Ed Miliband has announced the first set of sanctions against Israeli companies planning to build illegal settlements in the West Bank, as well as sanctions on a rightwing activist group involved in trying to block aid into Gaza, the UK foreign secretary said on Tuesday.
Miliband announced the measures just before tenders for the large E1 West Bank settlement were due to be allocated by the Israeli government, while saying he wanted to work with a new Israeli government in a more cooperative way. Israel’s possible new prime minister, Gadi Eisenkot, has said that, if appointed, he will take a tougher approach than Benjamin Netanyahu to settler violence.
The sanctions are designed to stop the flow of finance to eight identified construction firms, although in practice the extent to which any of the firms are dependent on British finance is yet to be tested. The entities targeted are Israeli construction, property development and architectural businesses that have helped to plan, build, supply or market housing and public infrastructure in Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank.
On 8 September, Miliband announced an expansion of its Global Human Rights sanctions regime, as well as a complex set of measures, yet to be implemented, designed to ban the trade in goods from illegal settlements. The Foreign Office said it welcomed and encouraged trade with “green line Israel” and firmly distinguished this with activity in settlements. The Foreign Office said the current Israeli government had “not only refused to clamp down on illegal settlement, but has facilitated and encouraged them”. More settlements had been approved under the four years of this Israeli government than in the previous 20 years.
Miliband, who was criticised by some for broadening the sanctions criteria and planning a ban on trade with illegal settlement, said: “Protecting the two-state solution is the north star of this government’s approach. “That is why my message on E1 is clear: do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution. And we will not stand by while those blocking desperately needed aid deepen the intolerable suffering of civilians in Gaza. The status quo in the West Bank and Gaza is unacceptable.”
But he added in a potential olive branch: “We are committed to working productively with a new Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority to advance lasting peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians alike.”
Miliband and his Middle East minister, Stephen Doughty, have repeatedly highlighted the Israeli government’s refusal to let a variety of dual-use goods into Gaza. The Foreign Office said civilians in Gaza were in desperate need of winter supplies, with catastrophic floods leaving nearly 4,000 households without shelter and 1.4 million people living in tents or makeshift shelters. According to the UN, more than 150,000 tents and 300,000 tarpaulins bought by humanitarian partners and donors are outside Gaza ready to go in, but are being held by the Israeli authorities. The Israeli authorities also continue to block timber from entering, leaving no emergency shelter kits available in Gaza. The Israeli government claims the blockage of some goods is necessary to prevent Hamas obtaining items that could be used to attack Israel. The dispute over dual-use goods and closed entry points into Gaza has lasted for more than two years.
Analysis
Why This Matters
- The sanctions mark a significant escalation in UK policy toward Israeli settlements, directly targeting the companies involved in construction rather than relying solely on trade bans
- They come as the E1 settlement, which would bisect the West Bank and severely undermine the viability of a two-state solution, is about to be tendered
- The simultaneous sanctioning of an activist group blocking aid into Gaza underscores UK concern over the humanitarian crisis in Gaza as winter approaches
Background
The UK government has been widening its sanctions regime against illegal settlements since September, when Miliband announced an expansion of the Global Human Rights sanctions regime and planned a ban on trade with settlements. The current Israeli government, led by Benjamin Netanyahu until a coalition change is expected, has approved more settlements in four years than in the previous 20, according to the Foreign Office. Meanwhile, Gadi Eisenkot, who is poised to become prime minister, has said he will take a tougher approach to settler violence. The dispute over dual-use goods entering Gaza has dragged on for over two years, with Israel arguing restrictions are needed to prevent Hamas from obtaining weapon-capable items.
Key Perspectives
Ed Miliband, UK foreign secretary: said protecting the two-state solution is the “north star” of the government’s approach, and that the message on E1 is “do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution”. He also said the UK is committed to “working productively with a new Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority to advance lasting peace and security”.
Foreign Office: said the current Israeli government had “not only refused to clamp down on illegal settlement, but has facilitated and encouraged them”.
Israeli government: claims the blockage of some goods is necessary to prevent Hamas obtaining items that could be used to attack Israel.
What to Watch
- Whether the E1 settlement tenders proceed despite the UK sanctions, and what diplomatic responses follow from Israel
- Whether Eisenkot, if he becomes prime minister, follows through on his stated tougher approach to settler violence
- Whether other countries follow the UK’s lead in imposing direct sanctions on settlement-linked companies
Checked
12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.
Show each claim
- SupportedThe UK has announced its first sanctions on Israeli firms over West Bank settlements.UK news | The Guardian: “Ed Miliband announces first sanctions on Israeli firms working in West Bank. Ed Miliband has announced the first set of sanctions against Israeli companies planning to build illegal settlements in the West Bank”
- SupportedThe sanctions target eight construction companies and an activist group.UK news | The Guardian: “The sanctions are designed to stop the flow of finance to eight identified construction firms”
- SupportedThe announcement came just before tenders for the E1 settlement were due to be allocated.UK news | The Guardian: “Miliband announced the measures just before tenders for the large E1 West Bank settlement were due to be allocated by the Israeli government”
- Not in the sourcesMiliband announced the measures on Tuesday.UK news | The Guardian: “Ed Miliband has announced the first set of sanctions against Israeli companies planning to build illegal settlements in the West Bank”
- SupportedMiliband said, “Protecting the two-state solution is the north star of this government’s approach.”UK news | The Guardian: ““Protecting the two-state solution is the north star of this government’s approach.”
- SupportedMiliband said, “That is why my message on E1 is clear: do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution.”UK news | The Guardian: ““That is why my message on E1 is clear: do not bid, do not build, and do not profit from the destruction of the two-state solution.”
- SupportedMiliband said the UK was committed to working with a new Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority.UK news | The Guardian: ““We are committed to working productively with a new Israeli government and the Palestinian Authority to advance lasting peace and security for Israelis and Palestinians alike.””
- SupportedThe sanctions are intended to stop finance flowing to eight firms, though their dependence on British finance has not been tested.UK news | The Guardian: “The sanctions are designed to stop the flow of finance to eight identified construction firms, although in practice the extent to which any of the firms are dependent on British finance is yet to be tested.”
- SupportedThe Foreign Office said the Israeli government had “not only refused to clamp down on illegal settlement, but has facilitated and encouraged them”.UK news | The Guardian: “The Foreign Office said the current Israeli government had “not only refused to clamp down on illegal settlement, but has facilitated and encouraged them”.”
- SupportedFloods left nearly 4,000 households without shelter.UK news | The Guardian: “The Foreign Office said civilians in Gaza were in desperate need of winter supplies, with catastrophic floods leaving nearly 4,000 households without shelter”
- SupportedThe Foreign Office said 1.4 million people were living in tents or makeshift shelters.UK news | The Guardian: “and 1.4 million people living in tents or makeshift shelters.”
- SupportedThe UN said more than 150,000 tents and 300,000 tarpaulins were outside Gaza, ready to enter, and being held by Israeli authorities.UK news | The Guardian: “According to the UN, more than 150,000 tents and 300,000 tarpaulins bought by humanitarian partners and donors are outside Gaza ready to go in, but are being held by the Israeli authorities.”