Asked why he would not officially declare an end to the Iran war, Trump said some Gulf allies could still face Iranian aggression, following White House talks with Qatar’s prime minister. He described renewed US attacks as unlikely but said American forces remained ready to act.
Asked why he would not officially end the conflict, Trump told reporters: “We have some great allies there and we have to make sure they're not hurt.” He suggested the US naval blockade on Iranian ports was helping secure the region and said there was “positive momentum” behind negotiations.
The war began with joint US-Israeli strikes in February. Negotiations have largely proceeded indirectly through mediators, and a memorandum of understanding signed in Islamabad in June expired in August after talks broke down. Saudi Arabia, Qatar and the United Arab Emirates have faced Iranian attacks during the conflict.
Trump’s latest assessment, that the war “militarily is effectively over”, followed his meeting with Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman Al Thani. The prime minister said on X that he had held “positive discussions” with Trump and Vice President JD Vance about reaching an agreement and bringing peace to the region.
But US Secretary of State Marco Rubio offered a more guarded assessment ahead of the meeting. “I wouldn’t say we’re at the verge of a breakthrough,” he said. On Sunday, he described Iran’s conditions as “not just unacceptable, but in some cases, outrageous and ridiculous and really not realistic.”
Tehran’s proposal envisages a two-day sequence: Washington would lift its naval blockade and release some frozen Iranian assets, while Iran would invite international inspectors to its bombed nuclear sites. The Strait of Hormuz would reopen on the second day, followed by renewed nuclear talks. Iran first wants agreement on seven conditions, including sanctions relief, reinstated oil waivers and an end to hostilities across the region.
Iranian Foreign Ministry spokesman Esmail Baghaei rejected Rubio’s criticism on Monday. “Iran’s plan is still the most logical plan on the table,” he said, arguing that it could restore security to the Strait of Hormuz and the Persian Gulf. Tehran maintains its nuclear programme is peaceful and says it would consider reducing the enrichment level of its uranium rather than surrendering the material.
Limited military action has continued alongside diplomacy. Ahmad Nafisi, deputy governor of Iran’s Hormozgan province, said overnight US strikes targeted Qeshm Island but damaged no residential or commercial areas or vital infrastructure. Al Jazeera reported that Washington had not directly acknowledged those particular strikes; Rubio has characterised similar recent operations as defensive.
Post-election recriminations over the Iran war are placing pressure on members of the Trump administration, after Republicans lost both chambers of Congress in last week’s midterm elections. Republican Representative Thomas Massie sought a House vote on impeaching Defence Secretary Pete Hegseth on Monday. Trump backed Hegseth, calling Massie’s effort a “sham”. Democrats have expressed willingness to pursue impeachment when they take control in January, according to the BBC.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- Trump’s reluctance to declare the conflict over leaves the US blockade and military readiness in place despite his assessment that major combat is effectively finished.
- The sequencing dispute remains central: Tehran wants economic and security concessions before nuclear negotiations resume, while Washington rejects its conditions.
- Continued strikes and uncertainty over shipping through the Strait of Hormuz give the negotiations immediate consequences for Gulf security and trade.
Background
The Strait of Hormuz connects Gulf oil exporters with international markets, making access to the waterway a concern beyond the countries directly involved in the war. A reduction in large-scale fighting does not itself resolve disputes over shipping, sanctions or nuclear inspections.
The earlier Islamabad understanding provides a diplomatic reference point, but its expiry left the parties negotiating both the terms of de-escalation and the order in which commitments would take effect.
Key Perspectives
Donald Trump: Says renewed attacks are unlikely but maintains that US forces must remain ready and Gulf allies must be protected.
Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed: Describes his discussions with Trump and Vance as positive and focused on reaching an agreement.
Marco Rubio: Rejects Iran’s conditions and doubts that negotiations are close to a breakthrough.
Iranian government: Defends its proposal as a route to regional security and insists on sanctions relief and other conditions before nuclear talks.
What to Watch
- Whether mediators secure agreement on the order of blockade relief, asset releases, inspections and reopening the strait.
- Whether limited strikes or attacks on shipping disrupt the diplomatic effort.
- Whether the impeachment push against Hegseth gains support as control of Congress changes in January.
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 4 sources: 12 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedQatar’s prime minister reported positive discussions with Trump and Vice President JD Vance about reaching a deal and bringing peace to the region.BBC News: “In a post on X, the Qatari prime minister said he held "positive discussions" with Trump and Vice-President JD Vance on "reaching a deal and bringing peace to the region".”
- SupportedThe US and Iran remain divided over the terms for peace.Foreign Policy: “But as Washington and Tehran remain unwilling to make concessions to end the war, senior officials appear to be pessimistic about the likelihood of an imminent peace deal.”
- SupportedRubio said the sides were not on the verge of a breakthrough.Foreign Policy: ““I wouldn’t say we’re at the verge of a breakthrough,” U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio said ahead of Monday’s talks.”
- SupportedIranian officials defended Tehran’s conditions for ending the conflict.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: ““Iran’s plan is still the most logical plan on the table. I think it can lead to security returning to the Strait of Hormuz and the Persian Gulf, and create the grounds for a process,” Baghaei said during a news conference in Tehran.”
- SupportedAsked why he would not officially declare an end to the conflict, Trump said some Gulf allies could still face Iranian aggression, after talks with Qatar’s prime minister.BBC News: “Responding to a question over why he would not officially declare an end to the conflict, Trump said that some of the Gulf allies could still face Iranian aggression. Trump hosted Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdul Rahman Al Thani in the Oval Office earlier on Monday”
- SupportedTrump said, “We have some great allies there and we have to make sure they're not hurt.”BBC News: ““We have some great allies there and we have to make sure they're not hurt,” Trump said”
- SupportedTrump described renewed US attacks as unlikely and said US forces were ready to act.BBC News: “Trump said that renewed US attacks on Iran were "highly unlikely" but that the US was "locked and loaded" should the circumstances change.”
- SupportedTrump’s latest assessment was that the war was “militarily is effectively over,” following his meeting with Qatar’s prime minister.BBC News: “Donald Trump says the Iran war "militarily is effectively over" declaring that there is "positive momentum" behind negotiations to end the Middle East conflict. ... Trump hosted Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdul Rahman Al Thani in the Oval Office earlier on Monday”
- SupportedThe war began with joint US-Israeli strikes in February.BBC News: “Efforts to broker a peace between Washington and Tehran have largely been held indirectly through mediators since the war first broke out following joint US-Israeli strikes in February.”
- SupportedA memorandum of understanding signed in Islamabad in June expired in August after talks broke down.DW English: “The most tangible diplomatic achievement since the start of the war was reported in June, when Iran and the US signed a memorandum of understanding in Islamabad. But the talks broke down and the memorandum expired in August”
- SupportedIran’s two-day proposal would have the US lift its naval blockade and release some frozen assets on day one, with Iran inviting inspectors to its bombed nuclear sites; the Strait would reopen on day two and nuclear talks would then resume.Foreign Policy: “Day one would have the U.S. military lift its naval blockade on Iranian ports and release some of Tehran’s frozen assets. In exchange, Iran would invite the International Atomic Energy Agency to send inspectors to its bombed nuclear sites. Day two would then see the Strait of Hormuz reopened, after which nuclear talks would resume.”
- SupportedAhmad Nafisi said overnight US strikes targeted Qeshm Island and damaged no residential or commercial areas or vital infrastructure.Al Jazeera – Breaking News, World News and Video from Al Jazeera: “Ahmad Nafisi, deputy governor for Hormozgan, where the overnight US strikes hit, confirmed on Monday morning that the southern island of Qeshm was targeted but no residential and commercial areas or vital infrastructure were damaged.”