OpenAI accuses former employee of taking 100-plus trade secret files to Apple

ChatGPT maker seeks court time to investigate and may bring counterclaims against iPhone maker

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
OpenAI has accused a former employee of taking more than 100 confidential files about its unreleased hardware back to Apple, escalating a trade secrets dispute between the two companies that began with Apple's own lawsuit in July.

OpenAI has accused a former employee of taking more than 100 confidential files about its unreleased hardware back to Apple, in the latest twist of a trade secrets dispute between the two companies.

In a court filing submitted Wednesday, OpenAI said the unnamed employee, who joined from Apple before returning to the iPhone maker six months later, transferred sensitive documents to personal accounts before leaving. The files allegedly included detailed images of at least one unreleased OpenAI device, engineering and manufacturing data, supplier information, project files, specifications for cosmetic finishes, and reports on coating and sealing hardware components. Some transfers occurred just after midnight Singapore time on June 2, which OpenAI says was the employee's final day.

OpenAI also alleges the former employee presented its product plans to Apple's senior leadership, including its vice president of operations in Asia, months ago. The ChatGPT maker pointed to Apple's push into AI-powered hardware, including newly announced smart home products, as cause for concern.

“OpenAI is very concerned that its trade secret and confidential information is now circulating inside Apple, where Apple engineers can shape Apple's upcoming products based on OpenAI's confidential and innovative work,” the company told the court.

Apple said it has found nothing to support the claims and insists it has rules to prevent staff from bringing former employers' secrets into the company.

The filing comes months after Apple sued OpenAI and former employees Chang Liu and Tang Yew Tan, alleging they took confidential engineering information to help the ChatGPT maker develop its own hardware. OpenAI denied those accusations at the time, saying: “We have no interest in other companies' trade secrets. We remain focused on building innovative technology that empowers people everywhere.”

OpenAI has yet to establish that Apple received or used any of the allegedly taken material. It has asked the court for time to investigate and potentially bring counterclaims, though none have been filed to date.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The filing turns the trade secrets fight back on Apple, months after Apple sued OpenAI over similar allegations involving two former employees.
  • The case could shape how much confidential material engineers may take with them when they move between rival hardware and AI companies.
  • If OpenAI's claims are proven, Apple's newly announced smart home products could face questions over whether they drew on a competitor's confidential work.

Background

In July, Apple sued OpenAI and former employees Chang Liu and Tang Yew Tan, alleging they took confidential engineering information to help the ChatGPT maker develop its own hardware. OpenAI denied the claims, saying it had no interest in other companies' trade secrets. The new filing alleges similar conduct in the opposite direction, involving an employee who left OpenAI to return to Apple. OpenAI has not yet established that Apple received or used any of the material.

Key Perspectives

OpenAI: Told the court it is very concerned that its trade secrets are now circulating inside Apple, where engineers could shape upcoming products based on its confidential work. It has asked for time to investigate and to potentially bring counterclaims.

Apple: Says it has found nothing to back OpenAI's claims and has policies designed to stop staff from bringing former employers' secrets into the company.

Critics and skeptics: No counterclaims have been filed, and the allegations rely on an employee who has not been named. Courts may also weigh whether an employee's personal transfers of documents amount to use by the new employer.

What to Watch

  • Whether OpenAI files counterclaims against Apple and what evidence supports them.
  • The court's response to OpenAI's request for more time to investigate.
  • Any further detail on the alleged presentation to Apple's Asia operations leadership, and whether Apple's smart home lineup shows signs of the disputed information.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe