The outgoing head of NSW’s casino watchdog has called for a single state regulator to oversee all poker machines in casinos, pubs and clubs, and accused the Minns government of lacking the bravery to implement mandatory carded play despite evidence of money laundering and gambling harm.
Philip Crawford, retiring next week as inaugural chief commissioner of the NSW Independent Casino Commission, told the Sydney Morning Herald the government had bowed to industry pressure and failed to act on the 2022 Project Islington inquiry, which found criminals were funnelling billions of dollars into pokies and recommended cashless gaming cards.
“We’ve got nowhere,” Crawford said. “The amount going through pokies is going through the roof. It’s billions. It’s a lot of money.”
Crawford’s comments, described as his fiercest public condemnation of Premier Chris Minns’ poker machine reforms, drew support from gambling reform advocates. Wesley Mission chief executive Reverend Stu Cameron accused the government of “tinkering around the edges”.
The state’s mega clubs, Crawford said, should be subject to the same levels of scrutiny as Crown and Star casinos. “I don’t see why they shouldn’t have, if they’ve got nothing to fear, better regulation. On any view of it, any definition anywhere around the world, they’re casinos.”
Crawford said gambling watchdog powers should be expanded, adding that legislation allowing regulators to hold far-reaching inquiries had been gradually watered down.
Former Liberal premier Dominic Perrottet in 2023 promised to implement cashless gaming on the back of Project Islington’s findings, a pledge the Minns government has refused to match. A tranche of reforms announced by Gaming and Racing Minister David Harris in August included facial recognition technology in gaming rooms, a third-party exclusion scheme and the scrapping of gaming VIP programs, but not mandatory carded play. The government said the foundations for technology to facilitate account-based play would be gradually introduced as part of a staged approach. Venues will be able to choose whether to implement account-based gaming, while the government’s alternatives will allow players to continue gambling with cash if they prefer.
Harris defended the reforms, saying they were the most comprehensive introduced by any NSW government to reduce gambling harm. “Before any account-based system implemented that is secure, reliable and fit for purpose, it is necessary to upgrade and modernise the core technology infrastructure of NSW’s gaming machine network that largely relies on legacy technology,” he said.
Wesley Mission chief executive Reverend Stu Cameron echoed Crawford’s call for a single regulator. “We have dozens and dozens of suburban casinos. If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it is a duck. They are casinos for all intents and purposes. Treat them as such, regulate them as such and don’t give them a free pass like they’ve been having for decades.”
NSW remains on track to eclipse $10 billion in poker machine losses this year.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- A single regulator for all gambling venues, if adopted, would end the current distinction between high-scrutiny casinos and lightly regulated pubs and clubs, potentially tightening anti-money-laundering controls across the state.
- The outgoing watchdog’s criticism puts pressure on Premier Chris Minns ahead of the next election, as the government’s staged approach to account-based gaming continues to face opposition from law enforcement and harm-reduction advocates.
- With pokie losses on track to top $10 billion this year, the reform debate directly affects the thousands of problem gamblers and their families in NSW communities.
Background
Poker machines in NSW are found in casinos, registered clubs and pubs. The 2022 Project Islington inquiry, led by the NSW Crime Commission and the state’s Independent Liquor and Gaming Authority, found criminals were laundering billions of dollars through pokies and recommended cashless gaming cards to trace the money. The former Perrottet government committed to mandatory cashless gaming but lost the 2023 election. The Minns government has instead pursued a voluntary, staged introduction of account-based play alongside facial recognition and other measures. The NSW Labor Party first allowed poker machines in pubs in 1997 under Premier Bob Carr.
Key Perspectives
Philip Crawford (outgoing chief commissioner, NSW Independent Casino Commission): The government has bowed to industry pressure and lacks bravery; clubs and pubs are essentially casinos and should face the same regulation.
Reverend Stu Cameron (Wesley Mission chief executive and gambling reform advocate): The government is “tinkering around the edges”; dozens of suburban venues are de facto casinos and should be regulated as such.
David Harris (NSW Gaming and Racing Minister): The government’s reforms are the most comprehensive by any NSW government; upgrading legacy technology must precede any account-based system.
What to Watch
- Whether the Minns government responds to Crawford’s call for a single regulator with a formal proposal or maintains its staged, voluntary approach.
- The next tranche of gambling reforms, if any, ahead of the 2027 state election, including the timeline for account-based play infrastructure.
- The NSW Crime Commission’s next assessment of money laundering through pokies, which could intensify pressure for cashless gaming.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- Partly supportedCameron said, “We have dozens and dozens of suburban casinos. If it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it is a duck.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““We have dozens and dozens of suburban casinos.” “We need to treat them for what they are...if it looks like a duck, quacks like a duck, it is a duck.”
- SupportedCrawford said the amount going through pokies was “going through the roof” and “billions”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““We’ve got nowhere,” Crawford said. “The amount going through pokies is going through the roof. It’s billions. It’s a lot of money.””
- SupportedCrawford said mega clubs are casinos and should face the same scrutiny as Crown and Star.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The state’s mega clubs, Crawford said, should be subjected to the same levels of scrutiny as Crown and Star casinos. “I don’t see why they shouldn’t have, if they’ve got nothing to fear, better regulation,” he said. “On any view of it, any definition anywhere around the world, they’re casinos.””
- SupportedCameron accused the government of “tinkering around the edges”.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Wesley Mission chief executive and gambling reform advocate Reverend Stu Cameron echoed Crawford’s criticisms, accusing the government of “tinkering around the edges” of reform.”
- SupportedThe headline says Crawford urged a single regulator to oversee poker machines in casinos, pubs and clubs, and criticised government inaction.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Crawford believes the government should establish a centralised gambling watchdog to oversee casinos, clubs and pubs across the state.”
- Partly supportedCrawford accused the government of lacking bravery specifically to implement mandatory carded play.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““You’ve got to have bravery, and the political climate now for bravery is limited because of re-elections,” Crawford said. “There’s no bravery in government at the moment.” Crawford ... said the government had failed to act on the findings of Project Islington”
- SupportedProject Islington found criminals were funnelling billions of dollars into poker machines.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The inquiry, a joint investigation led by the NSW Crime Commission and the state’s Independent Liquor and Gaming Authority, revealed that criminals were funnelling billions of dollars into poker machines”
- SupportedProject Islington recommended cashless gaming cards.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “and recommended cashless gaming cards to stem the illegal cash flow.”
- SupportedCrawford was retiring the following week as inaugural chief commissioner of the NSW Independent Casino Commission.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Crawford, who next week retires from his role as the inaugural commission head”
- SupportedThe government’s August reforms did not include mandatory carded play and included facial recognition, a third-party exclusion scheme and scrapping gaming VIP programs.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “A tranche of gambling reforms announced by Gaming and Racing Minister David Harris in August, including the use of facial recognition technology in gaming rooms, a third-party exclusion scheme and the scrapping of gaming VIP programs, did not include mandatory carded play.”
- SupportedThe government said its reforms were the most comprehensive introduced by any NSW government to reduce gambling harm.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Harris defended the reforms, which he said were the most comprehensive introduced by any NSW government to reduce gambling harm.”
- SupportedNSW was on track to exceed $10 billion in poker machine losses that year.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Venues will be able to choose whether they implement account-based gaming as the state remains on track to eclipse $10 billion in poker machine losses this year.”