Ed Miliband has said he will "definitely not" resign if the government approves the Rosebank oil field, despite previously describing the project as "climate vandalism". The foreign secretary told the BBC he would obey collective responsibility, which requires ministers to publicly support government decisions even if they disagree.
The decision on the oil field off Shetland will be taken by Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh, who succeeded Miliband as energy secretary in July. Miliband, appearing on BBC Radio 4's Today programme, was reminded of his 2023 remark that the project would be a “colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism”. Asked if it could be assumed he would resign if his successor decided to develop Rosebank, he replied: “No, definitely not because I obey collective responsibility.”
Rosebank is Britain's largest untapped oil field, about 80 miles north-west of Shetland, and, if approved, is expected to fill up to 500 million barrels of oil over 25 years. The Conservative government granted a licence in 2023, but the Court of Session in Edinburgh ruled last year that the government had made the approval unlawfully, leaving the current Labour government to make a new decision.
The party is split on the issue. Catherine Fookes, a Labour MP for Monmouthshire, is among a group of Labour MPs, reported to number at least 75, who have signed a letter opposing Rosebank. She said: “We need to really look at what we're doing and ensure we don't exacerbate our climate challenges and make climate change worse. And that's exactly what drilling in the North Sea would do.” In contrast, Steve Yemm, Labour MP for Mansfield, expressed support, calling it a “test of whether, as a country, we can support investment and skilled work in the North Sea whilst meeting our climate obligations”.
Shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie said: “One gas field does not make an energy strategy. Labour cannot claim to back the North Sea while continuing to block new licences, undermine investor confidence, and hammer the industry with a punishing windfall tax.” He added: “It is clear that Labour cannot be trusted to deliver the energy security we need,” with some of the party's MPs “seemingly poised to rebel” over Rosebank.
Miliband argued that the Ukraine war and Iran conflict showed the need to transition to clean energy. "We can't get economic and energy security from fossil fuels, we've got to keep on with this transition to wind power, solar power, nuclear power; homegrown clean energy we can control," he said. He also supported Fahnbulleh's recent approval of the Jackdaw gas field.
Some people in Parliament believe a decision on Rosebank could be made as soon as the end of this month.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The decision will test the Labour government's commitment to climate targets and its internal unity on energy policy.
- Approval could trigger a backbench rebellion and damage the party's environmental credibility among supporters.
- The outcome may influence investor confidence in UK North Sea projects and affect energy security debates.
Background
Rosebank is the UK's largest undeveloped oil field, located off Shetland. A licence was granted by the Conservative government in 2023 but was ruled unlawful by the Court of Session in Edinburgh last year, requiring a fresh decision from the current Labour government. The UK is committed to net zero emissions by 2050.
Key Perspectives
Ed Miliband: Says he will abide by collective responsibility and not resign if Rosebank is approved, despite previously calling it climate vandalism.
Catherine Fookes (Labour MP): Opposes Rosebank, arguing it would exacerbate climate challenges.
Steve Yemm (Labour MP): Supports the project as a test of balancing investment and climate obligations.
Andrew Bowie (Conservative shadow energy secretary): Argues Labour cannot be trusted on energy security and that its MPs are poised to rebel.
What to Watch
- The timing of Energy Secretary Miatta Fahnbulleh's decision, expected possibly by the end of November.
- The number of Labour MPs who rebel if the project is approved.
- The impact on UK climate targets and North Sea investment.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says Miliband rules out resigning if the government approves Rosebank.BBC Scotland: “Ed Miliband said he will "definitely not" resign if the government approves the Rosebank oil field”
- SupportedThe summary says Miliband will abide by collective responsibility despite previously calling Rosebank “climate vandalism”.BBC Scotland: “Ed Miliband said he will "definitely not" resign if the government approves the Rosebank oil field, despite previously calling the scheme "climate vandalism". The foreign secretary told the BBC he would "obey collective responsibility"”
- SupportedMiliband replied, “No, definitely not because I obey collective responsibility.”BBC Scotland: “Mil iband replied: "No, definitely not because I obey collective responsibility.”
- SupportedMiliband’s 2023 description of Rosebank included “a colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism”.BBC Scotland: “Miliband was reminded that in 2023 he said the project would be a "colossal waste of taxpayer money and climate vandalism"”
- SupportedFookes said, “We need to really look at what we're doing and ensure we don't exacerbate our climate challenges and make climate change worse. And that's exactly what drilling in the North Sea would do.”BBC Scotland: “The MP for Monmouthshire told Today: "We need to really look at what we're doing and ensure we don't exacerbate our climate challenges and make climate change worse. "And that's exactly what drilling in the North Sea would do."”
- SupportedYemm called Rosebank a “test of whether, as a country, we can support investment and skilled work in the North Sea whilst meeting our climate obligations”.BBC Scotland: “Steve Yemm, Labour MP for Mansfield, offered his support to Rosebank and said it would be a "test of whether, as a country, we can support investment and skilled work in the North Sea whilst meeting our climate obligations".”
- SupportedBowie said, “One gas field does not make an energy strategy. Labour cannot claim to back the North Sea while continuing to block new licences, undermine investor confidence, and hammer the industry with a punishing windfall tax.”BBC Scotland: “Conservative shadow energy secretary Andrew Bowie said: "One gas field does not make an energy strategy. "Labour cannot claim to back the North Sea while continuing to block new licences, undermine investor confidence, and hammer the industry with a punishing windfall tax."”
- SupportedBowie said Labour could not be trusted to deliver energy security, with some MPs “seemingly poised to rebel” over Rosebank.BBC Scotland: “Bowie added "it is clear that Labour cannot be trusted to deliver the energy security we need" with some of the party's MPs "seemingly poised to rebel" over the approval of Rosebank.”
- SupportedMiliband said, “We can't get economic and energy security from fossil fuels, we've got to keep on with this transition to wind power, solar power, nuclear power; homegrown clean energy we can control.”BBC Scotland: “Miliband added: "What does that teach us? That we can't get economic and energy security from fossil fuels, we've got to keep on with this transition to wind power, solar power, nuclear power; homegrown clean energy we can control."”
- SupportedAt least 75 Labour MPs have signed a letter opposing Rosebank.BBC Scotland: “Catherine Fookes is among a group of Labour MPs, reported to number at least 75, who have signed a letter opposing Rosebank.”
- SupportedIf approved, Rosebank is expected to fill up to 500 million barrels of oil over 25 years.BBC Scotland: “If approved, Rosebank is expected to fill up to 500m barrels of oil over its 25-year lifetime.”
- SupportedSome people in Parliament believe a decision on Rosebank could be made as soon as the end of this month.BBC Scotland: “Some people in Parliament believe that a decision on the oil field could be made as soon as the end of this month.”