A sheriff has concluded that the derailment of a passenger train near Stonehaven, Aberdeenshire, in August 2020 could have been avoided if a drain had been constructed and installed correctly. The crash killed driver Brett McCullough, 45, conductor Donald Dinnie, 58, and passenger Christopher Stuchbury, 62.
In her written determination following a Fatal Accident Inquiry (FAI), Sheriff Lesley Johnston found that the drain, built by construction firm Carillion, was not constructed in accordance with its design. The drain was unable to handle the flow of surface water during the intense rainfall on 12 August 2020, leading to debris washing onto the track.
The 06:38 Aberdeen to Glasgow service had been halted due to a landslip and was returning to Aberdeen when it struck the debris at about 73mph. The train derailed and collided with the parapet of bridge 325 over Carron Water. There were only nine people on board due to Covid-19 restrictions; the six survivors were injured.
Sheriff Johnston said Carillion failed to prepare 'as built' drawings of the new drain and provide them to Network Rail. She also found that Network Rail failed to comply with its own standards in place at the time.
She stated: 'On the basis of the evidence, I consider it can safely be concluded there was a defect in a system of work - namely, Network Rail's oversight and management of the construction of the drain and the failure to ensure the drain was constructed properly and in accordance with the design drawings.'
Liam Sumpter, Network Rail Scotland managing director, said: 'The tragedy at Carmont was a terrible day for our railway and our thoughts remain with the families and loved ones of Brett McCullough, Donald Dinnie, and Christopher Stuchbury, along with all those affected by the derailment. Since August 2020, we have been working hard to make our railway safer for our passengers and colleagues, to deliver on the RAIB recommendations and to fully support the FAI process to reach its conclusion. We have made significant changes to how we manage the risk of severe weather since the accident and to increase the resilience of Scotland's railway.'
Kevin Lindsay, Aslef Scottish organiser, said the failings represented 'a staggering level of governance and corporate failure'. He argued the determination shows Scottish corporate homicide laws are 'not fit for purpose and need to be strengthened' and reiterated the union's call for the removal of High Speed Train (HST) rolling stock from the fleet, citing concerns over crashworthiness, a move also backed by the RMT union.
The sheriff did not make any recommendations in her 199-page determination. She noted that the Rail Accident Investigation Branch (RAIB) had already made 20 comprehensive recommendations following its investigation, most of which have been implemented.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The ruling provides a definitive legal conclusion on the causes of a tragedy that has weighed on the Stonehaven community and the UK rail industry for over six years.
- It highlights critical gaps in safety oversight, contractor management, and extreme weather preparation within the rail network.
- The findings support ongoing calls for stronger corporate accountability laws in Scotland, particularly around senior management responsibility for safety.
Background
The 12 August 2020 crash at Carmont, near Stonehaven, was the subject of a 2023 prosecution in which Network Rail was fined £6.7 million for health and safety failings. The Rail Accident Investigation Branch had already identified the drainage system's incorrect installation in its 2022 report. The FAI, held in Aberdeen earlier this year, heard evidence over several weeks.
Key Perspectives
Sheriff Lesley Johnston: found there was a defect in Network Rail's system of work, that Carillion failed to construct the drain to design, and that the deaths could have been prevented.
Network Rail: accepted the findings, expressed condolences, and highlighted significant changes made to weather risk management and rail resilience since the accident.
Aslef: described the failings as a 'staggering level of governance and corporate failure', argued the determination shows Scottish corporate homicide laws are 'not fit for purpose', and reiterated the call to remove HST trains.
RMT: supported the removal of the older intercity fleet and all recommendations improving drainage, earthworks, and weather forecasting.
What to Watch
- Whether the Scottish government responds to Aslef's call to strengthen corporate homicide legislation.
- ScotRail and Network Rail's progress on the outstanding RAIB recommendations and the future of the HST fleet.
- The industry's response to the sheriff's specific critique of subcontractor 'self-assurance' practices.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 3 sources: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe sheriff concluded the Stonehaven derailment could have been avoided if the drain had been built correctly.BBC Scotland: “A train derailment which resulted in the deaths of three men could have been avoided if a drain had been built correctly, a sheriff has concluded.”
- SupportedThe FAI found Network Rail oversight failings and Carillion construction errors led to the 2020 crash that killed three.STV News: “Sheriff Johnston found that if Carillion had constructed the drain in accordance with the design and had not built a bund at the drain site, which formed no part of the design and was the significant cause of the drain’s washout, the deaths could have been prevented.”
- SupportedThe derailment could have been avoided if the drain had been constructed and installed correctly.STV News: “The deaths of three people in a train derailment in Aberdeenshire could have been avoided if a drain had been constructed and installed properly, a sheriff has found.”
- SupportedThe crash killed driver Brett McCullough, 45, conductor Donald Dinnie, 58, and passenger Christopher Stuchbury, 62.BBC Scotland: “Driver Brett McCullough, 45, conductor Donald Dinnie, 58, and passenger Christopher Stuchbury, 62, died in the crash at Carmont, near Stonehaven in Aberdeenshire, in August 2020.”
- SupportedThe sheriff said there was a defect in Network Rail’s oversight and management of the drain’s construction and failure to ensure it was built to the design.BBC Scotland: “On the basis of the evidence, I consider it can safely be concluded there was a defect in a system of work - namely, Network Rail's oversight and management of the construction of the drain and the failure to ensure the drain was constructed properly and in accordance with the design drawings.”
- SupportedCarillion failed to prepare as-built drawings of the drain and provide them to Network Rail, and Network Rail failed to comply with its standards.STV News: “It was also found that Carillion failed to prepare “as built drawings” of the new drain and provide them to Network Rail. ... Network Rail failed to comply with its own standards in place at the time the drain was completed in 2012”
- SupportedThe drain could not handle surface water during intense rainfall on 12 August 2020, and debris washed onto the track.STV News: “the drain was not constructed and installed in accordance with the design and, as a result, could not accommodate the flow of surface water during intense rainfall in the area on August 12, 2020.”
- SupportedThe 06:38 Aberdeen-to-Glasgow service was returning to Aberdeen after being halted because of a landslip and struck debris at about 73mph.The Independent UK: “The train was authorised to return to Stonehaven around 9.28am, and it struck the “washout” from the drain around 9.37am. The determination explained: “When the train collided with the washout, it was travelling at around 73mph”
- SupportedThere were nine people aboard because of Covid restrictions, and the six survivors were injured.BBC Scotland: “There were only nine people on the train due to Covid pandemic restrictions at the time. The six survivors were injured.”
- SupportedLiam Sumpter said the Carmont tragedy was a terrible day for the railway and that Network Rail had made significant changes to manage severe-weather risk and improve resilience.BBC Scotland: “We have made significant changes to how we manage the risk of severe weather since the accident and to increase the resilience of Scotland's railway.”
- SupportedKevin Lindsay described the failings as “a staggering level of governance and corporate failure.”STV News: “The failings of Network Rail and their contractor Carillion, identified by the RAIB report and supported by the FAI determination, represent a staggering level of governance and corporate failure”
- SupportedThe sheriff made no recommendations in her 199-page determination; the RAIB had made 20 recommendations, most of which had been implemented.BBC Scotland: “Sheriff Johnston did not make any recommendations in her 199-page determination. ... those 20 recommendations were “comprehensive and wide-ranging” ... Most of those recommendations have been implemented”