John Fetterman, the Democratic senator from Pennsylvania who has provoked anger within his party by increasingly siding with Republicans, is to be challenged by Ahmed Moor, a democratic socialist writer and journalist born in Gaza, who said he would run for the 2028 Democratic nomination.
Moor, 42, who was born in the southern Gaza city of Rafah and has previously written for the Guardian, told the Philadelphia Inquirer that he was “not really running against Fetterman”. “I’m running for good government. I’m running for the rule of law. I’m running because I believe in America,” he said.
His Palestinian background directly challenges Fetterman’s vocal pro-Israel stance, which has become increasingly strident since the 7 October 2023 attack by Hamas that left about 1,200 people on the Israeli side dead. More than 74,000 Palestinians in Gaza, most women and children, were killed in Israel’s retaliatory military response.
The move is the first sign of Fetterman’s weakened position in the party since Democrats won back control of the Senate in last week’s US midterm elections, when the party won at least 54 of the upper chamber’s 100 seats. The prospect of a comfortable Senate majority in effect eliminates the possibility of Fetterman’s vote being decisive, a relief to Democrat strategists who feared he could no longer be relied on for support on contentious issues.
Fetterman had already caused widespread disillusionment among many Pennsylvania Democrats, who campaigned for him in the 2022 midterms when he ran as a progressive outsider. He has sparked anger by, on occasion, speaking out in support of Donald Trump, who has praised Fetterman as “a great guy” and said he would “love” him to become a Republican.
Fetterman has said he has no intention of leaving the Democrats but strongly suggested he would change his mind if the party became “anti-Israel”. “That’s my red line,” Fetterman said last July. “If the Democratic party becomes official anti-Israel, then that’s when I would force me out. If they make it the official platform of the party, then that’s a much different situation.”
Moor, by contrast, said he supports withdrawing US aid from Israel and imposing sanctions aimed at securing equal rights for Palestinians.
Democrats say Moor is unlikely to be the only challenger. “I’m pretty confident that you’ll see some bigger, mainstream kind of names, involved,” said Mike Weidinger, a veteran Lancaster county Democrat, who cited Chris Deluzio, a representative from the Pittsburgh area, and Malcolm Kenyatta, a Pennsylvania state legislator, as likely challengers. “Generally people think [Fetterman] either misrepresented himself when he ran the first time, or he changed completely from what he said he was,” said Weidinger. On the possibility of Fetterman joining the Republicans, he added: “If he wants to switch, he can switch. If it would have been 51 to 49, it would have mattered. But it doesn’t matter now.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The primary challenge underscores the deep fracture within the Democratic Party over Israel policy and the direction of the party.
- Fetterman's weakened position within his own party, despite Democrats' Senate majority, signals potential shifts in coalition politics ahead of 2028.
- The candidacy of a Palestinian American born in Gaza injects a personal dimension into a national debate over US aid to Israel.
Background
Fetterman was elected in 2022 as a progressive outsider, but has since shifted rightward on several issues, drawing praise from Donald Trump and criticism from fellow Democrats. His strongly pro-Israel stance and occasional alignment with Republicans have alienated many of his original supporters. Ahmed Moor is a writer and journalist who previously wrote for the Guardian.
Key Perspectives
Ahmed Moor (Democratic primary challenger): Says he is running “for good government” and “for the rule of law” and supports withdrawing US aid from Israel and imposing sanctions for equal rights for Palestinians.
John Fetterman (incumbent senator): Has said leaving the Democrats would require the party to become “anti-Israel”, calling that his “red line”.
Mike Weidinger (Lancaster county Democrat): Says many Democrats think Fetterman “either misrepresented himself when he ran the first time, or he changed completely” and that a comfortable Senate majority means a party switch “doesn’t matter now”.
What to Watch
- Whether other high-profile Democrats, such as Chris Deluzio or Malcolm Kenyatta, enter the primary.
- Fetterman's future voting record and any shift in his party affiliation or rhetoric.
- The role of the Israel-Gaza issue in the 2028 Senate primary and its impact on national Democratic strategy.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedAhmed Moor, a Palestinian American, will challenge John Fetterman for the Democratic nomination in a primary.World news | The Guardian: “Ahmed Moor, a Palestinian American, said he would run in a primary to be the Democratic nominee in 2028, when Fetterman’s seat is up for re-election.”
- SupportedFetterman has provoked anger within his party by increasingly siding with Republicans.World news | The Guardian: “John Fetterman, the maverick Democratic senator who has provoked widespread anger by increasingly siding with Republicans”
- SupportedMoor said he would run for the 2028 Democratic nomination.World news | The Guardian: “Ahmed Moor, a Palestinian American, said he would run in a primary to be the Democratic nominee in 2028”
- SupportedMoor told the Philadelphia Inquirer he was “not really running against Fetterman”.World news | The Guardian: “told the Philadelphia Inquirer that he was “not really running against Fetterman”.”
- SupportedMoor said: “I’m running for good government. I’m running for the rule of law. I’m running because I believe in America”.World news | The Guardian: ““I’m running for good government. I’m running for the rule of law. I’m running because I believe in America,” he said.”
- SupportedTrump praised Fetterman as “a great guy” and said he would “love” him to become a Republican.World news | The Guardian: “Donald Trump, who in turn has praised Fetterman as “a great guy” and said he would “love” him to become a Republican.”
- SupportedIn last week’s midterm elections, Democrats won back Senate control with at least 54 of the chamber’s 100 seats.World news | The Guardian: “the Democrats won back control of the Senate in last week’s US midterm elections, when the party won at least 54 of the upper chamber’s 100 seats.”
- SupportedThe Hamas attack on 7 October 2023 left about 1,200 people on the Israeli side dead.World news | The Guardian: “the 7 October 2023 attack by Hamas that left about 1,200 people on the Israeli side dead.”
- SupportedMore than 74,000 Palestinians in Gaza were killed in Israel’s retaliatory military response, most of them women and children.World news | The Guardian: “More than 74,000 Palestinians in Gaza – most women and children – were killed in Israel’s retaliatory military response.”
- SupportedFetterman said last July that he would leave the party if it adopted an official anti-Israel position.World news | The Guardian: ““That’s my red line,” Fetterman said last July. “If the Democratic party becomes official anti-Israel, then that’s when I would force me out. If they make it the official platform of the party, then that’s a much different situation.””
- SupportedWeidinger said he was confident bigger, mainstream names would challenge Fetterman and cited Chris Deluzio and Malcolm Kenyatta as likely challengers.World news | The Guardian: ““I’m pretty confident that you’ll see some bigger, mainstream kind of names, involved,” said Mike Weidinger, a veteran Lancaster county Democrat with state-wide connections, who cited Chris Deluzio, a representative from the Pittsburgh area, and Malcolm Kenyatta, a Pennsylvania state legislator, as likely challengers.”
- SupportedWeidinger said people generally thought Fetterman had misrepresented himself or changed completely from what he had said he was.World news | The Guardian: ““Generally people think [Fetterman] either misrepresented himself when he ran the first time, or he changed completely from what he said he was,” said Weidinger.”