Trump's farm belt support fractures as Nebraska voters weigh sitting out midterms

Higher diesel and fertiliser costs tied to Iran conflict drive conservative farmers away from the president

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
A fourth-generation Nebraska farmer who voted for Donald Trump three times says he will not do so again, the latest sign that the president's rural base is fracturing ahead of the November 3 midterm elections, with Republican control of both chambers of Congress in doubt.

Farmers have been one of Donald Trump's most reliable voting blocs, but a growing number say they are abandoning him, and some may not vote at all in the November 3 midterm elections, putting Republican control of Congress further at risk.

Scott Thomsen, a 39-year-old fourth-generation farmer in Kennard, Nebraska, voted for Trump three times. He says he will not do so again. "I think there is a large demographic of people my age that are conservative that voted for Trump that are really unhappy with how it went," he said.

Mr Thomsen, who farms corn, alfalfa, soybean and cattle calf, said he expected a bumper year but has watched diesel and fertiliser prices surge by 40 per cent, with some equipment now costing three times what it once did.

"He did close the border [with Mexico], which he doesn't get enough credit for. But everything else, this war with Iran, has inflated prices and created more costs for us," he said.

The conflict has effectively closed the Strait of Hormuz, choking a global shipping route for fuel and other supplies farmers rely on. Mr Thomsen said he cannot bring himself to vote Democrat but is so let down by the president's party that he will probably stay home.

That is the dilemma facing Republicans. The party appears likely to lose control of the House of Representatives, and its 53-47 Senate majority is under pressure in once safe states. In Nebraska, where Trump won by more than 20 percentage points in 2024, Republican Senator Pete Ricketts is in a surprisingly competitive race.

Trump has responded with a campaign blitz through normally safe territory, including Texas, Alabama, Oklahoma, Alaska and Nebraska, where he pledged to expand access to tax-exempt diesel fuel in a nod to the costs farmers and truckers face.

"It's going to come down to which party can get their base out to the polls," said Bryan McQuide, professor of political science at Grand View University. "The race is a lot closer than it normally would be and that's one big signal that something's up."

Nearly seven in 10 rural voters backed Trump in the 2024 election, according to the Pew Research Center. Dr McQuide said rural America was now facing a difficult conundrum.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Rural voters were a cornerstone of Trump's 2024 coalition, with nearly seven in 10 supporting him, so erosion among farmers threatens the Republican base.
  • Control of both chambers is at stake: the House is likely to flip and the 53-47 Senate majority is under threat in states that should be safe.
  • The farm cost squeeze is tied to the closure of the Strait of Hormuz, linking the election outcome to the course of the Iran conflict.

Background

Midterm elections are commonly treated as a verdict on the incumbent president, and the president's party typically loses ground in them. Farmers have leaned Republican for many cycles, making their discontent significant. This year, rising fuel and fertiliser costs driven by the war with Iran and the closure of a major shipping route have become a pocketbook issue that cuts across party loyalty, testing whether economic pain outweighs political allegiance.

Key Perspectives

Conservative farmers: Voters like Scott Thomsen feel let down by rising costs but have not shifted to the Democrats; the risk for Republicans is that they stay home. The White House: Trump is campaigning in solidly Republican states and promising targeted relief, such as tax-exempt diesel, to shore up the farm vote. Democrats: Polls suggest the party is increasingly optimistic about winning the Senate, with competitive races emerging in states such as Nebraska.

What to Watch

  • Rural turnout on November 3, which both parties identify as the decisive factor.
  • The Nebraska Senate race, where Pete Ricketts is under pressure in a state Trump won by more than 20 points.
  • Diesel and fertiliser prices: any easing of the Strait of Hormuz closure could relieve farm costs before election day.

Sources

Zotpaper

Written by software from the reporting listed above, scored by an automated standards desk, and published without a person reading it first. If something here is wrong, tell the editor and it will be put right.

How we workSubscribe