Psychologist Emily E. Davis and colleagues compared implicit associative memory, the kind of learning that happens through repeated experience without conscious effort, in younger adults (ages 18–29) and older adults (ages 60–80). The study, posted as a preprint on bioRxiv and currently under review, used a task in which participants saw pictures of everyday objects overlaid with the name of another object and judged whether the two could fit inside a typical desk drawer. No one was told to memorise the pairings, but each pair appeared twice. Later, with some pairs preserved and others rearranged, the team measured how much faster participants responded to items that had previously appeared together, a measure called associative priming.
Across the whole sample, participants responded faster to previously paired items. The average benefit was about 16 milliseconds in younger adults and 34 milliseconds in older adults, who responded more slowly overall. Within each group alone, the benefit was statistically significant only in older adults, but a direct comparison found no significant age difference, so the result does not show that older adults’ memory is better.
The next day, participants completed an online test in which they saw a picture and chose which of two words had accompanied it previously. Younger adults answered correctly about 65 percent of the time, compared with 59 percent for older adults, still above chance, but significantly less accurate.
Functional MRI scans during the task showed no detected broad age differences in brain activity patterns. However, older adults showed higher activity in the right posterior hippocampus for previously paired items, a difference that emerged in one of several region-specific tests and was not linked to the size of the priming benefit. In the perirhinal cortex, participants with higher activity for rearranged pairs than previously paired items showed greater priming on both sides, though only the overall statistical model for the right side reached significance. No age difference was detected.
The study had limitations: the sample was small (28 younger and 25 older adults after exclusions from an initial 60), older participants had more education and greater head movement during scanning, and the study compared age groups cross-sectionally rather than following individuals over time.
“The main takeaway is that memory doesn't decline across the board as we age,” Davis told ScienceAlert. Davis and her colleagues argue that implicit measures may offer a sensitive way to assess memory in older adults, though the experiment did not test memory training or treatment. The research is available on the preprint server bioRxiv.
