A WA Government review has found that one of three children who were murdered repeatedly reported family domestic violence (FDV) to police before their deaths. The assurance review, released Wednesday, also found that most responses to recommendations in two earlier reviews had been substantially implemented or were on track to implement all recommendations within the agreed timeframes.
The review examined the child protection response before the three children were murdered.
The review, conducted by Nous Group, assessed the Department of Communities' response to recommendations from the Ombudsman and an internal child protection report. It acknowledged the children's courage, particularly that of one child who repeatedly reported FDV to police and shared concerns about the children's safety.
The review found that at the time of the deaths the department was experiencing increasing workforce pressure across the state. Ongoing challenges include workforce turnover, geographic dispersion and exposure to complex and traumatic circumstances.
Child Protection Minister Jess Stojkovski said on Wednesday the assurance review would not provide the answers sought by the children's family about the deaths, saying those answers would come through the coronial inquest. Attorney General Tony Buti ordered the inquest last month following sustained pressure from the family and the opposition.
Alongside the report, Stojkovski announced $22.6 million in new measures to boost child protection in the Pilbara and other regional areas. This includes $5 million in financial incentives for frontline workers in the Pilbara, Kimberley and Goldfields, rule changes allowing fourth-year social work students to complete a paid final year while having access to a HECS repayment incentive that could cover their tuition costs, expansion of the Aboriginal Family Led Decision-Making program, and $3 million for a new group foster home in Port Hedland.
Despite the report's praise, the South Hedland Child Protection office still has 11 full-time vacancies, according to responses to opposition questions in Parliament last week. Stojkovski acknowledged the difficulty of attracting staff to the region. "It is incredibly hard to get staff there but that's why we have this package today to attract and retain staff," she said.
Stojkovski defended the government's urgency on the issue. "I acted as soon as I could on this issue, I brought the staff up. I brought the chief practitioner in. We've installed the senior coordinator, and we've set up the multi-agency meeting. We've also done the contracting for the safe night spaces," she said.
The deaths have led to calls for Stojkovski to resign; Aboriginal Affairs Minister Don Punch has also been called on to resign in a petition started by prominent WA Indigenous elder Robert Isaacs, which currently has 3000 signatures.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The review confirms that child protection authorities had repeated warnings from a child victim before the murders, raising serious questions about the system's response.
- The $22.6m package signals the government's attempt to address chronic understaffing in remote areas, but persistent vacancies show the scale of the challenge.
- The coronial inquest, ordered last month, will provide a public examination of systemic failures and could lead to further reforms.
Background
Margaret Dale Hawke murdered her three children in Port Hedland in 2022. The case attracted scrutiny after it emerged that an email marked critical sat unopened in the South Hedland child protection office for eight days and was not opened until after the children were killed. The children's grandmother, Dorothy Papertalk, has campaigned for answers, and Attorney General Tony Buti ordered a coronial inquest last month. The Nous Group review was commissioned to assess progress on recommendations from earlier inquiries.
Key Perspectives
Child J (the 10-year-old victim): Repeatedly reported instances of FDV to police and shared concerns about the safety of herself and siblings, according to the review.
Minister Jess Stojkovski: Said the answers sought by the grandmother will come through the coronial inquest, and defended the government's actions, saying she acted as soon as she could.
Dorothy Papertalk (grandmother): Has been critical of the Cook Government's response to her pleas for answers.
Opposition and community: Have called for Stojkovski and Aboriginal Affairs Minister Don Punch to resign; a petition has gathered 3000 signatures.
What to Watch
- The coronial inquest, which will examine the circumstances leading to the children's deaths.
- Whether the $22.6m package reduces the 11 full-time vacancies in South Hedland.
- The political fallout, including potential ministerial resignations or further pressure on the government.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 8 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe review found that one of the three murdered children repeatedly reported family violence to police before the deaths.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““Child J repeatedly reported instances of FDV to police and shared concerns about the safety of herself and siblings,” the report said.”
- SupportedThe WA Government released the assurance review on Wednesday.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The confronting detail was included in the WA Government “assurance review” released Wednesday”
- SupportedMost responses to recommendations from two earlier reviews had been substantially implemented or were on track to implement all recommendations within agreed timeframes.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The report found most responses to the recommendations contained in the two reviews had been “substantially implemented or is on track to implement all the recommendations within the agreed timeframes”.”
- Partly supportedThe review examined the child protection response before the children were murdered.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Nous Group was tasked with assessing the actions of the Department of Communities in response to two separate reports from the Ombudsman and an internal child protection report following the murders”
- SupportedThe review was conducted by Nous Group and assessed the Department of Communities’ response to recommendations from the Ombudsman and an internal child protection report.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Nous Group was tasked with assessing the actions of the Department of Communities in response to two separate reports from the Ombudsman and an internal child protection report following the murders”
- SupportedAt the time of the children’s deaths, the department was experiencing increasing workforce pressure across the state.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “The report found at the time of the children’s deaths “the Department was experiencing increasing workforce pressure across the state.””
- SupportedStojkovski said, “It is incredibly hard to get staff there but that's why we have this package today to attract and retain staff.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““It is incredibly hard to get staff there but that’s why we have this package today to attract and retain staff,” she said.”
- SupportedStojkovski said, “I acted as soon as I could on this issue, I brought the staff up. I brought the chief practitioner in. We've installed the senior coordinator, and we've set up the multi-agency meeting. We've also done the contracting for the safe night spaces.”Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: ““I acted as soon as I could on this issue, I brought the staff up. I brought the chief practitioner in. We’ve installed the senior coordinator, and we’ve set up the multi-agency meeting. We’ve also done the contracting for the safe night spaces,””
- Partly supportedStojkovski said the assurance review would not provide the answers sought by the children’s family about the deaths, and that answers would come through the coronial inquest.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Child Protection Minister Jess Stojkovski said on Wednesday the assurance review would not provide the answers Papertalk sought into the death of her grandchildren. She said those would be found through the coronial inquest”
- Partly supportedThe Attorney General ordered the inquest last month following sustained pressure from the family and the opposition.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “which Attorney General Tony Buti ordered last month following weeks of sustained pressure from Papertalk and the opposition.”
- SupportedStojkovski announced a $22.6 million package of new measures for the Pilbara and other regional areas.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “Alongside announcing the report, Stojkovski announced $22.6 million in new measures to boost the agency in the Pilbara and other regional areas.”
- Partly supportedFourth-year social work students can complete a paid final year while receiving access to a HECS repayment incentive that could cover tuition costs.Sydney Morning Herald - Latest News: “rule changes to allow fourth year social work students to complete their final year in a paid placement while having access to a HECS repayment incentive that could cover their tuition costs.”