A convenience store worker in Melbourne's CBD has described a frightening encounter with a man who jammed a hunting knife into his car key on her counter the day before delivery rider Feng Jianming was allegedly stabbed to death nearby, and said she decided after the killing to report the incident to police.
Razia Rani, who works at City Mart near Queen Victoria Market, said she did not notice the weapon until she was in her glass booth after retrieving batteries from a back shelf. She described it as “a horrible knife, big knife” with a menacing curved blade, and said she took a step back, terrified. She thought about calling the police, but questioned what that would do, saying thieves and people making threats often came back anyway and the man had barely spoken to her.
The 51-year-old Roberto Urbano has been charged with murder and intentionally causing serious injury over the death of Feng, 47, and faced court on Monday. Police believe an altercation broke out when Feng and a fellow delivery rider who was injured confronted a man they caught tampering with their bikes.
Frightening encounters like this might be commonplace in this pocket of businesses. Rani gestured to a neighbouring liquor store, saying there is an incident “every week”. For example, she said, someone comes and takes the booze and runs away, and sometimes workers chase them and sometimes they just ignore it. She said they faced difficulty finding night staff because the shop is 24/7: “We are begging staff to … come work.”
Rani said the man did not verbally threaten her but she was reminded it is her duty to inform, whether anyone was arrested or not.
Detectives doorknocked businesses in A’Beckett Street and surrounds on Monday, as floral tributes and candles were left for Feng outside a hot pot restaurant on Frederick Way, where he lay dying on Friday night. Delivery riders for HungryPanda, the service Feng was working for at the time of the alleged attack, filtered in and out of the restaurant on Monday, collecting meals.
Rider Karan Gaddam said local rough sleepers would sometimes steal meals from unattended bags while riders went inside restaurants. Another rider, Ming Ku, said he picks up from the area often: “It’s not safe,” he said, “You see someone maybe push the bike [over] and you can’t do anything.”
Some local workers say the area is volatile because of a high concentration of people with untreated mental health and substance abuse issues. One cafe worker, Alex, who asked his surname not be published for privacy reasons, said more police would be welcome. Jo Stafford, police assistant commissioner for the north-west metro region, said at a press conference on Monday that policing could not solve the problem alone.
The Salvation Army’s Major Brendan Nottle said an increasing number of vulnerable people in the city were arming themselves with knives and other weapons for protection in lieu of that support. Melbourne Lord Mayor Nick Reece repeatedly asked whether it was time to “bring back the asylums”, but later said he was not necessarily calling for asylums to return, rather wanting a community conversation and expert advice on how to tackle a rise in violence involving people experiencing acute mental illness.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The death of a delivery rider in Melbourne's CBD has raised questions about safety for gig economy workers and the wider inner-city community
- The incident has reignited debate about Victoria's mental health system and the growing number of vulnerable people in the city arming themselves with weapons
- City Mart's struggle to hire night staff points to broader difficulties facing 24-hour businesses in areas where workers feel unsafe
Background
Feng Jianming, 47, was allegedly stabbed to death on Friday night on Frederick Way in Melbourne's CBD while working for delivery service HungryPanda. Roberto Urbano, 51, has been charged with murder and intentionally causing serious injury. Police believe the altercation began when Feng and another rider confronted a man they found tampering with their bikes. A nearby worker, Razia Rani, had a separate encounter with a man wielding a hunting knife at her convenience store the day before the killing.
Key Perspectives
Razia Rani, City Mart worker: Described a frightening encounter with a man who jammed a hunting knife into his car key on her counter, saying she took a step back, terrified. She said thieves and people making threats often come back, and the man had barely spoken to her. After Feng's death she decided to call police about the knife-wielding man, saying it is her duty to inform.
Jo Stafford, police assistant commissioner: Said there was no way policing could solve the problem alone.
Major Brendan Nottle, Salvation Army: Said an increasing number of vulnerable people in the city were arming themselves with knives and other weapons for protection.
Nick Reece, Melbourne Lord Mayor: Repeatedly asked whether it was time to “bring back the asylums”, but later said he wanted a community conversation and expert advice on tackling a rise in violence involving people experiencing acute mental illness.
Local workers and riders: Some say the area is volatile because of a high concentration of people with untreated mental health and substance abuse issues. Riders report theft of meals from unattended bags and described the area as unsafe.
What to Watch
- Whether further witnesses come forward with information about the altercation on Friday night
- The outcome of Urbano's court proceedings and any charges related to the injured rider
- Whether the Lord Mayor's call for a community conversation leads to any policy or funding changes for mental health support in the CBD
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedRani says she decided after Feng’s death to report the man with the knife to police.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “After Feng’s death, Rani at City Mart decided she would call police about the other man with the knife”
- SupportedThe encounter with the knife-wielding man happened the day before Feng was allegedly stabbed to death nearby.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “just one day after the run-in, another man – 51-year-old Roberto Urbano – allegedly stabbed 47-year-old delivery rider Feng Jianming to death metres from the convenience store where Rani works.”
- SupportedThe man jammed a hunting knife into the crevice of his car key on the store counter.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The man pulled out the hunting knife and jammed it into the tiny crevice of his car key, slamming his fist into it on the yellow convenience store counter as he tried to crack it open.”
- SupportedRani did not notice the weapon until she was in her glass booth after retrieving batteries from a back shelf.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Looking down at the batteries she had retrieved from a back shelf, Razia Rani didn’t notice the weapon until she was in the confines of her little glass booth.”
- SupportedRani described the knife as “a horrible knife, big knife”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “When the City Mart worker saw it – “a horrible knife, big knife” with a menacing curved blade – she took a step back, terrified.”
- SupportedThe 51-year-old Roberto Urbano was charged with murder and intentionally causing serious injury over Feng’s death.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “another man – 51-year-old Roberto Urbano – allegedly stabbed 47-year-old delivery rider Feng Jianming to death metres from the convenience store where Rani works. Urbano, who faced court on Monday, is charged with murder and intentionally causing serious injury.”
- SupportedDetectives believe Feng and an injured fellow rider confronted a man they caught tampering with their bikes, and an altercation broke out.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Detectives believe an altercation broke out when Feng and the fellow delivery rider who was injured confronted a man they caught tampering with their bikes.”
- SupportedRani said there is an incident “every week” at the neighbouring liquor store.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Rani gestured to the neighbouring liquor store, where she said there’s an incident “every week”.”
- SupportedRani said, “We are begging staff to … come work.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““We are begging staff to … come work.””
- Partly supportedDetectives doorknocked businesses in A’Beckett Street and surrounds on Monday.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Police door-knocked businesses in A’Beckett Street and surrounds on Monday”
- SupportedNottle said an increasing number of vulnerable people in the city were arming themselves with knives and other weapons for protection.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The Salvation Army’s Major Brendan Nottle said an increasing number of vulnerable people in the city were arming themselves with knives and other weapons for protection in lieu of that support.”
- SupportedReece later said he was not necessarily calling for asylums to return, but wanted a community conversation and expert advice on violence involving people experiencing acute mental illness.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Reece later said he was not necessarily calling for asylums to return to Melbourne, but rather wanted a community conversation and expert advice on how to tackle a rise in violence involving people experiencing acute mental illness.”