Enrolments in special religious education classes have dropped below 10 per cent at some Sydney public high schools, leaving hundreds of students unable to do regular schoolwork during scripture time, data obtained by the Atheist Foundation under freedom of information laws shows.
A snapshot of enrolment data across 10 high schools shows participation in special religious education has mostly declined between 2019 and 2025. At Willoughby Girls High School, only 6 per cent of students opted for religious classes last year. In year 9, six students were enrolled in special religious education and 184 in alternative meaningful activities. At selective schools North Sydney Boys High School and Northern Beaches College Manly Campus, enrolments also fell substantially over the period. Current state rules prohibit teaching regular school work while religious classes are in session. The policy can leave other students under teacher supervision doing other meaningful activities. Some primary schools have also seen drops of 20 percentage points or more in religion class enrolments.
Year 6 student Layla, who attends an inner west public school and asked not to use her surname, said she had experienced the weekly frustration of colouring in or watching children’s movies when she could have been learning. “Those students who don’t subscribe to the religions on offer can do ethics, if a parent volunteer is available, but these classes have limited spaces,” she said. She said that in Australia’s multicultural society, public school students should study all religions from an impartial source. “By educating ourselves about various belief systems, we build important life skills including greater respect for cultures other than our own and increased cultural sensitivity,” she said.
Atheist Foundation of Australia communications manager Steve Marton questioned why the state was facilitating religious instruction when a minority of students enrolled at some schools. “Why can’t they do it at the weekend?” he said.
The NSW Secondary Principals’ Council, the NSW Primary Principals’ Council and the state’s P&C Federation called in 2023 for an urgent review of religious education, citing the fact that thousands of students were missing out on crucial learning time. A 2015 review recommended procedures be revised for secondary schools to allow non-participating students to continue regular classwork, but it was not supported by the previous coalition government.
Greens member for Newtown Jenny Leong has launched a petition calling on Education Minister Prue Car to abolish special religious education classes in public schools. “This is about rejecting an approach that takes public school students out of class for an hour every week, segregating them based on religion, to be instructed by unqualified religious volunteers outside the accountability of the school and curriculum,” she said. “Our public schools should be a place where students can learn openly about the diverse religious faiths in our community, taught by professional teachers.”
A Teachers Federation spokesperson said any education should be delivered in line with an approved curriculum and by a qualified teacher. “Setting time aside for scripture detracts from teaching time, professional learning and extracurricular activities from an already crowded curriculum and school day,” he said.
Car last week expressed support for special religious education, saying it had been part of the state’s public education system since its inception. Opposition education spokesman Mark Speakman also said he supports it. “Having ‘non-sectarian’ public education does not mean shutting the door on faith,” he said. “It means not preferring one faith over another. This instruction helps to develop well-rounded, confident students, who should not be disadvantaged by being enrolled in these classes.”
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Hundreds of students in NSW public schools are losing instructional time each week because rules bar regular teaching during scripture classes, potentially affecting their learning outcomes.
- The debate reflects broader demographic shifts, with the number of Australians reporting no religion rising to 38 per cent in the 2021 census, putting pressure on long-standing practices.
- The issue mobilises multiple stakeholders, parents, principals, teachers, and politicians, calling for a review or abolition of the current system, making it a live policy question for the state government.
Background
Special religious education (scripture) has been part of NSW public schools since the education system began. Students attend classes led by volunteer instructors from various faiths unless their parents opt them out. Those who opt out must do other meaningful activities, but schools are not permitted to teach regular curriculum during the scripture period. A 2015 review recommended allowing non-participating students to continue classwork, but the then-coalition government did not pursue the change. Enrolment data is not routinely published by the Department of Education.
Key Perspectives
Education Minister Prue Car (last week): Expressed support for special religious education, saying it had been part of the state’s public education system since its inception.
Opposition education spokesman Mark Speakman: Also supports it, arguing non-sectarian education does not mean shutting the door on faith, and that instruction helps develop well-rounded, confident students.
Greens MP Jenny Leong: Calls for abolition, saying it segregates students, uses unqualified volunteers, and takes time from an already crowded school day.
NSW Teachers Federation spokesperson: Says religious education should be delivered by qualified teachers as part of the approved curriculum; scripture detracts from teaching time.
Atheist Foundation of Australia (Steve Marton): Questions why the state facilitates religious instruction when a minority of students enrol, suggesting it could be done on weekends.
NSW Secondary Principals’ Council, NSW Primary Principals’ Council, P&C Federation (2023): Called for an urgent review, citing thousands of students missing crucial learning time.
What to Watch
- Whether Education Minister Prue Car will respond to the Greens' petition or call for a review, given cross-party pressure and calls from education bodies.
- How schools will manage scheduling if enrolments continue to fall, particularly whether the department revises the policy banning regular classwork during scripture time.
- Any new enrolment data or court challenge that could force a formal review of the 2015 recommendations.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedLayla said students who do not subscribe to the religions on offer can do ethics if a parent volunteer is available, but the classes have limited spaces.WA Today - Latest News: ““Those students who don’t subscribe to the religions on offer can do ethics, if a parent volunteer is available, but these classes have limited spaces,” she said.”
- SupportedLayla said students should study all religions from an impartial source and that learning about belief systems builds respect and cultural sensitivity.WA Today - Latest News: “She said that in Australia’s multicultural society, public school students should study all religions from an impartial source. “By educating ourselves about various belief systems, we build important life skills including greater respect for cultures other than our own and increased cultural sensitivity,” she said.”
- SupportedSteve Marton asked, “Why can’t they do it at the weekend?”WA Today - Latest News: ““Why can’t they do it at the weekend?” he said.”
- SupportedJenny Leong said the approach takes students out of class weekly, segregates them by religion and has them taught by unqualified religious volunteers outside school and curriculum accountability.WA Today - Latest News: ““This is about rejecting an approach that takes public school students out of class for an hour every week, segregating them based on religion, to be instructed by unqualified religious volunteers outside the accountability of the school and curriculum,” she said.”
- SupportedLeong said public schools should teach students about diverse religious faiths through professional teachers.WA Today - Latest News: ““Our public schools should be a place where students can learn openly about the diverse religious faiths in our community, taught by professional teachers.””
- SupportedThe Teachers Federation spokesperson said setting aside time for scripture detracts from teaching time, professional learning and extracurricular activities in an already crowded school day and curriculum.WA Today - Latest News: ““Setting time aside for scripture detracts from teaching time, professional learning and extracurricular activities from an already crowded curriculum and school day,” he said.”
- SupportedMark Speakman said non-sectarian public education does not mean shutting the door on faith, and that religious instruction helps develop well-rounded, confident students who should not be disadvantaged by enrolling.WA Today - Latest News: ““Having ‘non-sectarian’ public education does not mean shutting the door on faith,” he said. “It means not preferring one faith over another. This instruction helps to develop well-rounded, confident students, who should not be disadvantaged by being enrolled in these classes.””
- SupportedEnrolments in special religious education have fallen below 10 per cent at some Sydney public high schools.WA Today - Latest News: “Enrolments in special religious education classes have dipped below 10 per cent at some public high schools”
- Partly supportedStudents not in religious classes are barred from schoolwork, and advocates and politicians call for reform.WA Today - Latest News: “Greens member for Newtown Jenny Leong has launched a petition calling on Education Minister Prue Car to abolish special religious education class in public schools.”
- SupportedA 10-school snapshot shows special religious education enrolments mostly declined between 2019 and 2025.WA Today - Latest News: “A snapshot of enrolment data, obtained under freedom of information laws, shows numbers in special religious education classes have mostly declined between 2019 and 2025 across 10 high schools.”
- SupportedAt Willoughby Girls High School, 6 per cent of students opted for religious classes last year; year 9 had six students enrolled in special religious education and 184 in alternative meaningful activities.WA Today - Latest News: “The data shows only 6 per cent of students at Willoughby Girls High School opted for religious classes last year. In year 9, there were six students enrolled in special religious education and 184 in alternative meaningful activities.”
- SupportedCurrent rules prohibit teaching regular schoolwork while religious classes are in session.WA Today - Latest News: “Current rules state actual school work cannot be taught while religious classes are in session.”