The Trump administration is finalising a rule to reimburse doctors who diagnose, treat and counsel patients with side effects from vaccines, as HHS Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has announced a vaccine 'injury' research centre and sought to reshape the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program, moves that experts believe are an attempt to undermine trust in vaccines and that they say are likely to make money for Kennedy or his associates.
The administration is finalising a rule to reimburse doctors who diagnose, treat and counsel patients with side effects from vaccines. Kennedy, a longtime vaccine sceptic, has also sought to restructure the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP), a 1986 system that expedites compensation for people who experience adverse side effects from vaccination.
Emily Hilliard, an HHS spokesperson, said the department “categorically reject claims that Secretary Kennedy is pursuing personal gain or seeking to dismantle American medicine”.
But experts said the changes risk creating the wrong incentives. Dorit Reiss, professor of law at UC Law San Francisco, said compensating doctors for VAERS reports could offer “the wrong incentives” to unscrupulous providers who might treat reporting as a new revenue source. “I do think he’s a real ideologue – he really believes in this,” Reiss said. Kennedy and his allies are likely “very happy to make money doing it”, she added.
Peter Hotez, dean of Baylor College of Medicine’s National School of Tropical Medicine, agreed, saying Kennedy’s actions are likely a combination of “being an ideological zealot and making money either for himself or for his associates”. Hotez said such actions appear intended to “completely wipe out American medicine as we know it in favour of this whole system of grifting and pseudoscience”.
Before his confirmation hearing in January 2025, Kennedy disclosed $2.5m in income from referrals for vaccine-related lawsuits. He would not commit to forgoing compensation from such lawsuits after leaving office. Tony Lyons, Kennedy’s publisher, reportedly paid him $4m in book advances over the past year and $451,000 in consulting fees before he became HHS secretary. Kennedy also earned $326,000 for 15 weeks as chairman of Children’s Health Defense in 2023.
Senator Elizabeth Warren, a Democrat from Massachusetts, warned at the hearing: “Kennedy can kill off access to vaccines and make millions of dollars while he does it. Kids might die. But Robert Kennedy can keep cashing in.” She highlighted Kennedy’s involvement in litigation against Merck for its HPV vaccine, which was settled for more than $50m in June 2026. Kennedy said his son would receive the expected 10% of the settlement; it is unclear if he did.
Aaron Siri, Kennedy’s former lawyer who represents people claiming severe vaccine side effects, has advocated for changing all vaccines to “shared clinical decision-making”. If those changes took place, Siri could argue that the vaccines would not be covered under VICP, potentially opening them to lawsuits. Siri did not respond to the Guardian’s question about profiting from litigation, but argued that “if vaccines are as ‘safe’ as touted by the government, then there should be no need for immunity to liability and, likewise, there should be very few, if any, successful cases”.
The most common claims to VICP, more than half, concern where the vaccine is administered rather than the vaccines themselves. Hotez noted that VAERS, alongside several other vaccine monitoring systems, works well to pick up signals of very rare side effects, but is not built to prove links between vaccines and certain side effects. “The VAERS system was never meant to show cause and effect,” he said.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The rule could incentivise doctors to report vaccine side effects, potentially amplifying unfounded safety concerns and undermining vaccination rates.
- Financial conflicts of interest at the highest level of HHS raise questions about whether public health policy is being shaped for private gain.
- If VICP is weakened, people with legitimate rare vaccine injuries could face more costly and lengthy litigation instead of streamlined compensation.
Background
The Vaccine Injury Compensation Program was established in 1986 to provide a no-fault alternative to lawsuits for people who experience rare side effects from vaccines. The program is funded by a tax on each vaccine dose. Robert F. Kennedy Jr. has long promoted disproven links between vaccines and autism, and his organisations have profited from anti-vaccine products and litigation referrals.
Key Perspectives
Dorit Reiss (law professor): Says Kennedy is an ideologue but also motivated by profit; the changes could give unscrupulous providers “wrong incentives” and be used to legitimise misinformation.
Peter Hotez (medical school dean): Calls Kennedy’s actions a mix of zealotry and profiteering, aimed at dismantling American medicine in favour of pseudoscience.
Emily Hilliard (HHS spokesperson): “Categorically reject claims that Secretary Kennedy is pursuing personal gain or seeking to dismantle American medicine.”
Elizabeth Warren (Senator): Warns Kennedy can kill access to vaccines and make millions; his actions could influence future litigation.
Aaron Siri (former Kennedy lawyer): Argues that if vaccines are as safe as claimed, there should be no immunity from liability and few successful cases.
What to Watch
- Finalisation of the reimbursement rule and its impact on VAERS reporting volume.
- Congressional investigations into Kennedy’s financial ties, including gifts from a former donor under Senate scrutiny.
- Whether changes to VICP or vaccine recommendations open the door to new litigation against vaccine manufacturers.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe Trump administration is finalizing a rule to reimburse doctors who diagnose, treat and counsel patients with vaccine side effects.World news | The Guardian: “The Trump administration is finalizing a rule to reimburse doctors who diagnose, treat and counsel patients with side effects from vaccines”
- SupportedExperts say Kennedy’s actions may undermine trust in vaccines.World news | The Guardian: “in what experts believe is an attempt to undermine trust in vaccines”
- SupportedExperts say the actions may create a more profitable litigation atmosphere.World news | The Guardian: ““A lot of what he is doing is geared toward setting up a more profitable litigation atmosphere,” Reiss said.”
- SupportedKennedy announced the creation of a vaccine “injury” research center at the NIH.World news | The Guardian: “Robert F Kennedy Jr, the secretary of the US Department of Health and Human Services (HHS), also announced the creation of a vaccine “injury” research center at the National Institutes of Health”
- SupportedKennedy has sought to reshape the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program.World news | The Guardian: “has sought to reshape the Vaccine Injury Compensation Program (VICP)”
- SupportedHilliard said HHS “categorically reject claims that Secretary Kennedy is pursuing personal gain or seeking to dismantle American medicine”.World news | The Guardian: “Emily Hilliard, an HHS spokesperson, said the department “categorically reject claims that Secretary Kennedy is pursuing personal gain or seeking to dismantle American medicine”.”
- SupportedReiss said compensating doctors for VAERS reports could offer “the wrong incentives” to unscrupulous providers.World news | The Guardian: “Compensating doctors for reporting side effects to the Vaccine Adverse Event Reporting System (VAERS) risks offering “the wrong incentives” to unscrupulous providers”
- SupportedReiss said, “I do think he’s a real ideologue – he really believes in this.”World news | The Guardian: ““I do think he’s a real ideologue – he really believes in this,” said Dorit Reiss”
- SupportedReiss said Kennedy and his allies are likely “very happy to make money doing it”.World news | The Guardian: “But Kennedy and his allies are likely “very happy to make money doing it”, she said.”
- SupportedHotez said Kennedy’s actions are likely a combination of ideological zealotry and making money for himself or associates.World news | The Guardian: “Peter Hotez, professor and dean of Baylor College of Medicine’s National School of Tropical Medicine, agreed, saying Kennedy’s actions are likely a combination of “being an ideological zealot and making money either for himself or for his associates”.”
- SupportedWarren said, “Kennedy can kill off access to vaccines and make millions of dollars while he does it. Kids might die. But Robert Kennedy can keep cashing in.”World news | The Guardian: ““Kennedy can kill off access to vaccines and make millions of dollars while he does it,” Warren said at the hearing. “Kids might die. But Robert Kennedy can keep cashing in.””
- SupportedThe Merck HPV-vaccine lawsuits involving Kennedy were settled for more than $50 million in June 2026.World news | The Guardian: “She pointed to Kennedy’s involvement in litigation against Merck for its HPV vaccine – lawsuits that were settled for more than $50m in June 2026.”