The government has opted not to exercise a break clause that would have ended Palantir's £330m NHS contract next year, instead extending the US tech giant's involvement in the Federated Data Platform until March 2029. Health minister James Frith confirmed the move, prompting criticism from Labour MPs, campaigners and transparency groups.
Frith told MPs that ending the agreement in 2027 would risk disrupting services, and the government plans to begin procurement for a replacement contract in the second half of 2027. The new procurement will be open to both UK and international suppliers and will focus on interoperability, resilience and trusted common standards.
Dame Chi Onwurah, chair of the Commons Science and Technology Committee, said she was "extremely disappointed" by the decision and questioned whether the break clause was still meaningful. "If a break clause cannot be exercised because of continuity of care, it is not a break clause; it is a lock-in," she said. She urged the government to start reducing dependency immediately rather than waiting two years.
The contract, awarded in 2023, covers the Federated Data Platform, which links data across NHS organisations in England. More than half of NHS trusts in England now use the technology, which NHS figures suggest has helped deliver 110,000 additional operations. The decision to keep Palantir has also drawn criticism over the company's work with the Israeli military and US immigration authorities.
"This is a victory for healthcare workers, patients and campaigners who refused to give up," said Tom Guha of Amnesty International UK. "The next two years must be about extracting Palantir from our NHS, not allowing it to become more deeply embedded."
Palantir's UK senior vice president, Tom Watson, welcomed the extension, calling it "good news for patients and for the NHS" and saying the company would "deepen our investment in the UK."
But Peter Griffiths, founder of Argyll Data Development, warned that replacing Palantir would do little to address Britain's technological dependence unless ministers ensured the NHS could move its data and systems between suppliers. “Sovereignty must be a priority for the government, and an exit clause only counts if the NHS can actually leave when it wants to,” he said.
Foxglove, a nonprofit tech transparency group, criticised the extension. Co-executive director Rosa Curling said: Palantir and its chief lobbyist Lord Tom Watson clearly think the contract extension is in the bag and appear to be already planning to turn that into another extension in two years, or a new procurement that heavily favours Palantir as we saw in 2023. The government must provide urgent clarity on whether they plan to help Watson embed Palantir in the NHS for the long term, or will kick this Trump-backing spy tech company out of the health service once and for all.
German software firm Celonis, through senior vice president Rupal Karia, supported keeping procurement open to trusted European partners and argued that digital sovereignty should focus on preventing single-vendor lock-in rather than isolationism.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The NHS's continued reliance on Palantir raises questions about the control of patient data and the feasibility of switching suppliers in future.
- The government's decision to delay procurement until the second half of 2026 suggests that Palantir's involvement could extend well beyond 2029.
- The case highlights broader concerns about "vendor lock-in" in critical public-sector IT contracts.
Background
The Federated Data Platform is an initiative to link data across NHS organisations in England, aiming to reduce waiting lists and improve efficiency. Palantir, a US data analytics company known for its work with defence and intelligence agencies, won the contract in 2023 after earlier pandemic-related work. Critics have long questioned the lack of competition and transparency in the deal, as well as Palantir's ties to the Israeli military and US immigration enforcement. More than half of NHS trusts currently use the platform.
Key Perspectives
Health minister James Frith: Said not exercising the break clause was necessary to avoid disruption, and the government plans to begin procurement for a replacement contract in the second half of 2026, focusing on interoperability and common standards.
Dame Chi Onwurah (chair, Commons Science and Technology Committee): Called the decision "extremely disappointing" and said that if the break clause cannot be exercised, it is not a break clause but a lock-in. She urged the government to start reducing dependency immediately.
Tom Watson (senior vice president, Palantir UK): Welcomed the extension, saying it is "good news for patients and for the NHS" and that Palantir will "deepen our investment in the UK."
Rosa Curling (Foxglove): Accused Palantir of planning to turn the extension into another extension or a procurement that favours Palantir, and called for urgent clarity on whether the government intends to help Watson embed Palantir in the NHS for the long term – or will kick this Trump-backing spy tech company out of the health service once and for all.
What to Watch
- The formal procurement process, set to begin in the second half of 2026, will determine whether the NHS can shift to a new supplier before 2029.
- The government's plans to test new capabilities with different providers, starting with maternity services, could indicate whether Palantir's replacement is workable.
- Palantir's own investment plans: Tom Watson said the company will "deepen our investment in the UK", which could complicate a future exit.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 10 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe headline says the Palantir NHS contract was extended by two years and the government faced criticism.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Lawmakers and campaign groups have slammed the UK government's decision to extend Palantir's controversial NHS contract by two years.”
- SupportedThe summary says the health minister announced a new FDP procurement and critics warned of lock-in.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Frith told MPs on Monday that the current contract would continue until March 2029 as the government procures a new version of the Federated Data Platform (FDP).”
- Partly supportedThe opening says lawmakers and campaign groups criticised the extension as risking long-term lock-in of the US spy-tech company in the health service.www.theregister.com - Articles: ““If a break clause cannot be exercised because of continuity of care, it is not a break clause; it is a lock-in.””
- Partly supportedThe existing Palantir-led contract was awarded in 2023 and has a maximum value of £330 million.www.theregister.com - Articles: “The existing Palantir-led deal, awarded in 2023, has a maximum value of £330 million and includes other suppliers.”
- SupportedThe extension keeps the current contract in place until March 2029.www.theregister.com - Articles: “the current contract would continue until March 2029”
- SupportedPalantir had won £60 million in NHS contracts without competition during and after the pandemic.www.theregister.com - Articles: “The US supplier had already won £60 million in NHS contracts without competition during and following the pandemic.”
- SupportedFrith said the new FDP iteration would welcome UK and international providers.www.theregister.com - Articles: “a "new FDP iteration" which would "welcome international and UK capability alike – whether that is UK small and medium-sized enterprises that want a crack at NHS contracts, sovereign AI-backed capability in the UK or any international provider worth merit."”
- SupportedOnwurah asked Frith whether assurances about continuity requirements had been made in error, calling the situation a lock-in.www.theregister.com - Articles: “"If a break clause cannot be exercised because of continuity of care, it is not a break clause; it is a lock-in. The Minister assured me that there were already contractual requirements that smooth continuity of care should continue. Were those assurances made in error?"”
- SupportedFrith said the contracts had exit and transition provisions and migration was possible in principle.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Frith confirmed that the contracts included exit and transition provisions and that migration was "possible in principle."”
- SupportedThe formal procurement process is due to start in the second half of next year and take around 18 months.www.theregister.com - Articles: “The formal process is set to start during the second half of next year and take around 18 months.”
- SupportedTom Watson said ministers described the programme as significantly exceeding its benefits forecast and having exceeded every target since launching in 2024.www.theregister.com - Articles: “in the words of Ministers, 'is significantly exceeding its benefits forecast and has exceeded every target' since it launched in 2024”
- SupportedFoxglove's Rosa Curling said Palantir and Watson appeared to expect another extension in two years or a new procurement favouring Palantir, as in 2023.www.theregister.com - Articles: “appear to be already planning to turn that into another extension in two years, or a new procurement that heavily favors Palantir as we saw in 2023.”