Mars's mysterious cloud may form by 'flash-freezing' without dust particles

New study suggests the Arsia Mons Elongated Cloud is the first natural example of homogeneous nucleation

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
For decades, planetary scientists have puzzled over a thin, 1,800-kilometre-long cloud that appears every summer morning west of Mars’s Arsia Mons volcano. A new study published in Nature Geoscience proposes that the cloud forms through homogeneous nucleation, a process in which water vapour spontaneously freezes into ice without needing the dust particles that normally seed cloud formation. If confirmed, it would be the first known natural occurrence of a phenomenon long dismissed as a laboratory curiosity.

The cloud, known as the Arsia Mons Elongated Cloud (AMEC), stretches for more than a thousand kilometres each morning before dissipating within hours. Traditional atmospheric models could not reproduce its thin, bright shape, typically producing either scattered haze or no tail at all.

Researchers led by Dr. Jorge Hernández-Bernal of the Sorbonne used the Mars Planetary Climate Model to simulate conditions around Arsia Mons in summer. They found that strong westward winds hitting the 20-kilometre-high volcano create gravity waves, standing ripples in the atmosphere, that cause the air to cool by about 30°C in less than fifteen minutes, dropping below -143°C.

At that point, water vapour molecules spontaneously freeze into hundreds of ice crystals per cubic centimetre. This homogeneous nucleation requires extremely high humidity and very few dust particles. In summer the Martian atmosphere near the volcano contains only about 0.1 dust grains per cubic centimetre, compared with millions on Earth, allowing relative humidity to soar to around ten million percent.

The resulting ice particles are then carried by winds into a long, narrow tail that remains stable for hours before dispersing.

The finding opens the possibility that homogeneous nucleation may occur elsewhere in the solar system, such as in the icy plumes of Saturn’s moon Enceladus or in Earth’s polar mesosphere. For now, AMEC is the only known natural example of cloud formation without condensation nuclei.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The discovery could rewrite textbooks on cloud physics, showing that a purely theoretical process actually operates in planetary atmospheres.
  • It provides a new framework for understanding cloud formation on Mars and other worlds, potentially improving weather and climate models for Earth as well.
  • It raises the possibility that similar “dust-free” clouds exist on other bodies with sparse atmospheres, such as Titan or Venus.

Background

Clouds on Earth form when water vapour condenses onto microscopic particles called condensation nuclei, sea salt, dust, or pollution. Homogeneous nucleation, where water molecules cluster and freeze without a seed, was thought to require humidity levels far beyond anything found naturally. The Martian cloud, known since the 1970s, resisted explanation because the planet is so dusty. The new study shows that at Arsia Mons, summer winds and low dust create a unique pocket of extreme conditions that allow spontaneous ice formation.

Key Perspectives

Planetary scientists: The finding is a breakthrough, offering the first natural validation of a long-standing theoretical prediction. It also explains a decade-old puzzle about the cloud’s behaviour. Modelers and experimentalists: Some may caution that the simulation results need to be confirmed by direct observation of cloud particles, which Mars orbiters cannot currently perform. Critics/Skeptics: The study relies on models, not direct measurements of ice nuclei. The lack of in-situ data means homogeneous nucleation remains a hypothesis, albeit a strong one.

What to Watch

  • Future Mars missions carrying instruments capable of sampling cloud particles.
  • Searches for similar cloud features on other moons with tenuous atmospheres, such as Enceladus or Triton.
  • Updates to global Martian climate models to incorporate homogeneous nucleation and test predictions for other regions.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedThe Arsia Mons cloud may form by flash-freezing without dust particles.Universe Today: “the cloud could be the first documented real-world example of a cloud flash-freezing out of thin air”
  2. SupportedThe study suggests AMEC may be the first natural example of homogeneous nucleation.Universe Today: “the cloud could be the first documented real-world example of a cloud flash-freezing out of thin air”
  3. SupportedThe thin cloud is about 1,800 kilometres long and appears west of Arsia Mons every summer morning.Universe Today: “every day of every summer, an 1,800 kilometer long thin white cloud appears to the west of Arsia Mons”
  4. SupportedResearchers led by Dr. Jorge Hernández-Bernal of the Sorbonne published the study in Nature Geoscience.Universe Today: “a new paper, published in Nature Geoscience by a research team led by Dr. Jorge Hernández-Bernal of the Sorbonne”
  5. SupportedTraditional atmospheric models could not reproduce the cloud, producing haze or no tail.Universe Today: “They would either produce wide patches of haze, or no trailing tale reaching thousands of kilometers at all.”
  6. SupportedWestward winds hitting Arsia Mons generate gravity waves that cool the air by about 30°C in less than fifteen minutes.Universe Today: “there are notable westward winds that hit the shield volcano straight on, deflecting upward violently enough to generate a phenomenon called gravity waves - standing ripples in the atmosphere that represent gigantic pressure shifts. As air moves through these waves, it experiences extreme adiabatic expansion, and cools by about 30℃ in less than fifteen minutes”
  7. SupportedThe cooling takes the air below -143°C.Universe Today: “cools by about 30℃ in less than fifteen minutes, superchilling to below -143℃.”
  8. SupportedWater vapour then spontaneously freezes into hundreds of ice crystals per cubic centimetre.Universe Today: “water vapor molecules hit a physical breaking point and spontaneously freeze into hundreds of ice crystals per cubic centimeter.”
  9. Partly supportedThe Martian atmosphere near the volcano has about 0.1 dust grains per cubic centimetre, compared with millions on Earth.Universe Today: “In the summer, the Martian atmosphere is relatively dust-free, with only 0.1 dust grains per cubic centimeter.”
  10. SupportedRelative humidity near Arsia Mons can reach around ten million percent.Universe Today: “the humidity in the area skyrockets to around ten million percent.”
  11. Partly supportedWinds carry the ice particles into a long, narrow tail that remains stable for hours before dispersing.Universe Today: “That’s where the wind takes over, blowing these newly formed ice particles to travel outside of the freezing pocket and into more than a thousand mile long pencil thin tail of cloud without dissipating.”
  12. SupportedThe finding raises the possibility that homogeneous nucleation could occur on Enceladus or in Earth's polar mesosphere.Universe Today: “From the icy plumes of Enceladus to our own polar mesosphere, there are other places in the solar system that, at least in theory, could have the same absurdly high relative humidity levels with relatively low dust particle counts.”

Correction

An earlier version of this story presented an explanation from Universe Today as a direct quotation from the study. It was explanatory prose by Universe Today, not a quotation from the study.

Zotpaper

Written by Harper Lane on the Science desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub. Plate by Ollie Flash, picture desk.

1 source10 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published updated once
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe