PC Richard Hardwick and PC Lauren Livingstone were found guilty of gross misconduct at a police disciplinary hearing in Newport. The panel chairman, Ian Arundale, said their behaviour may have compromised the missing persons investigation and undermined public trust in the police.
The hearing was told the officers were assigned to look into reports that Eve Smith, Darcy Ross and Sophie Russon had gone missing after a night out on 3 March 2023. The three women were reported missing to Gwent Police on 4 March, but were not found until 30 hours after the initial contact by the families. Five people were found in a crashed car in a wooded area off the A48 in St Mellons, Cardiff, 46 hours after the crash. Three occupants, Smith, Rafel Jeanne and Darcy Ross, had died, while Sophie Russon and Shane Loughlin were seriously injured.
Hardwick and Livingstone visited Russon's home and then Smith's house. Under Gwent Police's missing person policy, they were supposed to search the addresses for clues. Hardwick wrote in the official log that a “premise search conducted” and told his supervising officer the search at Russon's house had been carried out. He also said searches had happened to the police watchdog, the IOPC. Russon's father, Nathan, told the hearing the officers were at the house for a very short period and did not ask to search the bedroom. Livingstone wrote a report in the log that the panel head heard was “deliberately vague” but suggested a search had taken place. She said she could not remember whether searches had taken place.
The panel found both officers had failed to conduct searches at Smith and Russon's homes. Hardwick was found to have provided a false entry in the police log and a dishonest statement to the IOPC. Livingstone was found to have made a false log entry and given a dishonest account to her supervisor. Arundale said there was a lack of mitigating factors and a final written warning was not an option given the level of harm and culpability.
Smith's mother, Emma Borg, said her family felt their honesty and credibility were being questioned at a time when they "trusted the police to do their jobs". "Instead, the dishonesty established during these proceedings undermined the missing persons' investigation and the trust our families desperately needed to have in those responsible for helping us," she said. Smith's sister, Lauren Doyle, said the outcome was an "important step" but added: "Our search for answers continues."
Derrick Campbell from the IOPC said the officers failed to "act honestly and with integrity". "PC Hardwick deliberately lied during the course of the missing person investigation, claiming on police records and to his supervisor that searches had been completed," he said. "PC Livingstone had ample opportunity to tell the IOPC the required searches had not been conducted. Instead, she did not give an account and stated she could not remember the specifics of her visits to the homes of two of the young women who had been reported missing."