NHS Tayside has been fined after pleading guilty to safety failures that led to the death of an 82-year-old high-risk patient; BBC Scotland reported a £70,000 fine and STV News reported £75,250. Andrea Imrie died on 13 January 2024, a week after falling from her hospital bed at Murray Royal Hospital in Perth. Staff had removed her bed-pad alarm due to shortages and a room movement sensor also failed to activate.
NHS Tayside has been fined after admitting a shortage of safety alarms contributed to the death of 82-year-old Andrea Imrie, a high-risk patient at Murray Royal Hospital in Perth. The health board pleaded guilty at Perth Sheriff Court to a breach of health and safety regulations.
The court heard that Imrie, who was being treated in the Tummel Ward dementia assessment unit, had been assessed as a high falls risk and was reliant on both a bed pad alarm and a room movement sensor. On 5 January, the day before the fall, staff removed her bed pad alarm and gave it to a newly admitted patient who was also assessed as a high-risk faller. The room movement sensor did not sound when she got out of bed.
Imrie was later heard falling and was found on the floor with a head injury. She was taken to Ninewells Hospital, where a CT scan indicated she had suffered a large-volume haemorrhage. Her condition deteriorated and she died on 13 January 2024.
The BBC reported that Sheriff Jennifer Bain KC fined the health board £70,000, while STV News reported a fine of £75,250. Sheriff Bain said no sentence could properly reflect the "value of the life lost" or "alleviate the profound impact and enduring grief the loss of life has had on those left behind". She stated that the level of harm was high but noted that the health board's "swift" investigation and changes in procedures could be viewed as mitigating factors.
Depute fiscal Lisa Duffus said: "On 5 January – the day before the fall – a new admission came into the ward who was assessed as a high falls risk and was known to mobilise frequently. Due to shortages of bed pad alarms in the ward, there was none for the new patient. Staff made a collective clinical decision that Mrs Imrie was more settled, that her bed pad alarm could be safely removed, and moved to the new patient's bed. They would not have made that decision if Tayside Health Board had ensured there were enough bed pad alarms for patients."
Defence counsel Peter Gray offered the health board's apologies to the family and said: "It is a matter of great concern and regret in equal measure that Andrea Imrie suffered a fall, the consequence of which she sustained severe injury and died as a result of the failings for which the accused organisation is responsible."
Debbie Carroll, who leads on health and safety investigations for the Crown Office and Procurator Fiscal Service (COPFS), said: "This was the tragic death of a vulnerable patient whose care plan identified clear measures to reduce the risk of a fall. Those measures were not fully in place. One alarm had been removed because of equipment shortages and another failed to operate when it was needed."
NHS Tayside admitted failing to ensure that patients assessed as being falls risks in Tummel Ward were not exposed to risks to their health and safety; failing to provide an adequate system for checking room movement sensor alarms daily; and failing to have sufficient bed pad alarms available on 5 January. The health board has since increased the number of bed pad alarms and introduced revised procedures for alarm checks.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case highlights the consequences of equipment shortages in healthcare settings, where cost-cutting or insufficient resources can directly lead to patient deaths.
- It raises questions about how NHS boards manage falls risk for vulnerable patients, particularly those with dementia, and whether current alarm monitoring systems are adequate.
- The fine, though reduced to avoid harming patient care, demonstrates legal accountability for systemic safety failures in public health services.
Background
NHS Tayside is a health board covering the Tayside region of Scotland. Fall prevention is a key patient safety priority in hospitals, with bed-pad alarms and room sensors commonly used for high-risk patients. The case follows a Health and Safety Executive investigation that identified deficiencies in alarm availability and checking procedures. Imrie had a history of falls and had previously sustained significant injuries.
Key Perspectives
Sheriff Jennifer Bain KC: Said the level of harm was high but accepted the health board's swift investigation and procedural changes as mitigating factors. She limited the fine from a possible £1.5m to avoid impacting patient care.
Debbie Carroll (COPFS): Said organisations responsible for vulnerable people must ensure risk control measures are available and working effectively. She hoped the prosecution highlighted the serious consequences of failing to meet safety standards.
Defence counsel Peter Gray: Offered apologies to the family, said the failings were not deliberate and were isolated, and that they arose from a genuine but misplaced clinical opinion.
What to Watch
- Whether NHS Tayside's increased alarm stock and revised check procedures prevent similar incidents, and if other Scottish health boards review their own fall-prevention equipment levels.
- Possible civil claims from Imrie's family, which could further examine resource decisions at the ward level.
- Scrutiny from the Scottish Parliament or NHS oversight bodies regarding funding for patient safety equipment across boards.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 2 sources: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedNHS Tayside was fined after an alarm shortage and alarm failures led to the death of an 82-year-old high-risk patient.BBC Scotland: “NHS Tayside has been fined £70,000 after admitting a shortage of safety alarms led to the death of an 82-year-old patient.”
- Reports differThe fine was reported as £70,000 by BBC Scotland and £75,250 by STV News.STV News: “NHS Tayside was fined £75,250 after pleading guilty to a breach of health and safety regulations at Perth Sheriff Court on Monday.”
- SupportedNHS Tayside pleaded guilty to a breach of health and safety regulations.STV News: “NHS Tayside was fined £75,250 after pleading guilty to a breach of health and safety regulations at Perth Sheriff Court on Monday.”
- SupportedStaff removed Andrea Imrie’s bed-pad alarm because of shortages and gave it to another patient; the room movement sensor also failed to activate.STV News: “A subsequent Health and Safety Executive investigation found that Mrs Imrie’s bed pad alarm had been removed due to equipment shortages – and a damaged movement sensor had failed to alert staff when she became mobile.”
- SupportedThe alarm was removed on 5 January, the day before Imrie fell, and moved to a newly admitted patient assessed as a high falls risk.BBC Scotland: “The bed pad alarm had been removed the previous day. The fiscal said: "On 5 January - the day before the fall - a new admission came into the ward who was assessed as a high falls risk"”
- SupportedAndrea Imrie died on 13 January 2024, seven days after falling at the hospital.STV News: “Andrea Imrie was found with a head injury after falling within her room at Murray Royal Hospital in Perth on January 6, 2024. The 82-year-old ... died on January 13, 2024.”
- SupportedSheriff Jennifer Bain said no sentence could properly reflect the “value of the life lost” or “alleviate the profound impact and enduring grief the loss of life has had on those left behind”.BBC Scotland: “Sheriff Bain said no sentence could properly reflect the "value of the life lost" or "alleviate the profound impact and enduring grief the loss of life has had on those left behind".”
- SupportedSheriff Bain said the harm was high and described the health board’s “swift” investigation and procedural changes as possible mitigating factors.BBC Scotland: “The sheriff said the level of harm caused was high, but said the health board's "swift" investigation and changes in procedures could be viewed as mitigating factors.”
- SupportedDepute fiscal Lisa Duffus said staff would not have removed Imrie’s alarm if the health board had ensured enough alarms were available.BBC Scotland: “They would not have made that decision if Tayside Health Board had ensured there were enough bed pad alarms for patients.”
- SupportedDefence counsel Peter Gray said it was a matter of “great concern and regret” that Imrie suffered a fatal fall as a result of the organisation’s failings.BBC Scotland: “It is a matter of great concern and regret in equal measure that Andrea Imrie suffered a fall, the consequence of which she sustained severe injury and died as a result of the failings for which the accused organisation is responsible.”
- SupportedDebbie Carroll said Imrie’s care-plan measures were not fully in place, with one alarm removed because of shortages and another failing when needed.STV News: “Those measures were not fully in place. One alarm had been removed because of equipment shortages and another failed to operate when it was needed.”
- SupportedNHS Tayside increased the number of bed-pad alarms and introduced revised procedures for alarm checks after the incident.STV News: “NHS Tayside has since increased the the number of bed pad alarms available, as well as introducing revised procedures concerning alarm checks.”