Tennessee national guard members pointed their handguns at a man lying on a Memphis sidewalk after one of them shot him, video released on Monday by Shelby county prosecutors shows, as a police officer called for an ambulance and asked the troops whether they had a medical kit. The man, Tyrin Johnson, 20, died at the scene from a single gunshot wound, investigators said.
The footage, drawn from a Memphis police officer's body camera, stationary street cameras and a bystander's cellphone, does not capture Johnson's initial encounter with the guard members or the moment they fired.
An autopsy report shared by Johnson's family found that he was shot in the back, contradicting police and national guard accounts that said he was facing the guard members with a gun when they fired.
The guard members were part of a federal task force created by Donald Trump, who last year sent troops and federal agents to Democratic-run cities that he described as overrun with crime. Tennessee's Republican governor, Bill Lee, deployed the guard to support the effort. The task force was involved in four fatal shootings between May and July.
A Tennessee national guard report obtained by the Associated Press through a public records request said two guard members responded to a Memphis police radio call, left their vehicle and approached the suspect, who "rounded on them and pointed a tan handgun at them". Both fired their M17 service weapons, and Memphis police arrived shortly after, the report stated.
Authorities said the troops were responding with local police to reports of gunshots at about 4am when they began pursuing an armed man fleeing on foot. Street camera footage shows a person in dark clothing firing shots through an empty parking lot at three people walking on a sidewalk. Body camera audio captures yelling and the sound of a single gunshot followed by several more.
In the body camera video from the aftermath, guard members shout "Hands!" and "Turn over!" as they point their handguns at a man lying on his back. At least six guard members are at the scene, one of them seen moving a handgun on the ground until a police officer tells him to leave it alone. A guard member begins cutting off the man's shirt just before the video ends.
André C Wharton, an attorney for Johnson's family, noted that the videos do not show the moments immediately before the shooting, or the shooting itself. "This investigation must stay focused on the moment the guardsman fired the fatal shot and whether that action was reasonable," Wharton said.
Shelby county district attorney Steve Mulroy said he has not yet decided whether to file charges. Ed Yarbrough, an attorney for the two guard members, said they have no comment at this time. A spokesperson for the Tennessee national guard did not immediately respond to email and phone messages seeking comment.
Johnson was the father of a young child and was preparing to help lead the family construction business, his grandfather Evaniel Johnson said.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The release gives the public its most detailed look at the aftermath of a shooting by a national guard member in a US city where troops were deployed under a federal task force, and it sets the guard's official report against an autopsy shared by the family that found the wound was in Johnson's back.
- The shooting is one of four fatal shootings involving the task force between May and July, so how this case is handled bears on scrutiny of the wider deployment.
- The district attorney's charging decision is the next step that will determine whether the case moves from investigation to prosecution.
Background
National Guard troops are usually deployed at a state governor's direction, and can also be assigned to federal operations. In this case the guard members were part of a federal task force created by Donald Trump, which the sources describe as aimed at Democratic-run cities he called overrun with crime, with Tennessee's Republican governor, Bill Lee, deploying the guard to support it.
Records in the case have come from several directions: the Shelby county district attorney released the video footage, while the Associated Press obtained the national guard's own report through a public records request. The family's account of the autopsy is one of the pieces of evidence in dispute.
Key Perspectives
- André C Wharton, attorney for Tyrin Johnson's family: says the videos do not show the moments immediately before the shooting or the shooting itself, and that the investigation must stay focused on the moment the guardsman fired the fatal shot and whether that action was reasonable.
- Tennessee national guard report: states that the suspect "rounded on them and pointed a tan handgun at them" before both guard members fired their service weapons.
- Ed Yarbrough, attorney for the two guard members: said they have no comment at this time.
What to Watch
- The Tennessee Bureau of Investigation's findings on the 5 July shooting, and whether they address the autopsy finding that Johnson was shot in the back.
- Steve Mulroy's decision on whether to file charges.
- The status of the task force's other fatal shootings between May and July, and whether the video release prompts further records to be made public.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe video shows Tennessee National Guard troops training their handguns on a dying man.World news | The Guardian: “Tennessee national guard troops in Memphis last summer trained their handguns on a man as he lay dying on a sidewalk”
- SupportedShelby County’s district attorney’s office released the footage as the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation continued investigating the 5 July shooting of Tyrin Johnson, 20.World news | The Guardian: “The Shelby county district attorney’s office released the videos, which also include footage from stationary cameras and a cellphone from a bystander, as the Tennessee Bureau of Investigation continues its investigation into the 5 July shooting of Tyrin Johnson. Johnson, 20”
- SupportedA guard member shot Johnson before the troops pointed their handguns at him on the sidewalk.World news | The Guardian: “trained their handguns on a man as he lay dying on a sidewalk after a guard member shot him in the back”
- SupportedA police officer called for an ambulance and asked the troops whether they had a medical kit.World news | The Guardian: “A Memphis police officer can be heard in the footage from an officer’s body camera calling for an ambulance and then asking the troops: “Hey, you guys got a medical kit or anything?””
- SupportedInvestigators said Johnson died at the scene from a single gunshot wound.World news | The Guardian: “Johnson, 20, who had been armed, died at the scene from a single gunshot wound, according to investigators.”
- SupportedThe autopsy report shared by Johnson’s family found he was shot in the back, contrary to police and National Guard accounts that he was facing the guards with a gun when they fired.World news | The Guardian: “An autopsy report shared by Johnson’s family found that he was shot in the back, contradicting police and national guard accounts that said he was facing the guard members with a gun when they fired at him.”
- SupportedThe body-camera video shows guard members shouting “Hands!” and “Turn over!”World news | The Guardian: “Police body camera footage shows guard members at the scene shouting “Hands!” and “Turn over!””
- SupportedThe National Guard report said the suspect “rounded on them and pointed a tan handgun at them”.World news | The Guardian: “the suspect, who “rounded on them and pointed a tan handgun at them”.”
- SupportedWharton said, “This investigation must stay focused on the moment the guardsman fired the fatal shot and whether that action was reasonable,”World news | The Guardian: ““This investigation must stay focused on the moment the guardsman fired the fatal shot and whether that action was reasonable,” Wharton said.”
- SupportedThe task force was involved in four fatal shootings between May and July.World news | The Guardian: “The task force was involved in four fatal shootings between May and July.”
- SupportedAt least six guard members were at the scene immediately after the shooting.World news | The Guardian: “At least six guard members were on the scene immediately after the shooting, the body camera video shows.”
- SupportedJohnson’s grandfather said Johnson was the father of a young child and was preparing to help lead the family construction business.World news | The Guardian: “Johnson was the father of a young child and was preparing to help lead the family construction business, his grandfather, Evaniel Johnson, said.”