Labuschagne's dismissal exposes wind gap as Test place under threat

South Africa captain speaks of pressure of being world No.1 as series heads to decider in Cape Town

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
Sources4 outlets
Marnus Labuschagne's Test place is under intense scrutiny after he was dismissed in Gqeberha by a wind-assisted catch, the kind of local knowledge that only the St George's Park ground can offer. SouthAfrica captain Temba Bavuma and spinner Simon Harmer both noted how the narrow gap between two stands funnelled the breeze, holding up Labuschagne's lofted shot to hand Marco Jansen a simple catch. The dismissal leaves the series locked at 1-1 with the final Test starting in Cape Town on Tuesday, and Australian selectors pondering changes to a batting order that has repeatedly failed to convert starts into big scores.

The moment came on the fourth afternoon of the second Test. Labuschagne had built a partnership with Travis Head and survived a tight lbw review when he faced off-spinner Simon Harmer. Harmer, an Eastern Province local who has played many times at St George's Park, recognised that the gap between the western stand and the Duck Pond End terrace was a trap for airborne shots. With Marco Jansen stationed at deepish mid-on, he tossed the ball higher and dared the shot.

"I don't know what he was thinking," Harmer said with a laugh. "Obviously I've played a lot of cricket at St George's Park and it funnels through that corner ... a lot of times you think you've got enough of it, but it just gets held up in the wind."

Bavuma, who made a sublime 179 to rescue his side from 6-110, spoke with empathy about Labuschagne's run of handy but insubstantial scores. "I think I'm probably the last person to speak ... he's doing all the hard work," Bavuma said. "From what I've learned, it's more a mental thing, and I think only he will know what's happening in his head."

The South African captain also acknowledged that his team had been more aggressive in Gqeberha. "We were just probably just looking at things a lot more internally ... part of it is being aggressive in situations," he said. "There's obviously certain individuals within the team who enjoy a little argy bargy, and I mean, you allow those guys to go about doing that within the rules."

Bavuma said the Proteas had embraced the target of being world No.1 after losing the first Test in Durban. "I think sometimes, as a team, we forget that the target is on our back," he said. "We've definitely strengthened that by being able to perform like that from a pressure point of view."

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Labuschagne's place in Australia's Test XI is at risk if he cannot convert starts into centuries, creating a selection headache for the Cape Town decider.
  • The series, locked at 1-1, will decide the winner of the two-Test contest and affects both teams' standing in the World Test Championshipn- Australia's batting order has been heavily dependent on a few players; losing Labuschagne would force a change in composition

Background

Labuschagne has been a mainstay of Australia's Test batting since his emergence in 2019, but his recent form has been marked by a series of scores in the 30s and 40s without going on to a big innings. The second Test in Gqeberha saw Australia's batting again fail to set a challenging target, leaving the match to South Africa. The series is now a decider in Cape Town, where the pitch is expected to assist pace and bounce. Selectors have several options: retaining Labuschagne, promoting a spare batter, or altering the balance of the XI.

Key Perspectives

[Marnus Labuschagne]: The batter is aware of his form slump, having talked about the mental battle to get past the 30-40 mark. He spent extra time in the nets before Cape Town. [Australian selectors]: They must decide whether to persist with Labuschagne or make a change, knowing that another failure could deepen the batting crisis. [South Africa]: Captain Bavuma has spoken of embracing the pressure of being world No.1, while Harmer's use of local conditions shows the value of home-ground knowledge.

What to Watch

  • The Cape Town pitch report and how it might favour pace or spin.
  • Labuschagne's batting in the first innings of the third Test; another low score could force the selectors' hand.
  • Whether South Africa's aggression continues or Australia's bowlers can strike early to put the hosts under pressure.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedLabuschagne’s wind-affected dismissal puts his Test place under threat.The Age - Latest News: “A narrow gap between two grandstands at St George’s Park is the margin by which Marnus Labuschagne finds himself on the edge of losing his Test place”
  2. SupportedBavuma spoke about pressure on South Africa as world No.1 while the series headed to a Cape Town decider.The Age - Latest News: “Proteas captain Temba Bavuma has flagged the importance of his team embracing the title of world No.1”
  3. Not in the sourcesThe ground offered local knowledge that only St George’s Park could provide.
  4. Partly supportedBoth Bavuma and Harmer said the gap between the stands funnelled the breeze.The Age - Latest News: “Harmer recognised the gap between those two stands as a source of pushback for airborne shots.”
  5. SupportedThe breeze held up Labuschagne’s shot and Jansen caught it.The Age - Latest News: ““It held it, and you probably had the guy with the safest hands in the team; Marco Jansen, to catch it.””
  6. Partly supportedSelectors were pondering changes to a batting order that had repeatedly failed to turn starts into big scores.The Age - Latest News: “the Australian selectors ponder their options with the series locked at 1-1”
  7. SupportedHarmer said, “I don't know what he was thinking,” with a laugh.The Age - Latest News: ““I don’t know what he was thinking,” Harmer said with a laugh.”
  8. SupportedHarmer said the breeze funnelled through the corner and could hold up a shot.The Age - Latest News: ““Obviously I’ve played a lot of cricket at St George’s Park and it funnels through that corner of the old stand and the Duck Pond, and a lot of times you think you’ve got enough of it, but it just gets held up in the wind.””
  9. SupportedBavuma said Labuschagne was doing the hard work and that his difficulties were more mental.The Age - Latest News: ““I mean, he’s doing all the hard work.” “From what I’ve learned, it’s more a mental thing, and I think only he will know what’s happening in his head””
  10. SupportedBavuma said South Africa had been more aggressive in Gqeberha and described players’ “argy bargy” as within the rules.The Age - Latest News: “Bavuma acknowledged that his men had been chirpier and more aggressive in Gqeberha. “There’s obviously certain individuals within the team who enjoy a little argy bargy, and I mean, you allow those guys to go about doing that within the rules.””
  11. SupportedBavuma said South Africa sometimes forgot the target was on their backs and had strengthened through performing under pressure.The Age - Latest News: ““I think sometimes, as a team, we forget that the target is on our back””
  12. SupportedThe series was 1-1 and the final Test was due to start in Cape Town on Tuesday.The Age - Latest News: “with the series locked at 1-1 and the final Test starting in Cape Town on Tuesday.”

Zotpaper

Written by Harper Lane on the Australia & local desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

2 sources9 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe