A security researcher assigned to find flaws in a tobacco company's network found an open file share containing files he identified as product recipes, with detailed chemical compositions. The company’s security team denied the files were real, according to pen tester Dahvid Schloss, and the two sides argued about the finding for a year; toward the end of the engagement, the files were gone.
In The Register's PWNED column, Schloss recounted that his initial probes using tools like Metasploit raised no alarms from the company's Trend Micro antivirus. "I'm running through this environment, and I'm basically just using the loudest toys and tools you can imagine," he said.
His senior manager told him to think about what would be important to the organization if leaked. Schloss thought the recipes might be important to a products company. He found an SMB file share (ports 139 and 445 open) that was accessible to every employee and hosted sensitive IT and HR records.
Within a folder named "confidential," he found files combining the word "recipe" with the product name, sub-product name, and date. One file detailed how a tobacco product was made, including the weight, volume, and percentage of each chemical. It was marked with red letters at the top saying "Confidential" and at the bottom saying "Do not share." Schloss downloaded it as evidence.
"I think we found a smoking gun here. This is pretty bad," he said.
Schloss's manager then asked him to delete the downloaded file because it was so sensitive. When he reported the finding to the company's security team, he got a surprise. His contact told him the recipes were not real and denied a security problem existed. "And we're just kind of baffled because we're like, what? What are you talking about? This is clearly a recipe you guys have," Schloss said.
The argument continued for a year. Towards the end of the engagement, he checked the folder again. The files were gone.
"So there was obviously some truth behind it, but they wanted to deny the finding," he said.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The tobacco company's response, outright denial followed by the quiet removal of the files, highlights a dangerous security culture where internal findings are dismissed rather than acted upon.
- Trade secrets like manufacturing recipes are a company's core intellectual property; leaving them on a completely open internal share exposes them to any employee or attacker who gains a foothold.
- The failure of the company's antivirus to detect even the most obvious scanning tools suggests basic endpoint defenses were ineffective.
Background
The story comes from The Register's long-running PWNED series, which examines security failures where organizations are their own worst enemies. Pen tester Dahvid Schloss was conducting a standard red-team engagement against an unnamed tobacco company when he encountered a completely unprotected Windows SMB file share containing the firm's product recipes alongside its IT and HR records.
Key Perspectives
- Dahvid Schloss (Pen Tester, Cobalt): Said the unauthenticated share contained files named "recipe" along with the product name and date, with chemical percentages. He called it a "smoking gun" and was "baffled" when the company denied the finding. He pointed out the files later vanished, proving "there was obviously some truth behind it."
- Tobacco Company's Security Team: Denied the files were real or that he had seen a real recipe. They argued with Schloss for a year, despite the files being in the correct folder structure with proper naming conventions and marked "Confidential."
What to Watch
- Whether the tobacco company has since addressed the broader security weaknesses on its network that allowed the SMB share to be exposed to all employees.
- Whether similar "shoot the messenger" responses discourage ethical hackers and security researchers from thoroughly reporting critical vulnerabilities.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedA pen tester found tobacco-product trade secrets on an open network share.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Assigned to find flaws in the network of a tobacco company, Schloss stumbled onto some very poorly protected trade secrets.”
- SupportedThe company’s security team denied that the recipe files were real.www.theregister.com - Articles: “The security people at the tobacco company vehemently denied that the files were real or that he had seen a real recipe.”
- SupportedSchloss and the company argued about the finding for a year.www.theregister.com - Articles: “They continued arguing about it for a year and Schloss could not show them the recipe file he had downloaded because he had been forced to erase it.”
- SupportedToward the end of the engagement, Schloss found the files were gone.www.theregister.com - Articles: “The funny thing is, I went back and checked towards the end of the engagement to see if those files are still in that folder. And no, they were gone, they were deleted or moved, or something,”
- SupportedA recipe file detailed how a tobacco product was made, including the weight, volume and percentage of each chemical.www.theregister.com - Articles: “He opened one file and discovered that it had information about how that tobacco product was made, including the weight and volume and what percentage of each chemical it had inside.”
- SupportedThe share had no access restrictions and was accessible to every employee.www.theregister.com - Articles: “Despite hosting sensitive IT and HR records, this specific file share had no access restrictions and was completely exposed to every employee in the company.”
- SupportedSchloss said, “I'm running through this environment, and I'm basically just using the loudest toys and tools you can imagine.”www.theregister.com - Articles: “"I'm running through this environment, and I'm basically just using the loudest toys and tools you can imagine," he told The Register.”
- SupportedThe file share scan found ports 139 and 445 open.www.theregister.com - Articles: “The scan revealed that ports 139 and 445 were open, indicating that the system was running the Windows SMB file sharing protocol.”
- SupportedSchloss said, “I think we found a smoking gun here. This is pretty bad.”www.theregister.com - Articles: ““I think we found a smoking gun here. This is pretty bad,” Schloss said.”
- SupportedSchloss’s manager asked him to delete the downloaded file because it was highly sensitive.www.theregister.com - Articles: “But his manager asked him to delete the downloaded file, because it was such sensitive information that he shouldn't retain a copy.”
- SupportedSchloss said, “And we're just kind of baffled because we're like, what? What are you talking about? This is clearly a recipe you guys have.”www.theregister.com - Articles: “"And we're just kind of baffled because we're like, what? What are you talking about? This is clearly a recipe you guys have," Schloss said.”
- SupportedSchloss said, “So there was obviously some truth behind it, but they wanted to deny the finding.”www.theregister.com - Articles: “"So there was obviously some truth behind it, but they wanted to deny the finding."”