Sunday 4 October 2026
Afternoon EditionRSS
ZOTPAPER

News without the noise

ZOTPAPER
Australia

Swans condemned over Heeney's best and fairest win amid sexual assault investigation

Four players at centre of police probe featured in top 10 of Bob Skilton Medal count

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Sources2 outlets
A sexual assault advocacy group has criticised the Sydney Swans for allowing players at the centre of sexual assault allegations to remain eligible for the club's best and fairest award, after midfielder Isaac Heeney took home the Bob Skilton Medal on Thursday night.

Full Stop Australia chief executive Karen Bevan said the club had taken action on standards in August and the awards night was a chance to show those standards were still being upheld.

"In August the club took action on standards," Ms Bevan said. "[The awards] were a chance to show those standards are still being upheld."

Heeney and teammates Chad Warner, Nick Blakey and James Jordon all featured in the top 10 of polling for the medal, which the club earlier this week recast as an award for the Swans' "most valuable player".

The four players remain persons of interest in an unfolding investigation by Victoria Police into allegations of sexual assault made by three exotic dancers in a suite of the Pullman Hotel in the pre-dawn hours of August 17.

All of the men deny any wrongdoing and maintain their innocence. No charges have been laid, and the police investigation is ongoing.

The club has defended the players' eligibility, with the club boss saying they deserve the presumption of innocence, according to reporting from the awards night.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The outcome of the Victoria Police investigation will determine whether charges are laid, with major implications for the players and the club.
  • The controversy highlights how sporting clubs balance the presumption of innocence against their own stated behavioural standards.
  • The club's decision to recast the award's messaging midweek has raised questions about how it wants to be perceived while the probe continues.

Background

Australian football clubs have faced growing scrutiny over how they respond to allegations of serious misconduct against players. The presumption of innocence is a central legal principle, but clubs also present themselves as setting behavioural standards. The Swans' handling of this awards night has drawn attention because it brings those two considerations into direct tension.

Key Perspectives

Full Stop Australia: The club took action on standards in August, and the awards ceremony was a chance to show those standards are still being upheld. Honouring players under investigation sends the wrong message.

Sydney Swans: The club recast the Bob Skilton Medal messaging as a "most valuable player" award and kept the four players eligible, with the club boss saying they deserve the presumption of innocence while no charges have been laid.

Critics and sceptics: The rebadging of the award may be seen as cosmetic, and featuring players at the centre of allegations in the top 10 could undermine public confidence, particularly for survivors of sexual violence.

What to Watch

  • Whether Victoria Police lays charges as the investigation concludes.
  • Any further action the Swans or the AFL take regarding the four players' status.
  • Whether the "most valuable player" framing becomes permanent or is revised at next year's count.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workReport an errorSubscribe