Liberals condemn One Nation call to imprison former Victorian premiers

Senator James Paterson says performative promises have no place in a liberal democracy

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources3 outlets
One Nation's Victorian state election launch descended into controversy when party figure Mark Nicholson declared former premiers Daniel Andrews and Jacinta Allan should be in prison by Christmas. The call drew immediate condemnation from federal Liberals, who said threatening to jail political opponents is unacceptable in a liberal democracy.

At the launch at Crown on Saturday, Nicholson, who previously created cartoons labelling Liberal MP Andrew Hastie a traitor, told the crowd "heads are going to roll". "Dan Andrews, Jacinta Allan – they're going to be in prison by Christmas," he said, describing the event as "a revolution" and "a movement" to "take Victoria back".

The remarks were quickly criticised. Victorian Senator James Paterson, an ally of Opposition Leader Angus Taylor, said Victorians deserved justice for what had happened under Labor, but the best way was a royal commission, not threats to lock up opponents. "Performative promises to lock up your political opponents have no place in a liberal democracy," he said.

Meanwhile, New England MP Barnaby Joyce, who recently joined One Nation, distanced himself from the comment, telling the Seven Network that it was not Pauline Hanson who said it, and calling the Andrews and Allan administrations "disastrous for Victoria".

One Nation's social media pages have amplified the statement, posting "We're not pulling our punches in Victoria" alongside a screenshot of the "In prison by Christmas" headline. No one from the party has clarified whether the comments represent an official pledge to seek prosecutions against the former premiers.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The threat to imprison political opponents undermines the democratic norm that elections, not criminal courts, decide political outcomes.
  • It exposes a potential liability for One Nation as it tries to broaden its support in Victoria ahead of the state election.
  • The episode deepens tensions between the federal Coalition and One Nation, particularly with Coalition defector Barnaby Joyce caught in the middle.

Background

One Nation, led by Senator Pauline Hanson, launched its campaign for the upcoming Victorian state election at a function at Crown on Saturday. The party is ahead of the Coalition in national polls but trails in Victoria. Mark Nicholson, who made the prison remarks, is a prominent One Nation figure previously responsible for cartoons that labelled Liberal MP Andrew Hastie a traitor. The call to jail former premiers echoes Donald Trump's campaign rhetoric about locking up Hillary Clinton.

Key Perspectives

One Nation (via Mark Nicholson): He declared that "heads are going to roll" and that Andrews and Allan would be in prison by Christmas, framing the election as a revolution to take back Victoria. The party's social media pages have promoted the statement rather than walking it back. Federal Liberals (via Senator James Paterson): They support a royal commission into the former Labor governments but insist that locking up political opponents is a "performative promise" with no place in a liberal democracy. Barnaby Joyce: The New England MP tried to distance himself by noting the statement came from a candidate, not Pauline Hanson, while still criticising the Andrews and Allan administrations as disastrous.

What to Watch

  • Whether One Nation clarifies or formally adopts the jail threat as party policy.
  • Reaction from the Labor Party and the current Victorian Premier.
  • Any change in the Coalition's willingness to preference One Nation below Labor in Victoria.
  • Further fallout between Barnaby Joyce and his former Coalition colleagues.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.