Russia's wealthiest businessmen, long silent under Vladimir Putin's rule, are privately imagining what might follow him, with some wondering whether the country could resemble the 1990s, according to analysts. Prokopenko says they are too afraid to make that happen.
An interesting clue came this year from fertiliser magnate Andrey Melnichenko, Russia's eighth-richest man, who surprised observers by giving a rare interview to The Economist. He argued for a change that would bring about an end to one-man rule and said Russia needed to engage more with the world. The interview was described as a bombshell.
Since the full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, the Kremlin has kept the business elite in line through a ruthless policy of carrot and stick, seizing assets from critics and rewarding loyalists with lavish war contracts. Russia now has 155 billionaires with collective wealth of nearly $700bn, a new high, yet privately some are growing restless.
"They'd like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game," said Alexandra Prokopenko, an exiled Russian analyst who has spoken extensively to the country's richest people. Arkady Ostrovsky told the BBC he felt a "historic, political shift" was happening in how the ultra-rich view the future.
Arkady Ostrovsky, a Kremlin-watcher at The Economist who interviewed Melnichenko, said the tycoon seemed to be "genuinely thinking" about his answers rather than giving spin. He said many of the mega-rich feel a "sense of complete dead end, which this war has led Russia to… [an] absence of the future". Some hope for an "oligarchic republic" resembling the 1990s, Ostrovsky said.
Financier and Putin critic Bill Browder said: "They understand that if they were to do anything that would challenge Putin, he would kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid little man." Former Kremlin adviser Dmitry Nekrasov noted that those whose wealth depends on state contracts will feel too afraid in case they lose everything.
Nekrasov said the tycoons' behaviour in coming years will depend in part on their finances. Those with lots of liquid cash will be more confident to "play political games" and jockey for position as they prepare for a post-Putin country. Putin, who turned 74 last month, was asked by Reuters last year if he intended to serve until 2036. He replied: "Only God knows if we have enough health."
The silence of the billionaires at a Kremlin meeting in February 2022, when Putin said he expected them to support the war, has become a feature of the Russian super-rich. None said a word. But even in that silence, there are murmurings.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The attitudes of Russia's super-rich could shape the country's political transition when Putin eventually leaves office, determining whether the country moves toward oligarchy, autocracy or democracy.
- Their immense wealth and connections mean they are likely to try to reassert political influence after decades of being sidelined, potentially pushing Russia back toward the chaotic 1990s-style rule by tycoons.
- The current silence and fear among the elite highlight the repressive nature of the regime and the limits of opposition even among those with the most resources.
Background
Since coming to power in 2000, Vladimir Putin subjugated the oligarchs who had dominated Russia in the 1990s. The jailing of oil magnate Mikhail Khodorkovsky in 2003, after he accused Putin of corruption, served as a warning to others. The 1990s were a period of extreme wealth concentration as state assets were privatized, with rampant corruption and contract killings. Today, the Kremlin keeps the tycoons in line through a mixture of rewards and threats, and Western sanctions have ostracised them internationally.
Key Perspectives
- Andrey Melnichenko: The fertiliser magnate called for an end to one-man rule and for Russia to engage more with the world, in a rare public intervention that analysts say may have had implicit Kremlin approval.
- Bill Browder: Says the tycoons understand that challenging Putin would get them killed; they are treated like "low-level criminals" under Western sanctions and cannot enjoy their wealth freely.
- Alexandra Prokopenko: Notes that tycoons now refer to Putin as "Ded" (granddad) with "a pinch of contempt"; they want a return to a time when they were listened to and understood the rules of the game.
- Dmitry Nekrasov: Says the tycoons have no political cards because their wealth depends on Putin, not the other way round; only those with liquid cash can afford to "play political games" ahead of a transition.
What to Watch
- Whether more tycoons follow Melnichenko's example and speak out publicly, indicating growing confidence or implicit Kremlin permission for limited debate.
- The behaviour of state-dependent versus liquid-wealth tycoons as Putin's eventual departure approaches: those with cash may begin jockeying for position.
- Any signs of a Kremlin crackdown on business figures seen as overstepping or conspiring, which would reaffirm the regime's grip.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedRussia’s super-rich are quietly imagining a future after Putin, according to analysts.BBC News: “And so, quietly, some of their minds are turning to what happens after Putin leaves the scene. That's what I'm told by well-placed analysts, who are immersed in the world of these tycoons.”
- SupportedSome tycoons hope for an “oligarchic republic” after Putin’s departure, but analysts say they are unlikely to act soon.BBC News: “Some of them are hoping that after Putin's departure, the country might become an "oligarchic republic"”
- SupportedRussia’s wealthiest businessmen are privately imagining what might follow Putin, and some wonder whether the country could resemble the 1990s.BBC News: “some members of Russia's once-mighty business elite seem to be imagining a Russia after Putin. They are wondering if, once the president has left office or died, the country might look more like it did in the 1990s”
- SupportedProkopenko says the tycoons are too afraid to make that happen.BBC News: “But at the moment, she says, they are too afraid to make that happen due to Russia's stifling atmosphere.”
- SupportedProkopenko said: “They'd like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game.”BBC News: “"They'd like to return to a time when they were listened to, when they were not stripped of assets and when they understood the rules of the game," says Prokopenko”
- SupportedMelnichenko, described as Russia’s eighth-richest man, gave a rare interview to The Economist earlier this year.BBC News: “Melnichenko, who is known as the world's fertiliser king and is currently Russia's eighth richest man. Earlier this year, he surprised observers by giving an interview to The Economist - a rare thing for a rich Russian to do”
- SupportedMelnichenko argued for a change to end one-man rule and said Russia needed to engage more with the world.BBC News: “he argued for a change that would bring about an end to one-man rule in Russia. He said Russia needs to engage more with the world.”
- Partly supportedRussia has 155 billionaires with collective wealth of nearly $700bn, a new high.BBC News: “today there are more Russian billionaires than ever (155 in total, according to Forbes magazine). Their collective wealth has reached a new high of nearly $700bn (£525bn).”
- SupportedOstrovsky said he felt a “historic, political shift” was happening in how the ultra-rich view the future.BBC News: “says he feels that a "historic, political shift is happening" in terms of how the ultra-rich view the future of the country.”
- SupportedOstrovsky said many mega-rich people feel a “sense of complete dead end, which this war has led Russia to… [an] absence of the future”.BBC News: “many of the country's mega-rich currently feel a "sense of complete dead end, which this war has led Russia to… [an] absence of the future".”
- SupportedBrowder said: “They understand that if they were to do anything that would challenge Putin, he would kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid little man.”BBC News: “"They understand that if they were to do anything that would challenge Putin, he would kill them. And Putin is a very paranoid little man."”
- SupportedPutin turned 74 last month and, when Reuters asked last year if he intended to serve until 2036, replied: “Only God knows if we have enough health.”BBC News: “Putin, who turned 74 last month”