The South Australian government is facing accusations of a policy backflip after Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis said he was 'absolutely fine' with gas-generated power supplying energy to proposed AI data centres, while the state's Data Centre Strategy, released just under five months ago, focused on promoting renewable energy.
Mr Koutsantonis told the ABC that gas could be used to 'firm up' or guarantee ongoing electricity to data centres 'if the sun stops shining or wind stops blowing'. The government's own Data Centre Strategy, released less than five months ago, stated: 'South Australia can produce the clean energy needed, at scale and on time, to power the artificial intelligence revolution'. Under the strategy, new data centres would be required to supply their own power.
Developer Quantum DC, which yesterday announced it was pausing its plans for a 1,200-megawatt data centre at Tungkillo, had previously estimated about 20 per cent of the energy it needed would be supplied by a gas power station to be built on a section of its 220-hectare Adelaide Hills block. The rest was to come from renewables. Apart from Tungkillo, plans are underway for at least three other major data centres in SA, including a $10 billion 800MW facility proposed by Australian company Iren at Bundey near Robertstown, and AI giant Firmus's previously announced plans for data centres near Tailem Bend and Port Augusta.
Conservation Foundation of SA chief executive Kirsty Bevan said using gas to supply energy to SA's data centres would be a 'step backwards' for the government and the climate. 'South Australia has led the nation on renewable energy and is aiming for 100 per cent net renewable electricity by 2027, but that progress could be undermined by proposals to lock in more gas,' she said. Ms Bevan said using gas would also ignore 'community expectations,' adding: 'With energy storage and other backup technologies available to support grid reliability, expanding gas supply for data centres and AI infrastructure is a step backwards.'
When asked about the potential environmental impacts of using gas for data centres, Mr Koutsantonis said: 'Well if you don't let them use gas, they'll use diesel or they'll use coal.'
SA Greens leader Rob Simms called the shift a 'total backflip' and said green-lighting gas projects was a major step away from previous policy. 'This is outrageous,' Mr Simms said. 'We don't need more dirty gas here.' He urged the government to reconsider and proposed a moratorium on data centre construction.
Political parties including the Liberals, One Nation and the Greens have welcomed the pause on the Tungkillo development and united in the upper house to establish a parliamentary inquiry into data centres. The SA government is currently establishing a regulatory framework for AI data centres, with dedicated legislation set to be introduced to parliament this year.
Belinda Dennett, chief executive of national peak body Data Centres Australia, defended the need for gas power generation but said renewables would still have a substantial role. 'I think assuming that suddenly this is all about gas is wrong, there is still a huge commitment to renewable energies,' she said. '[But] If we wait until we've gone through the energy transition, this investment in data centres will have moved elsewhere.'
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The decision could set a precedent for how Australia powers energy-intensive AI infrastructure, potentially locking in fossil fuel use for decades.
- It threatens South Australia's goal of 100% net renewable electricity by 2027 and its reputation as a clean energy leader.
- The outcome will affect billions of dollars in data centre investment and the state's ability to attract the AI industry.
Background
South Australia has been a national leader in renewable energy, with the state aiming for 100% net renewable electricity by 2027. The SA government's Data Centre Strategy, released less than five months ago, promoted the state's renewable energy sector as a key selling point for attracting data centres. The strategy stated the state could produce the clean energy needed to power AI. Developer Quantum DC had estimated about 20% of its energy needs would come from gas for a proposed data centre at Tungkillo, which it has now paused. Plans for at least three other major data centres are underway.
Key Perspectives
Tom Koutsantonis (SA Energy Minister): said he was 'absolutely fine' with gas being used to firm data centres, and argued that without gas, data centres would use diesel or coal.
Kirsty Bevan (Conservation Foundation of SA): said using gas was a 'step backwards' for the climate and ignored community expectations, pointing to energy storage as an alternative.
Rob Simms (SA Greens leader): called the shift a 'total backflip' and 'outrageous', proposing a moratorium on data centre construction.
Belinda Dennett (Data Centres Australia): defended the need for gas, arguing that renewables remain significant and that waiting for the energy transition would see investment move elsewhere.
What to Watch
- The introduction and content of the SA government's dedicated legislation for AI data centres, expected this year.
- The findings of the parliamentary inquiry into data centres, which has support from Liberal, One Nation and Greens MPs.
- Whether other developers follow Quantum DC's lead in pausing or ceasing plans, pending the regulatory framework.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe South Australian government is accused of a backflip over gas for proposed AI data centres.Latest business news: “The South Australian government has been accused of doing a "backflip" by allowing gas-generated power to be used to supply energy for proposed AI data centres.”
- SupportedKoutsantonis said he was “absolutely fine” with gas-generated power supplying proposed AI data centres.Latest business news: “Energy Minister Tom Koutsantonis has told the ABC that he was "absolutely fine" with gas being used to help run the new large-scale centres”
- SupportedThe Data Centre Strategy was released just under five months ago and focused on promoting renewable energy.Latest business news: “The government's own Data Centre Strategy, released just under five months ago, focused on the promotion of the state's renewable energy sector.”
- SupportedThe strategy said South Australia could produce the clean energy needed to power the AI revolution.Latest business news: “"South Australia can produce the clean energy needed, at scale and on time, to power the artificial intelligence revolution".”
- SupportedKoutsantonis said gas could firm up or guarantee ongoing power to data centres when solar or wind generation stops.Latest business news: “gas could be used to "firm" up or guarantee ongoing electricity to data centres "if the sun stops shining or wind stops blowing".”
- SupportedUnder the strategy, new data centres would be required to supply their own power.Latest business news: “As part of the strategy, new data centres would be required to supply their own power.”
- SupportedQuantum DC paused plans yesterday for a 1,200-megawatt data centre at Tungkillo.Latest business news: “Developer Quantum DC, who yesterday announced it was pausing its plans for a 1,200-megawatt data centre at Tungkillo”
- Partly supportedAbout 20 per cent of the Tungkillo centre’s energy was to come from a gas power station, and the rest from renewables.Latest business news: “had previously estimated about 20 per cent of the energy it needed would be supplied by a gas power station... The company had proposed that the rest of the centre's electricity requirement would be supplied by renewables.”
- SupportedAt least three other major data centres are planned in SA, including Iren’s proposed $10 billion, 800MW facility at Bundey and Firmus plans near Tailem Bend and Port Augusta.Latest business news: “Apart from Tungkillo, plans are underway for at least three other major data centres in SA. Australian company Iren proposed a $10 billion 800MW facility at Bundey... while AI giant Firmus previously announced plans for data centres near Tailem Bend and Port Augusta.”
- SupportedKirsty Bevan said gas for SA data centres would be a “step backwards” and said renewable electricity was targeted to reach 100 per cent by 2027.Latest business news: “Kirsty Bevan said the use of gas to supply energy to SA's data centres would be a "step backwards" for the government and the climate. "South Australia has led the nation on renewable energy and is aiming for 100 per cent net renewable electricity by 2027”
- SupportedRob Simms called the shift a “total backflip” and said, “This is outrageous” and “We don't need more dirty gas here.”Latest business news: “"It's a total backflip from where the government was just a few months ago when they gave an assurance to the people of South Australia that these data centres would be self-sufficient, they'd be reliant on renewables." Mr Simms urged the government to reconsider its position... "This is outrageous," Mr Simms said. "We don't need more dirty gas here."”
- SupportedThe government is establishing a regulatory framework for AI data centres, with dedicated legislation to be introduced to parliament this year.Latest business news: “The SA government is currently establishing a regulatory framework for AI data centres, with dedicated legislation set to be introduced to parliament this year.”