The Albanese government has ruled out antisemitism envoy Jillian Segal's proposal to scrap the ABC and SBS ombudsmen in favour of an external independent oversight body, with government sources pointing to the Australian Communications and Media Authority (Acma) as an existing external regulator. Labor could still consider changes in response to the final report of the royal commission into antisemitism, which is scheduled for mid-December.
Segal, in updated priorities released last month, proposed an “external independent ombudsman” to monitor ABC and SBS coverage of the war in Gaza and to ensure the publicly funded broadcasters were “held accountable to their own stated standards of accuracy and impartiality”. She said the government should consider “transferring” responsibilities from the existing ombudsmen to an “external independent ombudsman consistent with other sectors such as telecommunications and banking”.
"Many in the Jewish community remain concerned that coverage they perceive as one-directional may contribute to a negative – and even hostile – view by audiences of those who support Israel, or have sympathy for it," Segal said in her updated plan.
The ABC said at the time its complaints process was "the most robust and transparent in the Australian media", and both broadcasters said they were subject to external review by Acma. This week, government sources noted Acma already acted as an external independent regulator that could investigate complaints if they needed to be escalated beyond the ABC and SBS ombudsmen.
A spokesperson for the federal communications minister, Anika Wells, thanked Segal for her work and said there was no place for antisemitism in Australia. It was an evil "that tears at the fabric of our country … [and] puts the peaceful, free and equal society we cherish at risk", they said. The spokesperson said the government would soon receive the final report from the Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion and would continue to work with the special envoy, the Jewish community and all Australians to combat antisemitism. It is understood Labor could consider changes in response to the commission's recommendations; the commission, headed by former high court judge Virginia Bell, was established after the antisemitic Bondi beach massacre in December 2025.
Segal's suggestion received a mixed response a fortnight ago. Alex Ryvchin, the co-chief executive of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, welcomed the proposal, saying meaningful oversight of coverage by public broadcasters could only be achieved "through external accountability". But the Progressive Jewish Council of Australia criticised the plan as "Trumpian", arguing it threatened freedom of speech and democratic rights. The Australian Palestine Advocacy Network criticised attempts to conflate legitimate criticism of Israel with antisemitism, stating: "Speaking out against Israel's ongoing atrocities is the prerogative of anyone who believes in human dignity and human rights."
Segal wrote in October that the "independence of public broadcasters must, of course, be protected", but that independence "does not – and should not – amount to a right to be free from external scrutiny and empirical review". In her first report in mid-2025, she proposed giving the special envoy powers to monitor media organisations to encourage "accurate, fair and responsible reporting". She told the royal commission into antisemitism in mid-2026 she wanted a new "oversight" committee that could give ABC and SBS coverage a "tick" or "guidance", and told Senate estimates this week she was concerned about "the tone [and] the frequency of reporting about Gaza from the ABC".
ABC Alumni, which represents hundreds of former staff, said that since October 2023 the ABC ombudsman has upheld four out of thousands of complaints of bias or inaccuracy relating to Middle East coverage. Acma, "to which dissatisfied complainants can appeal, has upheld none", the group said, adding it was "outraged at the continued insistence by Jillian Segal … that the ABC and SBS, Australia's most trusted news outlets, are contributing to antisemitism".
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The rejection leaves the existing ABC and SBS complaints process in place, but the royal commission's report in mid-December could still lead to changes in how coverage of the Gaza war is overseen.
- The episode underscores how the Gaza conflict continues to fuel debate in Australia over media impartiality, free speech and antisemitism.
- The government's careful response, welcoming Segal's work while declining her specific proposal, shows the limits of the envoy's influence over media policy.
Background
The Royal Commission into Antisemitism and Social Cohesion, headed by former high court judge Virginia Bell, was established after the antisemitic Bondi beach massacre in December 2025 and is due to report in mid-December. Segal, appointed as the special envoy, released her first plan to combat antisemitism in mid-2025, proposing monitoring powers over media organisations. Her updated priorities, released last month, included the proposal to replace the ABC and SBS ombudsmen with an external independent ombudsman. Public complaints about ABC and SBS coverage are currently handled by each broadcaster's ombudsman, with appeals to the Australian Communications and Media Authority.
Key Perspectives
- Government (Anika Wells' spokesperson): thanks Segal for her work and says there is no place for antisemitism in Australia; government sources say Acma already provides external independent review of the broadcasters.
- Jillian Segal: argues an external independent ombudsman would hold the ABC and SBS to their own stated standards of accuracy and impartiality, citing community concerns about coverage of the Gaza war.
- ABC and SBS: defend their complaints processes, with the ABC calling its own "the most robust and transparent in the Australian media" and both noting they are subject to Acma review.
- Executive Council of Australian Jewry (Alex Ryvchin): welcomes Segal's suggestion, saying meaningful oversight requires "external accountability".
- Progressive Jewish Council of Australia: criticises the plan as "Trumpian", arguing it threatens freedom of speech and democratic rights.
- Australian Palestine Advocacy Network: criticises attempts to conflate criticism of Israel with antisemitism, saying speaking out against Israel's "ongoing atrocities" is the prerogative of anyone who believes in human dignity and human rights.
- ABC Alumni: says the ABC ombudsman has upheld four of thousands of complaints about Middle East coverage, Acma has upheld none, and the group is "outraged" at claims the broadcasters contribute to antisemitism.
What to Watch
- The royal commission's final report, expected in mid-December, and whether the government adopts any of its recommendations on media oversight.
- Whether Segal's proposal is revived in parliament or by the commission, and how the broadcasters respond.
- Any further data on complaints about Middle East coverage from the ABC ombudsman or Acma, which could shape the debate.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe Albanese government has ruled out replacing the ABC and SBS ombudsmen with an external body, as proposed by Jillian Segal.Australia news | The Guardian: “The Albanese government won’t follow a suggestion by the antisemitism envoy to scrap the ABC and SBS ombudsmen and replace them with an external oversight body.”
- SupportedGovernment sources pointed to ACMA as an existing external independent regulator that could investigate complaints escalated beyond the ABC and SBS ombudsmen.Australia news | The Guardian: “This week, government sources noted that Acma already acted as an external independent regulator that could investigate complaints if they needed to be escalated beyond the ABC and SBS ombudsmen.”
- SupportedThe royal commission’s final report is scheduled for mid-December.Australia news | The Guardian: “It is understood Labor could consider changes in response to recommendations from the royal commission into antisemitism that is scheduled to report in mid-December.”
- SupportedLabor could consider changes in response to the royal commission’s recommendations.Australia news | The Guardian: “It is understood Labor could consider changes in response to recommendations from the royal commission into antisemitism”
- SupportedSegal said many in the Jewish community remained concerned that coverage they perceived as one-directional might contribute to negative or hostile views of people who support or sympathise with Israel.Australia news | The Guardian: ““Many in the Jewish community remain concerned that coverage they perceive as one-directional may contribute to a negative – and even hostile – view by audiences of those who support Israel, or have sympathy for it,” Segal said”
- SupportedThe ABC described its complaints process as “the most robust and transparent in the Australian media”.Australia news | The Guardian: “The ABC said at the time its complaints process was “the most robust and transparent in the Australian media””
- SupportedThe federal communications minister’s spokesperson said antisemitism was an evil “that tears at the fabric of our country … [and] puts the peaceful, free and equal society we cherish at risk”.Australia news | The Guardian: “It was an evil “that tears at the fabric of our country … [and] puts the peaceful, free and equal society we cherish at risk”, they said.”
- SupportedThe commission was headed by former High Court judge Virginia Bell and was established after the Bondi beach massacre in December 2025.Australia news | The Guardian: “The commission, headed by former high court judge Virginia Bell, was established after the antisemitic Bondi beach massacre in December 2025.”
- SupportedAlex Ryvchin said meaningful oversight of public broadcasters’ coverage could only be achieved “through external accountability”.Australia news | The Guardian: “Alex Ryvchin, the co-chief executive of the Executive Council of Australian Jewry, welcomed Segal’s suggestions, warning meaningful oversight of coverage by public broadcasters could only be achieved “through external accountability”.”
- SupportedThe Progressive Jewish Council of Australia criticised Segal’s plan as “Trumpian”, arguing that it threatened freedom of speech and democratic rights.Australia news | The Guardian: “But the progressive Jewish Council of Australia criticised the envoy’s new plan as “Trumpian”, arguing it threatened freedom of speech and democratic rights.”
- SupportedThe Australian Palestine Advocacy Network said: “Speaking out against Israel's ongoing atrocities is the prerogative of anyone who believes in human dignity and human rights.”Australia news | The Guardian: “The Australian Palestine Advocacy Network criticised attempts to conflate legitimate criticism of Israel with antisemitism and stated: “Speaking out against Israel’s ongoing atrocities is the prerogative of anyone who believes in human dignity and human rights.””
- SupportedABC Alumni said the ABC ombudsman had upheld four out of thousands of complaints about bias or inaccuracy in Middle East coverage since October 2023, while ACMA had upheld none.Australia news | The Guardian: “ABC Alumni, which represents hundreds of former staff, has said that since October 2023 the ABC ombudsman has upheld four out of thousands of complaints of bias or inaccuracy relating to Middle East coverage. Acma, “to which dissatisfied complainants can appeal, has upheld none””