Smugglers remain resilient as UK ends 'one in, one out' migration deal with France

Asylum seekers in northern France say people smugglers are adapting with multiple contingency plans, undermining UK efforts to stop Channel crossings

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
People smugglers continue to profit from transporting migrants across the English Channel, with asylum seekers in northern France describing them as highly adaptable and determined, even as the UK prepares to scrap its 'one in, one out' migration deal with France.

A smuggler working on a beach near Boulogne-sur-Mer was observed by a Guardian journalist digging up a dinghy buried in a sand dune, assembling it and attaching a motor in what witnesses described as record time. The scene, on a calm day with no French police present, illustrates the ongoing challenge of preventing small boat crossings.

Amad, an asylum seeker from Iraq waiting with about 30 others to cross, said: "The UK government wants to stop the smugglers, but they are smart. They have plan A, plan B and plan C, so there is always a way for them to get people across this sea. For as long as asylum seekers will pay them, there is too much money involved for them to give up."

Another asylum seeker, Omar from Yemen, said the area known as the Jungle "is busier than ever. So many refugees and so many smugglers are here. Everyone wants to cross."

The UK's 'one in, one out' scheme, under which one small boat arrival was forcibly returned to France in exchange for another asylum seeker brought legally to the UK, is being scrapped. Some asylum seekers who were previously removed from the UK under the scheme have reportedly returned to France hoping to cross again.

The scrapping of the deal raises questions about the UK's strategy, with no replacement plan yet detailed by the government. Smugglers show no sign of ceasing operations as demand from asylum seekers remains high.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The UK's ability to manage its borders and deter irregular migration is at stake, with the scrapping of a key bilateral agreement.
  • Asylum seekers risk dangerous crossings, while smuggling networks profit with apparent impunity.
  • The failure to disrupt smuggling operations could embolden more people to attempt the journey, increasing pressure on UK asylum systems.

Background

The English Channel has become a major route for asylum seekers attempting to reach the UK from France, with thousands making the crossing in small boats each year. The UK and French governments have sought various measures to stop the flows, including increased patrols, fencing and the 'one in, one out' deal. That scheme, now being abandoned, was intended to create a deterrent by ensuring the return of some arrivals.

Key Perspectives

Asylum seekers: They view smugglers as essential facilitators who will always find a way, given the desperation of those wanting to reach the UK and the money involved. Smugglers: The source suggests they are highly organised and able to adapt quickly to changing conditions, including law enforcement presence. UK government: While not directly quoted, the decision to scrap the 'one in, one out' deal signals a recognition that it was not working, but leaves a policy gap. Critics: The lack of a clear alternative plan may lead to an increase in crossings and further entrench smuggling networks.

What to Watch

  • Whether the UK announces a new framework for cooperation with France on migration.
  • The number of small boat arrivals in the weeks following the deal's end.
  • Any changes in smuggling tactics or prices as smugglers respond to the policy shift.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe