inquiry has heard that a 'blue code of silence' is discouraging victims from reporting sexual violence committed by police officers, with advocates warning that the close-knit nature of the state's police force creates conflicts of interest in investigations.

The inquiry into Tasmania Police's responses to allegations of officer misconduct heard evidence from sexual assault and family violence advocates on Thursday.

Policy officer Elise Whitmore from Laurel House, a community sexual assault support service, told the inquiry that victim-survivors were concerned about the 'interconnected relationships' that police had with each other, both inside and outside work.

'Their concerns were not only that they wouldn't be believed, but that there may be retaliation from police in relation to other aspects of their life,' she said.

Laurel House advocacy manager Kaity Graham said there was a perceived culture of police banding together to protect their own, which Laurel House called a 'blue code of silence'.

'When the alleged perpetrator is a police officer, the response must address the power, relationships and conflict of interest that can affect a victim-survivor's confidence in coming forward,' she said.

Bree Klerck, chief executive officer of the Tasmanian Family and Sexual Violence Alliance (TFSVA), agreed, noting that Tasmania is a small and deeply networked jurisdiction.

'In this context it is difficult for Tasmania Police to investigate serious allegations involving its own officers,' she said.

Multiple members of the inquiry raised the ongoing impacts of the actions of paedophile police officer Paul Reynolds, who died by suicide in 2018 while being investigated for multiple child sexual abuse offences and was given a full police funeral with honour guard in Launceston.

Nicole Asquith, a policy and research officer at TFSVA, said the subsequent Weiss Report focused on sexual violence but did not properly address family violence, which she called 'the bigger elephant in the room'.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Victim-survivors may be reluctant to report sexual violence by police, undermining public trust in law enforcement.
  • The 'blue code of silence' can allow misconduct to go unaddressed, potentially leaving perpetrators in positions of power.
  • The inquiry's findings could lead to reforms in how Tasmania Police handles internal allegations.

Background

Tasmania is a small state with a closely networked police force. Previous scandals, such as the case of paedophile officer Paul Reynolds, have raised concerns about internal investigations and the handling of misconduct allegations. The current parliamentary inquiry is examining Tasmania Police's responses to officer misconduct, including sexual and family violence.

Key Perspectives

Victim-survivor advocates (Laurel House): They argue that the interconnected relationships among police officers create a conflict of interest, leading to fears of not being believed and potential retaliation. They call for independent oversight. Tasmanian Family and Sexual Violence Alliance (TFSVA): The Alliance highlights the difficulty of investigating officers within a small jurisdiction and notes that family violence, a common issue, was overlooked in the Weiss Report. Critics/skeptics: No police representatives have yet been heard in the inquiry, but past cases suggest internal processes may not adequately address such complaints.

What to Watch

  • Whether the inquiry recommends an independent body to investigate police misconduct.
  • Any changes to Tasmania Police's internal reporting and investigation procedures.
  • The response from police leadership and the state government to the evidence presented.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.