Almost all National Disability Insurance Scheme plan managers will be wiped from the system next year, with no more than 20 providers authorised to work with half a million participants, as the government attempts to eradicate dodgy operators.
The Health Minister, Mark Butler, put plan managers in his sights when he announced the ambitious overhaul of the ballooning $50 billion NDIS scheme in April, measures the government hopes will make $35 billion in savings over four years. Until now, anybody could register as a plan manager to help participants navigate the complex NDIS system and oversee some of the $8.6 billion in payments that flowed through service providers in the June quarter.
Two-thirds of plan managers were under review last month over concerns of fraud and non-compliance. That comes after 1400 operators were forced out of the sector in the three quarters to July this year. The National Disability Insurance Agency rejected $5.8 million in claims, or more than 3500 requests for funds, from plan managers in the September quarter. Two in five of those were because no service had been delivered. In one-third of cases, the services were not covered by the participant’s plan.
From April next year, plan managers will have to apply for selection to a panel, from which NDIS participants will choose their provider. The panel is slated to be up and running by next October, after which participants will have six months to transition to an approved plan manager. The agency opened consultation on the changes on Wednesday.
The government will preference larger operators who work at scale because it believes they are running more sustainable businesses. Small plan managers who handle fewer than 100 participants are the most likely to be flagged for fraud and non-compliance, with nine in 10 showing warning signs of such mismanagement. Almost 1000 plan managers fell into that category in October. Of those, 678 had been the subject of at least one integrity enforcement measure.
Minister for the NDIS, Jenny McAllister, said the plan management panel would boost integrity and accountability in the market. “It … means better protection for NDIS participants from bad actors and those who seek to rip off participants, their families and the taxpayer,” she said, adding that plan managers’ input would be vital to selecting a high-quality panel. The government says more savings are expected from the drop in fraud it anticipates will follow. Labor is banking on this reform saving the budget $1.4 billion over four years.
The government estimates that three-quarters of accredited plan managers are paying themselves down the track by referring participants to services with which they are affiliated, a practice that will be banned under the reforms.
However, the scheme’s reforms already face challenges. States and territories have baulked at absorbing the care of the hundreds of thousands of people expected to be shifted off the national scheme, and disabled Australians from last month started to feel the cuts to their budgets for social activities and therapy hours. The government’s own advisory committee on disability, the Australian Human Rights Commission and the Greens have warned the speed of change could harm some of the nation’s most vulnerable.
Professor of public service research at UNSW, Helen Dickinson, said some plan managers were not working in the way they should, which had led to an uptick in the number of people having unscheduled reviews because their plans had run out of money. She said the challenge would be ensuring participants with complex needs were still provided with enough choice in a much more limited system. “If [plan managers] need to meet particular kind of criteria, it might weed out some of those that are less effective,” she said.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Hundreds of thousands of NDIS participants who use plan managers will have to switch providers, potentially affecting their access to services and supports.
- The reform is a major part of the government's effort to rein in the $50 billion NDIS budget, with implications for the federal budget and the sustainability of the scheme.
- The crackdown aims to tackle widespread fraud and non-compliance, but critics warn the pace of change could harm vulnerable Australians if their complex needs are not met.
Background
The NDIS, Australia's national disability insurance scheme, provides funding to millions of Australians with permanent and significant disabilities. Plan managers help participants navigate the system and oversee payments to service providers. The scheme has grown rapidly to $50 billion, prompting the government to pursue major reforms to curb costs, including removing hundreds of thousands of people from the scheme and overhauling provider arrangements.
Key Perspectives
- Minister for the NDIS Jenny McAllister: said the panel would 'boost integrity and accountability in the market' and 'means better protection for NDIS participants from bad actors and those who seek to rip off participants, their families and the taxpayer'.
- Critics (government's own advisory committee, Australian Human Rights Commission, the Greens): have warned the speed of change could harm some of the nation's most vulnerable.
- Professor Helen Dickinson, UNSW: said some plan managers were not working as they should, leading to unscheduled reviews, and the challenge would be ensuring participants with complex needs still had enough choice in a much more limited system.
What to Watch
- The outcome of the consultation on the changes, which opened on Wednesday, and whether the government adjusts the proposal before the panel goes live.
- How states and territories respond to the expectation they absorb hundreds of thousands of people shifted off the NDIS.
- Whether the limited number of plan managers (20) will be sufficient to serve half a million participants, particularly those with complex needs.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says plan managers will be reduced from 1,442 to 20 in a fraud crackdown.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The next big NDIS cut: Plan managers to be slashed from 1442 to 20 in fraud crackdown.”
- SupportedLabor is banking on the reform saving $1.4 billion over four years.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Labor is banking on this reform saving the budget $1.4 billion over four years.”
- SupportedCritics warn the speed of change could harm vulnerable participants.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The government’s own advisory committee on disability, the Australian Human Rights Commission and the Greens have warned the speed of change could harm some of the nation’s most vulnerable.”
- SupportedNo more than 20 plan managers will be authorised to work with half a million participants.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “No more than 20 of the 1442 plan managers responsible for funnelling billions in government funding to NDIS participants will be authorised to work with half a million of the scheme’s participants.”
- SupportedThe government hopes the NDIS overhaul will make $35 billion in savings over four years.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Health Minister Mark Butler put plan managers in his sights when he announced the ambitious overhaul of the ballooning $50 billion NDIS scheme in April – measures the government hopes will make $35 billion in savings over four years.”
- SupportedPlan managers oversee some of the $8.6 billion in payments that flowed through service providers in the June quarter.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Until now, anybody could register as a plan manager to help participants navigate the complex NDIS system and oversee some of the $8.6 billion in payments that flowed through the service providers in the June quarter.”
- SupportedTwo-thirds of plan managers were under review last month over fraud and non-compliance concerns.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Two-thirds of plan managers were under review last month over concerns of fraud and non-compliance.”
- Supported1,400 operators were forced out of the sector in the three quarters to July.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “That comes after 1400 operators were forced out of the sector in the three quarters to July this year.”
- SupportedThe NDIA rejected $5.8 million in claims, or more than 3,500 requests for funds, from plan managers in the September quarter.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The National Disability Insurance Agency rejected $5.8 million in claims – or more than 3500 requests for funds – from plan managers in the September quarter.”
- SupportedFrom April next year, managers will apply to a panel; it is slated to be operating by next October, followed by a six-month transition.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “From April next year, plan managers will have to apply for selection to a panel, from which NDIS participants will choose their provider. The panel is slated to be up and running by next October, after which participants will have six months to transition to an approved plan manager.”
- SupportedMcAllister said the panel means “better protection for NDIS participants from bad actors and those who seek to rip off participants, their families and the taxpayer”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““It … means better protection for NDIS participants from bad actors and those who seek to rip off participants, their families and the taxpayer,” she said”
- SupportedThe government estimates that three-quarters of accredited plan managers refer participants to affiliated services and pay themselves down the track.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The government estimates that three-quarters of accredited plan managers are paying themselves down the track by referring participants to services with which they are affiliated”