A knifeman accused of attempting to kill passengers on a moving train had a delusional belief his life was threatened by a “conspiracy by the devil”, a court has heard. Anthony Williams, 33, denies 10 counts of attempted murder on a Doncaster to London King's Cross service, as well as four other attempted murder charges, including an attack on a teenager on a DLR train in east London. Cambridge Crown Court heard defence psychiatrist Dr Bernard Chin say Williams was suffering from an acute relapse of schizophrenia at the time of the alleged offences.
Dr Bernard Chin, a consultant forensic psychiatrist instructed by the defence, gave evidence that Williams was diagnosed with schizophrenia, an opinion shared with a prosecution expert. Chin said Williams "had what we call paranoid persecutory delusions, meaning he had ideas and beliefs that people were going to harm him and that this was an organised conspiracy that came about due to… the devil".
The trial relates to an attack on an LNER train travelling to London on 1 November last year, which made an unscheduled stop at Huntingdon in Cambridgeshire. The previous evening, Williams is accused of attempting to murder three people in Peterborough, including two on a footbridge over the River Nene.
The court heard Williams had contacted his GP on 30 September, highlighting his deteriorating mental state and that his medication was not working. A report by a psychiatrist noted the defendant believed there was a “conspiracy organised by the devil against him and everyone was part of the conspiracy against him”. Jones, summarising the report, said Williams had stopped taking quetiapine three days before the attack because it was not working, though he acknowledged the voices got worse after.
Williams was reported to have said he heard announcements on the train's speakers saying “these people are going to attack you”. Jurors heard Williams tell Dr Chin: “I just needed to protect myself. It was me or them.”
While the fact of the attacks is not in dispute, the jury must determine whether Williams intended to kill. Chin said Williams retained the capacity to form intent, and the defence of insanity had not been met. Williams' barrister, Gillian Jones KC, told jurors her client would not give evidence. The judge, Mr Justice Calver, warned the jury not to hold this against the defendant, saying: “You must not hold this against him in any way.”
The trial continues.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The case highlights the complex intersection of severe mental illness and the criminal justice system, specifically how the law addresses intent and responsibility in cases involving psychosis.
- It raises questions about the adequacy of community mental health support, given Williams contacted his GP complaining his medication was not working shortly before the attacks.
- The outcome will have significant implications for the victims and public confidence in the safety of rail travel.
Background
Anthony Williams is on trial at Cambridge Crown Court for a series of knife attacks across Peterborough and on public transport in November last year. The most serious charges relate to an attack on a London-bound LNER train during which passengers intervened to stop him. The current phase of the trial is hearing the defence case, centering on the psychiatric evidence of Dr Bernard Chin.
Key Perspectives
Defence Psychiatrist (Dr Bernard Chin): Diagnosed Williams with schizophrenia and stated he was suffering paranoid persecutory delusions at the time of the attacks, believing his life was threatened by a devil-led conspiracy. He argued Williams retained the capacity to form intent.
Prosecution: Alleges Williams attempted to murder 10 people on the train and three others in Peterborough, and one teenager on a DLR train, arguing his actions were intentional despite his mental state.
Judge (Mr Justice Calver): Instructed the jury not to hold against Williams the fact he has not given evidence in his own defence.
What to Watch
- The jury's verdict on whether Williams intended to kill, which is the central issue in the trial given his psychiatric condition.
- The potential sentence if convicted, or a possible hospital order under the Mental Health Act.
- Any subsequent reviews into the mental health care provided to Williams prior to the attacks.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedWilliams was said to believe his life was threatened by a conspiracy by the devil.BBC News: “A knifeman accused of trying to kill passengers on a moving train had a delusional belief his life was at risk because of a "conspiracy by the devil", a court has heard.”
- SupportedWilliams was diagnosed with schizophrenia.BBC News: “Cambridge Crown Court heard Dr Bernard Chin, a consultant forensic psychiatrist instructed by the defence, diagnosed Williams with schizophrenia.”
- SupportedWilliams denies 10 counts of attempted murder on the Doncaster-to-King’s Cross service.BBC News: “Anthony Williams denies 10 counts of attempted murder on a Doncaster to London King's Cross service”
- SupportedWilliams denies four other attempted-murder counts.BBC News: “Williams, 33, of Langford Road, Peterborough, denies four other counts of attempted murder in relation to earlier attacks in his home city and London.”
- SupportedOne of the other charges concerns an alleged attempted murder of a teenager on a DLR train in east London.BBC News: “He is also charged with attempting to murder a teenager in the early hours of 1 November on a DLR train in east London.”
- SupportedChin described Williams as having “paranoid persecutory delusions” and quoted the belief that people would harm him in a conspiracy caused by the devil.BBC News: “He said Williams "had what we call paranoid persecutory delusions, meaning he had ideas and beliefs that people were going to harm him and that this was an organised conspiracy that came about due to… the devil".”
- SupportedChin said Williams was suffering an acute relapse of schizophrenia at the time of the alleged offences.BBC News: “Chin said he was satisfied Williams had been "suffering from an acute relapse of schizophrenia at the time of each of the alleged offences".”
- SupportedThe LNER train attack was on 1 November last year, and the train made an unscheduled stop at Huntingdon.BBC News: “Anthony Williams denies 10 counts of attempted murder on a Doncaster to London King's Cross service which had to make an unscheduled stop at Huntingdon in Cambridgeshire on 1 November last year.”
- SupportedThe previous evening, Williams was accused of attempting to murder three people in Peterborough, including two on a footbridge over the River Nene.BBC News: “He is accused of attempting to murder three people in Peterborough - two of them on a footbridge over the River Nene - on 31 October, the day before the attack on the LNER service.”
- SupportedA psychiatrist’s report said Williams believed there was a conspiracy organised by the devil against him and that everyone was part of it.BBC News: “It had noted Williams thought there had been a "conspiracy organised by the devil against him and everyone was part of the conspiracy against him".”
- SupportedWilliams was reported to have said train announcements told him, “these people are going to attack you”.BBC News: “On the LNER service, he was reported to have said he had heard announcements on the train's speakers saying "these people are going to attack you".”
- SupportedWilliams told Chin, “I just needed to protect myself. It was me or them.”BBC News: “Jurors heard Williams had said to Chin: "I just needed to protect myself. It was me or them."”