Ukraine Adviser Says US Intelligence Restrictions Causing Deaths, Despite White House Denials

Serhii Beskrestnov tells BBC warnings are incomplete and inconsistent; White House says no changes to intelligence sharing

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
A key adviser to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has told the BBC that Ukrainians have died because Kyiv is not receiving reliable US warnings of incoming Russian attacks, directly contradicting US assurances that intelligence sharing has been fully restored.

Serhii "Flash" Beskrestnov, an adviser to President Zelensky, said that lives had been lost because the US was not providing enough time to warn citizens about ballistic missile strikes. "It's dangerous... I think it's really very bad... People [have] already died," he told BBC News.

Ukraine first reported an interruption to US intelligence sharing last week amid a row with the Trump administration over a controversial deal to import Russian oil. President Zelensky wrote on social media on Monday that two ballistic missile attacks on the capital had occurred overnight, one without warning and the second with only minimal time to take shelter. In an interview with NBC published hours earlier, Zelensky said intelligence sharing had been restored after a three-day pause. "We are very thankful for this," he said, noting that only the US has the unique intelligence to warn when Russia uses ballistic missiles.

But Beskrestnov told the BBC that American intelligence remained incomplete and inconsistent, and that the US had failed to provide a clear explanation. "This looks very strange," he said. "Sometimes we receive this information before the attack, another time we [do] not." He added that on the previous night, warnings arrived just one minute before the attack. He stressed that other intelligence collaboration continues and that the issue is solely with the air raid alert component.

The White House denied any changes to intelligence sharing. A White House official, speaking on background, said there were no changes to intelligence sharing operations between the US and Ukraine, and that President Trump is focused on ending the war. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio told reporters on Monday that he did not know where Zelensky was getting his claims, adding that there had not been a "pause" to intelligence sharing. Rubio said he could not comment on the incident but noted that "a few nights ago there was a software problem involving their early warning system."

Beskrestnov also said that restrictions to Ukraine's use of the Starlink internet network and the military service Starshield were ongoing. Last week, Starshield limited the speed at which mobile units could stay connected to 100mph (160km/h), hindering Ukraine's ability to shoot down drones or launch mid-range drone attacks. Starlink owner Elon Musk said the US government ultimately controls access to Starshield, suggesting it may be behind the restrictions. Trump has denied involvement.

Beskrestnov said the simultaneous issues were "probably" a deliberate move to pressure Ukraine into negotiations with Russia. He said Ukraine is urgently looking into alternative communication systems, as it cannot be sure what to expect next regarding Starlink.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • The dispute over intelligence sharing directly affects Ukraine's ability to defend against Russian missile attacks, potentially costing civilian lives.
  • The simultaneous Starlink and Starshield restrictions raise questions about US reliability as a partner, even as Washington insists support is unchanged.
  • The row complicates prospects for any ceasefire or peace negotiations, as trust between Kyiv and Washington erodes.

Background

Ukraine relies heavily on US satellite intelligence and real-time warnings to prepare for Russian ballistic missile strikes, which can reach Kyiv in minutes. Last week, Ukraine reported an interruption to intelligence sharing after tensions flared over the Trump administration's deal to import Russian oil. Meanwhile, Starlink and its military variant Starshield have been critical for Ukrainian military communications, drone operations and internet connectivity. Any disruption to these systems forces Ukraine to seek alternatives.

Key Perspectives

Ukraine (President Zelensky and adviser Beskrestnov): The US warnings are incomplete and inconsistent, and people have died as a result. Restrictions on Starlink and Starshield appear coordinated and are likely intended to pressure Kyiv into talks with Russia. Ukraine is grateful for US support but needs reliable, timely alerts and unrestricted connectivity. United States (White House and State Department): There have been no changes to intelligence sharing. Reports of a pause are denied; a software problem may have caused a temporary issue. The Trump administration is focused on ending the war and notes it has provided more aid than any other country. Critics/Skeptics: The conflicting accounts raise doubts about US transparency. If the White House is indeed restricting intelligence or Starlink access while publicly denying it, that undermines confidence in US commitments. The timing of the issues alongside the oil deal dispute suggests political leverage rather than technical glitches.

What to Watch

  • Further statements from the White House or Pentagon clarifying whether any restrictions exist on air raid alert data.
  • Any changes to Starlink or Starshield service terms that affect Ukrainian operations.
  • The outcome of the oil deal dispute and its impact on broader US-Ukraine relations, including potential pressure for negotiations.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 11 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedUkraine Adviser Says US Intelligence Restrictions Causing Deaths, Despite White House DenialsBBC News: “Ukrainians dying because US restricting intelligence sharing, Zelensky adviser tells BBC”
  2. SupportedSerhii Beskrestnov tells BBC warnings are incomplete and inconsistent; White House says no changes to intelligence sharingBBC News: “Beskrestnov told the BBC that American intelligence continued to be incomplete and inconsistent... A White House official said there were no changes to intelligence sharing operations between the US and Ukraine.”
  3. Partly supportedA key adviser to Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky has told the BBC that Ukrainians have died because Kyiv is not receiving reliable US warnings of incoming Russian attacks, directly contradicting US assurances that intelligence sharing has been fully restored.BBC News: “Ukrainians have died because Kyiv is still not receiving reliable US warnings of incoming Russian attacks... The White House said there had been no changes to intelligence sharing with Ukraine.”
  4. Supported"It's dangerous... I think it's really very bad... People [have] already died."BBC News: “It's dangerous... I think it's really very bad... People [have] already died.”
  5. SupportedOn the previous night, warnings arrived just one minute before the attack.BBC News: “And for example, last night we received it, but... one minute before the attack.”
  6. SupportedUkraine first reported an interruption to US intelligence sharing last week amid a row with the Trump administration over a controversial deal to import Russian oil.BBC News: “Ukraine first reported an interruption to US intelligence sharing last week , as a row with the Trump administrations over its controversial deal to import Russian oil sent relations to new lows.”
  7. SupportedPresident Zelensky wrote on social media on Monday that two ballistic missile attacks on the capital had occurred overnight, one without warning and the second with only minimal time to take shelter.BBC News: “On Monday morning, Zelensky wrote on social media: 'Overnight two ballistic missile attacks were reported on the capital, one without warning, the second with only minimal time to take shelter.'”
  8. SupportedIn an interview with NBC published hours earlier, Zelensky said intelligence sharing had been restored after a three-day pause.BBC News: “Hours earlier, an interview the president did with NBC was published, in which he said intelligence sharing had been restored after a three-day pause.”
  9. SupportedA White House official, speaking on background, said there were no changes to intelligence sharing operations between the US and Ukraine, and that President Trump is focused on ending the war.BBC News: “A White House official said there were no changes to intelligence sharing operations between the US and Ukraine. The official spoke on background to discuss intelligence matters. Trump is focused on ending the war, the official said.”
  10. SupportedUS Secretary of State Marco Rubio told reporters on Monday that he did not know where Zelensky was getting his claims, adding that there had not been a 'pause' to intelligence sharing.BBC News: “I don't know where [Zelensky is] getting these things or why he's saying these things to the press... Rubio said there had not been a 'pause' to intelligence sharing.”
  11. SupportedRubio said he could not comment on the incident but noted that 'a few nights ago there was a software problem involving their early warning system.'BBC News: “I know a few nights ago there was a software problem involving their early warning system.”
  12. SupportedLast week, Starshield limited the speed at which mobile units could stay connected to 100mph (160km/h), hindering Ukraine's ability to shoot down drones or launch mid-range drone attacks.BBC News: “Last week, Starshield restricted the speed at which mobile units could move while staying connected to the network to 100mph (160km/h). This has limited Ukraine's ability to shoot down incoming drones or to launch mid-range drone attacks.”

Zotpaper

Written by Harper Lane on the World desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub.

1 source11 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe