NASA is moving forward with a plan to convert an engineering model of its Perseverance and Curiosity Mars rovers into a lunar rover called PROMISE (Polar Rover for Observation, Mapping, and In-Situ Exploration), aiming to land on the Moon's south pole by late 2028 for an 18-month mission at a cost it says will be under $400 million. However, outside estimates and the agency's own administrator's warnings have raised doubts about whether the mission can stay within that budget.
During a weekend briefing, NASA outlined that PROMISE will use a spare Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator (RTG) leftover from the Cassini mission launched in 1997, and it will carry copies of the science instruments from the space agency's VIPER rover, including a drill capable of boring one meter into the lunar regolith. Blue Origin will deliver the rover under a base contract worth $94 million, with an optional additional $140 million based on performance.
The Register reports that The Planetary Society's chief of space policy, Casey Drier, earlier this year estimated the total cost of the mission, including repurposing Mars hardware and landing, would be at least $723 million. At that time, NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said, “if PROMISE costs even 20% of your low-end estimate, we simply will not fly it.” The Register notes that, assuming Isaacman was only talking about the rover, Drier's figure drops to $489 million without launch and landing costs, and adds that 20% of that would not be enough.
NASA said it was “pretty comfortable” with how the Mars rovers were going and therefore happy about repurposing the engineering models. During the briefing, one NASA speaker said, “can we give it a new paint job?”
A source told The Register that morale at the agency's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) was not high at present, and the article said raiding successful programs to fulfill the administration's whims was unlikely to have improved engineers' mood.
The article notes that determining the exact cost of PROMISE is difficult because the figures include different elements; the $400 million figure includes the Blue Origin lander.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- NASA's strategy to repurpose Mars hardware for the Moon may save money but risks impacting Mars missions and engineer morale.
- The cost disagreement highlights tensions between NASA's public commitments and external estimates.
- The mission's viability hinges on Blue Origin's performance and the integrity of the Cassini RTG.
Background
The PROMISE rover will be built using engineering test articles originally developed for NASA's Perseverance and Curiosity Mars rovers. It will follow the agency's VIPER rover to the lunar south pole. The RTG it will use was originally built for the Cassini mission to Saturn, which launched in 1997. Blue Origin's Mark 1 lander will carry PROMISE to the surface.
Key Perspectives
- NASA: Says the mission will cost under $400 million, including the lander, and that it is confident in the plan.
- Casey Drier, The Planetary Society: Estimated the actual cost at $723 million, including developing the Mars hardware and landing.
- Jared Isaacman, NASA Administrator: Pledged to cancel the mission if costs exceed 20% of Drier's low-end estimate.
- Anonymous JPL source: Stated that morale at the Jet Propulsion Laboratory is low, and raiding Mars hardware is unlikely to help.
What to Watch
- Whether NASA's cost remains under $400 million or rises, and whether Isaacman enforces his 20% threshold.
- The impact of removing engineering models from the Mars program, which could affect future rover availability.
- Blue Origin's delivery of the Mark 1 lander and the performance-based option contract.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- Partly supportedNASA repurposes a Mars rover engineering model for a lunar mission.www.theregister.com - Articles: “NASA is moving ahead with its plan to repurpose a Mars rover engineering model as a lunar trundlebot”
- SupportedPROMISE aims to land on the Moon by late 2028 for an 18-month mission.www.theregister.com - Articles: “During a weekend briefing, NASA outlined the plan for PROMISE: to land the robot on the lunar surface by late 2028 for an 18-month mission.”
- SupportedThe Planetary Society estimated the mission would cost at least $723 million, compared with NASA’s under-$400 million figure.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Earlier this year, The Planetary Society's chief of space policy, Casey Drier, estimated that the mission (including repurposing the hardware developed for Mars and landing it on the Moon) would cost at least $723 million.”
- SupportedNASA put the cost at under $400 million, including the lander.www.theregister.com - Articles: “NASA said it had "a pretty firm agreement with JPL to basically deliver the rover to the surface under $400 million." The $400 million includes the lander, which will be Blue Origin's Mark 1.”
- SupportedOutside estimates and the administrator’s warning have raised doubts about whether the mission can stay within NASA’s budget.www.theregister.com - Articles: “At the time, NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said: "if PROMISE costs even 20 percent of your low-end estimate, we simply will not fly it."”
- SupportedPROMISE will use an RTG left over from the Cassini mission, launched in 1997.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Power will come from a Radioisotope Thermoelectric Generator (RTG) left over from the Cassini mission. NASA acknowledged the fuel was processed some time ago – the Cassini mission to Saturn was launched in 1997”
- SupportedPROMISE will carry copies of VIPER’s science instruments, including a drill capable of boring one meter into lunar regolith.www.theregister.com - Articles: “PROMISE will carry copies of VIPER's science instruments, including a drill capable of boring 1 meter into the lunar regolith.”
- SupportedBlue Origin’s base contract is worth $94 million, with an optional additional $140 million based on performance.www.theregister.com - Articles: “NASA awarded the company a $94 million base contract, "with an option period worth an additional $140 million based on performance to deliver PROMISE to the lunar South Pole."”
- SupportedIsaacman said, “if PROMISE costs even 20% of your low-end estimate, we simply will not fly it.”www.theregister.com - Articles: “At the time, NASA Administrator Jared Isaacman said: "if PROMISE costs even 20 percent of your low-end estimate, we simply will not fly it."”
- SupportedAssuming Isaacman was referring only to the rover, Drier’s figure falls to $489 million without launch and landing costs, and 20% of that would not be enough.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Assuming Isaacman was only talking about the rover, Drier's figure drops to $489 million without launch and landing costs. 20 percent of that is… not going to be enough.”
- SupportedNASA said it was “pretty comfortable” with how the Mars rovers were going and was happy to repurpose the hardware; a speaker asked, “can we give it a new paint job?”www.theregister.com - Articles: “During the briefing, NASA said it was "pretty comfortable" with how the Mars rovers were going and so was happy about repurposing the hardware or, as one speaker put it, "can we give it a new paint job?"”
- SupportedA source told The Register that morale at JPL was not high, and the article said raiding successful programs was unlikely to have improved engineers’ mood.www.theregister.com - Articles: “A source told The Register that morale at the agency's Jet Propulsion Laboratory (JPL) was not high at present. Raiding successful programs to fulfill the administration's whims is unlikely to have improved the mood of engineers.”