The California Commission on Judicial Performance has removed Robert Draper, an 84-year-old Los Angeles County Superior Court judge, from the bench after finding he engaged in 17 instances of behavior that made him no longer fit for office, including offensive comments, abusive emails, and defiance of court orders.
The commission concluded Tuesday in an 87-page decision, following a yearslong investigation into Draper’s conduct. He had not heard a case since 2023 because of the issues.
“Judge Draper persistently violated the standards governing judicial behavior and engaged in extensive and severe misconduct,” the commission said in a statement, adding that the misconduct was “aggravated by his refusal to accept responsibility for his misconduct, and his lack of insight or remorse for his misconduct and its effect on others.”
Draper lost reelection earlier this year after serving 14 years on the bench. He previously admitted to some claims and denied others in interviews with LAist. In a statement this week, he called the decision “deeply disappointing.” He said the investigation came when he raised concerns within the judiciary and was used “presumably for purposes of dismissing his dissent by discrediting him.” He plans to pursue “other avenues” to change the system, according to the statement. His attorney declined to share what those would be.
According to the commission, Draper’s misconduct included making “offensive” and “insensitive” comments in court about race and gender; sending “abusive” emails and unnecessary graphic pictures of his naked backside to colleagues; and acting with “deliberate defiance of his presiding judge’s orders” by continuing to access court systems and work on cases while on involuntary leave. Some allegations, including one that he inappropriately touched an attorney’s hair, were dismissed for lack of evidence.
Laurie Levenson, a professor at Loyola Law School, said removal is “the ultimate sanction against a judge.” Draper’s seat is now empty sooner than usual, with judge-elect Tal Khan Valbuena on deck to replace him in January. Gov. Gavin Newsom may appoint Valbuena sooner, or the court could move another judge into the department.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Judicial removal is extremely rare in California, making this case a significant check on judicial power.
- The misconduct, including racial and gender insensitivity, undermines public trust in the court system.
- Draper’s refusal to acknowledge wrongdoing means the commission’s ruling stands as a statement on judicial accountability.
Background
Draper served 14 years on the Los Angeles County Superior Court before losing his reelection bid. The California Commission on Judicial Performance is the state’s disciplinary body for judges; removal is its harshest penalty. Since 1995, only 15 judges have been removed, and the last L.A. County Superior Court judge removal occurred in 2006.
Key Perspectives
California Commission on Judicial Performance: stated Draper “persistently violated the standards governing judicial behavior” and his misconduct was aggravated by lack of remorse.
Robert Draper: called the decision “deeply disappointing” and suggested the investigation was a response to his internal dissent and aimed at discrediting him.
Laurie Levenson (Loyola Law School professor): described removal as “the ultimate sanction against a judge.”
What to Watch
- Whether Gov. Gavin Newsom appoints judge-elect Tal Khan Valbuena before January, affecting court operations.
- Any further “avenues” Draper may pursue to challenge the system, as indicated in his statement.
- How the court fills the vacant department in the interim.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says Robert Draper was removed from the bench for severe misconduct.LAist: “the state’s judicial watchdog has removed Judge Robert Draper, 84, from the Los Angeles County Superior Court”
- SupportedDraper had served 14 years on the bench.LAist: “removed Judge Robert Draper, 84, from the Los Angeles County Superior Court after 14 years of service.”
- SupportedDraper was 84 years old.LAist: “removed Judge Robert Draper, 84, from the Los Angeles County Superior Court”
- SupportedThe commission had removed 15 judges since gaining that authority in 1995.LAist: “The commission has only removed 15 judges since it gained the authority to do so in 1995, according to its records”
- SupportedDraper was the first L.A. County Superior Court judge removed since 2006.LAist: “with the last for an L.A. County Superior Court judge happening in 2006.”
- SupportedThe commission found 17 instances of behavior that made Draper no longer fit for office.LAist: “Draper engaged in 17 instances of behavior that made him no longer fit for office.”
- SupportedThe commission said Draper persistently violated judicial behavior standards and engaged in extensive and severe misconduct.LAist: ““Judge Draper persistently violated the standards governing judicial behavior and engaged in extensive and severe misconduct,” the commission said in a statement”
- SupportedDraper had not heard a case since 2023 because of the issues.LAist: “He hasn’t heard a case since 2023 because of the issues.”
- SupportedDraper called the decision “deeply disappointing.”LAist: “In a statement this week, he called the decision “deeply disappointing.””
- SupportedDraper said the investigation was used “presumably for purposes of dismissing his dissent by discrediting him.”LAist: “it was used “presumably for purposes of dismissing his dissent by discrediting him.””
- SupportedThe commission said Draper sent abusive emails and unnecessary graphic pictures of his naked backside to colleagues.LAist: “Sending “abusive” emails and unnecessary graphic pictures of his naked backside to colleagues.”
- SupportedAn allegation that Draper inappropriately touched an attorney’s hair was dismissed for lack of evidence.LAist: “Some allegations the commission reviewed were dismissed for lack of evidence, including one that he inappropriately touched an attorney’s hair.”