Tom Watson warns against 'mob rule' in awarding government contracts after joining Palantir

Former Labour deputy leader says ministers risk 'a lot of trouble' if they bow to public pressure

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time2 min
Tom Watson, the former Labour deputy leader who recently joined US tech firm Palantir as a senior vice-president, has warned that UK ministers must not let 'mob rule' dictate how public contracts are awarded, as the company faces mounting political backlash over its deepening involvement in British public services.

In an interview on the BBC podcast Political Thinking with Nick Robinson, Lord Watson said UK ministers could get themselves "in a lot of trouble" if they let public opinion override the rule of law in procurement. His comments come as Prime Minister Andy Burnham faces significant pressure from Labour MPs and unions to drop Palantir from government contracts, including a £330 million software deal with the NHS.

Palantir, co-founded by billionaire Peter Thiel, has provided AI-powered software to the Israeli military and the White House's ICE immigration crackdown, sparking protests. The company is also fighting London Mayor Sadiq Khan in court after he blocked a £50 million contract to use its AI in Metropolitan Police investigations. Palantir already has an annual turnover of £427 million in the UK.

Watson told the podcast: "One of the things I'd say to my former colleagues is: do you want to let the rule of law to lead procurement practice, or do you want to let mob rule to lead procurement practices?" He added that the company is "very targeted by the people that are targeting Israeli companies" due to its work in Israel.

When asked if he would work with a Reform UK government on immigration crackdowns, Watson said: "We don't actually work in that sector, but yes, of course we would."

Watson, who served as a defence minister and minister for digital engagement under Gordon Brown, stepped down from parliament in 2019. He has taken a leave of absence from the House of Lords and relinquished his parliamentary pass while working for Palantir, which he called "the most interesting company on the planet" when announcing his new role last month. The company said his job includes deepening "the social and economic value its work creates through better British public services, jobs and skills".

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The debate over Palantir's contracts tests the UK government's willingness to prioritise ethical concerns over technological efficiency.
  • The outcome could set precedent for how AI and surveillance companies engage with public services amid public backlash.
  • Internal Labour divisions threaten the stability of Burnham's government as allies demand a break with the firm.

Background

Tom Watson was deputy leader of the Labour Party from 2015 to 2019 and held ministerial roles in Gordon Brown's government. After leaving parliament, he advised the gambling and music industries before becoming a part-time adviser to Palantir in 2024. He now works as a senior vice-president at the company, which was co-founded by Peter Thiel and is known for its work with US defence and immigration enforcement agencies. Palantir already generates £427 million in annual UK turnover and is pursuing more public sector contracts.

Key Perspectives

Palantir and supporters: Argue that the rule of law should guide procurement, not public sentiment, and that the company's technology improves public service efficiency. Labour MPs and unions: Claim Palantir's human rights record, particularly its work with the Israeli military and ICE, makes it an unacceptable partner for the NHS and police. Critics/Skeptics: Question whether Watson's appointment is an attempt to greenwash the company's reputation and worry that ethical scrutiny is being dismissed as 'mob rule'.

What to Watch

  • Whether the NHS proceeds with the £330 million software deal under mounting political pressure.
  • The outcome of Palantir's legal challenge against Sadiq Khan's block on the Met police contract.
  • Any further defections or public statements from Labour MPs demanding a break with the company.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe