They fled Russia, but the West sent them back: deportees describe fear and military call-up in Moscow

BBC reports rising numbers of anti-war Russians forcibly returned from Western countries

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Russian security services were waiting when a US deportation flight landed in Moscow in December, according to the BBC, as the number of anti-war Russians forcibly returned from Western countries rises. One deportee, identified only as Katya, said the FSB handed military papers to the men on the flight, requiring them to register with local enlistment offices.

The BBC spoke to Katya, a Russian woman who fled the country and claimed asylum in the US two years earlier after Russia launched its full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022. Her asylum application was rejected by US authorities, despite what she says was evidence that she took part in protests and belonged to an opposition movement.

"It was unbelievably frightening. My knees were shaking with fear," she said. Her name has been changed to protect her identity because she remains in Russia.

In Moscow, Katya said officers from the FSB security service gave all the male deportees on the flight military papers, requiring them to register with the local enlistment office, from where men are often sent to fight in Ukraine. Another passenger on the flight and an activist confirmed her account.

The case highlights a broader shift. When Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, many countries publicly welcomed Russians fleeing the war. More than four years later, the BBC reports, attitudes have hardened and the numbers of anti-war Russians forcibly returned from Western countries is rising.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Russian returnees who publicly opposed the war face potential conscription and state scrutiny, a risk the BBC says is growing as Western countries return more anti-war Russians.
  • The case raises questions about how asylum systems weigh political dissent and protest activity against the legal tests for refugee status.
  • It also shows how deportations can feed Russia's military mobilisation effort through enlistment registration on arrival.

Background

After Russia's full-scale invasion of Ukraine in 2022, many Western countries publicly welcomed Russians fleeing conscription or opposition to the war. More than four years on, official and public attitudes have hardened, and the number of anti-war Russians forcibly returned from the West is rising. Asylum decisions are made case by case, and applicants must persuade authorities that they face a well-founded risk of persecution at home.

Key Perspectives

Deported activists: They say they face danger on return, pointing to the FSB's presence at the airport and the issuing of military registration papers to men on the December flight. Western governments and asylum officials: They assess claims on their merits; in Katya's case, US authorities rejected her application despite her evidence of protest participation and opposition membership. Critics and refugee advocates: They argue that sending anti-war Russians back exposes them to potential prosecution or military service, and weakens the protection Western countries offered at the start of the war.

What to Watch

  • The number of Russian asylum seekers deported from the US and other Western countries in coming months.
  • Whether returnees in Russia report conscription or other security service attention.
  • Any legal or political challenges to the handling of Russian asylum claims in Western courts.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe