A federal judge has blocked the Trump administration's plan to cap student-loan borrowing for certain advanced degrees, ruling that the Department of Education exceeded its authority. The judge said students and colleges would face 'imminent' harm from the proposed caps, which were set to take effect July 1.
The ruling by U.S. District Judge Michael Simon in Oregon is the third court decision to block the department’s plan from taking effect. The department had planned to limit the list of professional programs qualifying for a $200,000 lifetime borrowing cap to 11 fields, including medicine and dentistry, while capping others at $100,000. Lawmakers and advocates had criticized the exclusion of programs like nursing and social work.
The case before Simon involved naturopathic medicine, which was excluded from the professional list. The plaintiffs, including colleges and students in naturopathy, said the exclusion risked pushing students into higher-interest private loans. Naturopathy associations said the caps could harm revenue if students chose not to enroll.
At the end of June, after a separate court decision blocked the department’s narrowed definition, it released an updated list of 30 programs that would qualify for the higher cap as litigation continues. The department said at the time it was confident its narrowed definition was lawful and would continue to defend it. It also advised students to check with their schools about how the ruling affects them.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The outcome affects whether graduate and professional students can access federal loans sufficient to cover their costs without turning to private lenders.
- Students in fields excluded from the professional list, such as naturopathic medicine, face higher borrowing costs and limited access to loan forgiveness.
- The repeated court blocks signal a broader legal challenge to the administration's authority to unilaterally reshape student-loan limits.
Background
The Trump administration sought to tighten borrowing limits on advanced-degree programs, arguing that high borrowing levels contribute to student debt. Advocacy groups and some colleges opposed the move, saying it would hurt students in fields not deemed 'professional' by the department. The department initially listed 11 programs for the higher cap, later expanded to 30 after earlier court orders.
Key Perspectives
Judge Michael Simon: The department exceeded its authority, and the caps would cause imminent harm to students and schools.
Education Department: The narrowed definition is lawful and the agency will continue to defend it in court.
What to Watch
- Further court rulings on similar challenges from other fields.
- Whether the department revises its list of qualifying programs or appeals.
- Impact on enrollment and tuition decisions at programs excluded from the higher borrowing limit.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedA judge blocked the Trump administration’s plan to cap borrowing for advanced degrees.All Content from Business Insider: “A federal judge recently ruled that Trump's plan to cap borrowing for professional degrees was an overreach.”
- SupportedThe judge said students and colleges would face “imminent” harm.All Content from Business Insider: “The judge said that students and colleges would face "imminent" harm and revenue loss from the caps.”
- SupportedJudge Michael Simon ruled that the Department of Education exceeded its authority.All Content from Business Insider: “US District Judge Michael Simon ruled that the Department of Education exceeded its authority when it intended to restrict access to federal lending for certain professional degrees.”
- SupportedIt was the third ruling blocking the department’s plan from taking effect.All Content from Business Insider: “It's the third ruling by a federal judge blocking the department's plan from taking effect.”
- SupportedThe proposed rule was set to take effect July 1.All Content from Business Insider: “The department had planned to implement a new rule on July 1”
- SupportedThe plan would limit the higher borrowing cap to 11 professional programs, with a $200,000 lifetime cap for those programs and a $100,000 cap for other advanced programs.All Content from Business Insider: “Only these programs would qualify for a $200,000 lifetime borrowing cap, while other advanced programs would receive a $100,000 lifetime cap.”
- SupportedLawmakers and advocates pushed back against excluding programs such as nursing and social work.All Content from Business Insider: “The department's proposed list of professional degrees sparked pushback from lawmakers and advocates”
- SupportedSimon’s ruling ordered the department to qualify naturopathic medicine for the higher borrowing limit.All Content from Business Insider: “He placed a preliminary injunction on the department's proposed definition of "professional" and ordered it to qualify naturopathic medicine for the higher borrowing limit.”
- SupportedThe plaintiffs said excluding naturopathic medicine risked pushing students into higher-interest private loans.All Content from Business Insider: “The plaintiffs, including colleges and students in naturopathy, said that the department's decision to exclude the field from the professional degree list risked pushing students into private student loans, which often have higher interest rates”
- SupportedNaturopathy associations said the caps could harm revenue if students chose not to enroll.All Content from Business Insider: “naturopathy associations said the caps could harm revenue should students choose not to enroll due to the borrowing caps.”
- SupportedAfter a separate court decision at the end of June blocked the narrowed definition, the department released an updated list of 30 programs eligible for the higher limit.All Content from Business Insider: “At the end of June, a separate court decision blocked the department's narrowed definition of a professional degree from taking effect. As a result of that ruling, the department released an updated list of 30 programs that would qualify for a higher borrowing limit”
- SupportedThe department advised students to check with their schools about how the ruling affects them.All Content from Business Insider: “The department wrote in a notice on Federal Student Aid that it encourages students to contact their school to see how the court ruling affects them.”