Measles Outbreak in Pennsylvania's Amish Country Hits 1,300 Cases; Political Clash Over Vaccination Misinformation

Six dead, including two infants; health officials warn of under-reporting and low vaccination rates

By LineZotpaper AI staff

Published25 October 2026

Read Time3 min

Illustration: Measles Outbreak in Pennsylvania's Amish Country Hits 1,300 Cases; Political Clash Over Vaccination Misinformation

A measles outbreak that began in late April in rural Pennsylvania has ballooned to more than 1,300 cases, making it the state's largest spread of the disease in over three decades. At least six people have died, including two infants, and about one in five cases have resulted in hospitalisation. The outbreak has largely affected Amish communities, where low vaccination rates and scepticism of modern medicine have created a public health challenge now entangled in a political confrontation between state and federal officials.

The outbreak started west of Philadelphia and has hit Lancaster County hard, home to the nation's oldest and largest Amish settlement. The Amish, a religious group that rejects most modern technologies and government intervention, have been disproportionately affected. Five of the six victims were from Amish communities, local media reported.

Braxton Mitchell, co-director of the University of Maryland's Amish research program, said the community's highly social, large-family lifestyle creates a unique risk for rapid virus spread. 'The Amish get together with their neighbours, with their relatives; they have church services on Sundays which tend to be at somebody's house and the whole church district shows up,' he said. Professor Mitchell added that many Amish believe 'if we get sick, if God's will is that we're meant to survive, we'll survive', and are wary of government-mandated medicine.

Steve Nolt, a professor at Elizabethtown College who has lived in Lancaster County most of his life, said non-Amish residents are worried, warily monitoring transmission alerts for schools, stores and other locations where the virus has spread beyond Amish areas.

In neighbouring Chester County, which has reported 93 cases, public health director Jeanne Franklin said the reported numbers likely understate the problem. 'What we're seeing is the worst of the worst,' she told the ABC. 'Statistically speaking, we're likely going to see more deaths.' She described the Amish as 'vaccine hesitant' but said public health messaging should target everyone who chooses not to be vaccinated, regardless of background. 'Thirty years ago you may have said: Why do I need that? Measles isnt an issue. Well, guess what, its an issue.'

Health authorities have administered more than 6,000 MMR vaccines at 212 pop-up clinics in affected communities since April. The outbreak comes amid a national surge in measles: the US has recorded over 4,500 cases this year, the highest since 1991, and the CDC says vaccination rates have fallen below the 95 per cent coverage needed to prevent outbreaks.

The outbreak has sparked a political clash. Pennsylvania's Democratic Governor Josh Shapiro, who has advocated for vaccines, faced attacks from Health Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr, who suggested Mr Shapiro may have 'altogether fabricated' the deaths and accused him of 'fearmongering, misinformation, finger-pointing, and the weaponisation of infectious disease fears for political gain.' The CDC initially did not list the deaths on its public dashboard, saying it needed more information, a move Mr Shapiro condemned as allowing misinformation to spread.

RSS

The Daily Edition

The front page in your inbox each weekday morning: the lead, the picks, and why each one earned its place.

Analysis

Why This Matters

The outbreak highlights how vaccine hesitancy, whether rooted in religious belief or misinformation, can undo decades of public health progress and lead to preventable deaths.
The political dispute between state and federal officials threatens to erode trust in vaccination efforts and complicate containment.
Measles is highly contagious: nine out of ten unvaccinated people exposed to the virus will contract it, as noted by the Australian Centre for Disease Control, underscoring the stakes for vulnerable communities.

Background

The US eliminated endemic measles in 2000 thanks to high vaccination rates, but coverage has slipped below the 95 per cent threshold needed for herd immunity. The Amish, who number over 410,000 nationally with at least 40,000 in Lancaster County, trace their roots to 18th-century European migration and typically avoid government programmes, including national health insurance. Their communal lifestyle, with large families and regular social gatherings, facilitates rapid disease spread.

Key Perspectives

Braxton Mitchell: says the Amish are very social with large families and sceptical of government intervention, and many believe survival is a matter of God's will. Steve Nolt: says non-Amish residents are warily monitoring the spread of measles outside Amish areas, concerned about transmission. Jeanne Franklin: describes the outbreak as "the worst of the worst" and says it is likely larger than official counts; she urges everyone, Amish or not, to reassess their vaccine decision. Robert F. Kennedy Jr: accuses Governor Shapiro of fabricating deaths and engaging in fearmongering for political gain. Governor Josh Shapiro: condemns Kennedy's comments as allowing misinformation to spread and hampering the public health response.

What to Watch

The number of confirmed cases and deaths in Pennsylvania and other states, which could prompt stronger state or federal intervention.
Whether the political dispute between Shapiro and the Trump administration undermines the credibility of vaccination efforts or leads to policy changes.
The effectiveness of door-to-door and community outreach in Amish areas, which could serve as a model for future outbreak response.

Sources

Measles-stricken Amish hit hard amid US vaccine misinformation fight · ABC News

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 9 supported.

Show each claim

SupportedThe outbreak has exceeded 1,300 cases and is Pennsylvania’s largest measles spread in more than three decades.Just In: “Cases have since ballooned above 1,300 in what has become Pennsylvania's largest spread of the disease in more than three decades.”
SupportedThe outbreak has become a political clash over vaccination misinformation.Just In: “a political clash erupted between the state's vaccine-promoting Democratic Governor Josh Shapiro and the Trump Administration's Health Secretary Robert F Kennedy Jr”
SupportedAt least six people have died, including two infants.Just In: “At least six people have died, including two infants — one of which was a newborn”
SupportedAbout one in five cases have resulted in hospitalisation.Just In: “at least 251 people — or about one in every five — have been hospitalised.”
Partly supportedLow vaccination rates and scepticism of modern medicine in Amish communities have created the public health challenge.Just In: “Low vaccination rates, mostly in vulnerable Amish communities, remain the biggest challenge according to officials. The Amish traditionally reject modern-day medicine and technologies in favour of communal living.”
SupportedMitchell said: “The Amish get together with their neighbours, with their relatives; they have church services on Sundays which tend to be at somebody's house and the whole church district shows up.”Just In: ““The Amish get together with their neighbours, with their relatives; they have church services on Sundays which tend to be at somebody's house and the whole church district shows up.””
Partly supportedMitchell said many Amish believe: “if we get sick, if God's will is that we're meant to survive, we'll survive”.Just In: ““With some diseases, the Amish [believe] 'if we get sick, if God's will is that we're meant to survive, we'll survive'."”
SupportedChester County has reported 93 cases this year.Just In: “In the neighbouring Chester County, 93 cases have been reported this year”
SupportedFranklin said: “What we're seeing is the worst of the worst,” and, “Statistically speaking, we're likely going to see more deaths.”Just In: ““What we're seeing is the worst of the worst,” she told the ABC. “It is definitely bigger than we are able to report because it is moving very quickly … Statistically speaking, we're likely going to see more deaths.””
Reports differMore than 6,000 MMR vaccines were administered at 212 pop-up clinics since April.Just In: “more than 6,000 MMR vaccines have been administered at 212 pop-up clinics in affected communities since April. | at least 6,500 MMR vaccines have been administered at 226 pop-up clinics in affected communities since April.”
SupportedThe US has recorded more than 4,500 measles cases this year, its highest number since 1991.Just In: “With more than 4,500 reported cases, the US is enduring its worst year for measles since 1991, the Centers for Disease Control (CDC) said.”
SupportedKennedy suggested Shapiro may have “altogether fabricated” the deaths and accused him of “fearmongering, misinformation, finger-pointing, and the weaponisation of infectious disease fears for political gain.”Just In: “Mr Kennedy suggested Mr Shapiro's office may have "altogether fabricated" the deaths and accused the governor of "fearmongering, misinformation, finger-pointing, and the weaponisation of infectious disease fears for political gain."”