US electric vehicle sales slump despite high gas prices, analysis finds

Study argues supply shortage caused by policy changes, not lack of consumer demand

By LineZotpaper
Published
Read Time3 min
A new analysis from George Washington University challenges the conventional explanation for a 16 percent drop in US electric vehicle sales this spring, a period when gasoline prices surged past $4 per gallon following US and Israeli strikes on Iran. Professor John Paul Helveston argues the decline was driven by a policy-induced manufacturing retreat, not a failure of consumer appetite for electric cars.

In the three months following the strikes on Iran on February 28, 2026, the average price of gasoline in America rose from $2.94 to $4.35 a gallon. While sales of hybrid vehicles surged 18 percent over the same period, sales of fully electric vehicles fell by 16 percent. Writing in The Conversation, Helveston contends that the divergence has little to do with consumer preferences and everything to do with what was actually available to buy.

The supply of new EVs had been in retreat since the Trump administration ended federal tax credits for electric vehicles in September 2025. Automakers responded by cutting capacity. General Motors laid off more than 3,400 workers at its EV and battery plants. Ford wrote down $19.5 billion from its EV business and ended production of its all-electric F-150 Lightning truck. By November 2025, the EV share of new vehicle sales had fallen to 4.3 percent, down from a credit-fueled high of 11.3 percent in September.

When the Iran crisis drove up demand for efficient vehicles in early 2026, the industry was unprepared. An analysis of online listings from marketcheck.com shows the median discount on new EVs shrank from 9.8 percent below sticker price in February to just 4.7 percent in June, a sign that supply was tight. Inventories of new EVs fell from roughly 130 days of supply in the first quarter to 78 days by August, barely above the level for gasoline cars.

The used market tells a similar story. Prices for used electric vehicles climbed 13 percent through late June, adding about $3,500 to the cost of a typical vehicle. Recurrent, a company that tracks used EV batteries, found the price of a used 2023 Chevrolet Bolt rose almost 20 percent between January and June. Used EV inventories fell to just 31 days of supply in May.

Federal policy is continuing to move in the same direction. A new fuel economy rule released in September 2026 loosens efficiency requirements for gas-powered vehicles. A Commerce Department rule will bar cars from Chinese-linked automakers starting with the 2027 model year, and a bill in Congress would widen that ban. American buyers had just four EV models priced under $40,000 in 2024, compared with more than 130 in China.

The result, Helveston concludes, is that drivers remain exposed to the volatility of world oil prices with fewer alternatives. With oil still above $100 a barrel in mid-October and diesel hitting a record $6.52 a gallon in late September, the gap between the electric vehicles Americans want and those available to buy looks set to persist.

§

Analysis

Why This Matters

  • Challenges the widely reported narrative that high gas prices failed to spark EV adoption, shifting the focus from consumer demand to industrial policy.
  • Demonstrates the real-world consequences of abruptly removing purchase incentives, leaving the domestic auto industry unable to respond to a geopolitical energy crisis.
  • Highlights continued vulnerability of American drivers to global oil price shocks in the absence of a robust domestic supply of affordable electric alternatives.

Background

The analysis focuses on the chain of events following the July 2025 tax and spending law signed by President Trump, which ended federal tax credits of up to $7,500 for new EVs and $4,000 for used EVs. Automakers including Ford and General Motors responded by cutting EV production and shifting capacity back to gasoline vehicles. The geopolitical crisis with Iran that began in late February 2026 caused a sharp increase in gasoline prices, creating a sudden surge in demand for fuel-efficient cars.

Key Perspectives

[John Paul Helveston / EV market analysts]: The sales data reflects supply gridlock, not demand rejection. Policy reversals dismantled manufacturing capacity just when a crisis made efficient vehicles most attractive to buyers. Consumers wanted EVs but could not find them at reasonable prices. [Automakers (Ford, GM)]: Faced a rational strategic choice. Without federal purchase subsidies, the immediate consumer market for EVs evaporated. Shifting resources back to proven, profitable gasoline lines was necessary to protect the business. [Administration and free-market proponents]: Reducing subsidies and loosening fuel economy rules lowers the immediate upfront cost of new gas-powered cars. The administration's analysis estimates buyers save $1,289 on purchase price, though independent economists note the long-term fuel costs likely outweigh these savings.

What to Watch

  • EV inventory levels and pricing trends over the rest of 2026 as an indicator of whether automakers begin to rebuild capacity.
  • The progress of the congressional bill that would widen the ban on Chinese-linked automakers and block Chinese investment in US auto factories.
  • Whether sustained high oil prices eventually pull manufacturing investment back into the US EV sector or if the gap in affordable models persists.

Sources

Checked

12 claims in this story checked against 1 source: 8 supported.

Show each claim
  1. SupportedUS electric-vehicle sales slumped despite high gas prices, an analysis found.Fortune | FORTUNE: “From March to May 2026, in fact, sales of hybrid electric vehicles were 18% higher than over the same months in 2025. But sales of fully electric vehicles were 16% lower from March to May 2026 compared with the same months in 2025.”
  2. Partly supportedA study argues a policy-driven supply shortage, rather than lack of consumer demand, caused the EV sales decline.Fortune | FORTUNE: “Rather, the sales stalled because there weren’t enough EVs available to buy – and there were plenty of hybrids as an alternative.”
  3. Partly supportedThe analysis is from George Washington University.Fortune | FORTUNE: “John Paul Helveston , Associate Professor of Engineering Management and Systems Engineering, George Washington University”
  4. Partly supportedProfessor John Paul Helveston argues the decline reflects policy-induced manufacturing retreat, not a failure of consumer appetite.Fortune | FORTUNE: “John Paul Helveston , Associate Professor of Engineering Management and Systems Engineering, George Washington University”
  5. SupportedGasoline prices rose from $2.94 to $4.35 a gallon within three months of the February 28 strikes on Iran.Fortune | FORTUNE: “Within three months of the U.S. and Israeli strikes on Iran on Feb. 28, 2026, the average price of gasoline for American drivers climbed from US$2.94 to $4.35 a gallon .”
  6. Partly supportedHybrid sales rose 18% and fully electric vehicle sales fell 16% over the same period.Fortune | FORTUNE: “From March to May 2026, in fact, sales of hybrid electric vehicles were 18% higher than over the same months in 2025. But sales of fully electric vehicles were 16% lower from March to May 2026 compared with the same months in 2025.”
  7. SupportedFederal EV tax credits ended in September 2025, after which automakers cut EV production.Fortune | FORTUNE: “Buyers had been able to get up to $7,500 for new EVs and $4,000 for used ones, but that ended after Sept. 30, 2025. Automakers responded by cutting back their EV production.”
  8. SupportedBy November 2025, EVs' share of new vehicle sales had fallen to 4.3%, from 11.3% in September.Fortune | FORTUNE: “Buyers, for their part, rushed to beat the tax credit deadline, pushing EVs to 11.3% of new vehicle sales in September 2025. But by November 2025, after the tax credits ended, their share dropped to 4.3% .”
  9. SupportedThe median discount on new EVs shrank from 9.8% below sticker price in February to 4.7% in June.Fortune | FORTUNE: “My analysis of online listings from marketcheck.com shows the median new EV was listed 9.8% below sticker price in February. By April, the median discount was 6.6%, and 4.7% in June.”
  10. SupportedUsed EV prices climbed 13% through late June, adding about $3,500 to the cost of a typical vehicle.Fortune | FORTUNE: “After the war began, they climbed 13% through late June 2026 . For a typical used electric vehicle, that’s about $3,500 more.”
  11. SupportedA fuel economy rule released in September 2026 loosens efficiency requirements for gas-powered vehicles.Fortune | FORTUNE: “The fuel economy rule released Sept. 28, 2026 , loosens efficiency requirements for gas-powered vehicles”
  12. SupportedOil remained above $100 a barrel in mid-October, and diesel hit a record $6.52 a gallon in late September.Fortune | FORTUNE: “Oil was still above $100 a barrel in mid-October, and diesel hit a record $6.52 a gallon on Sept. 22.”

Zotpaper

Written by June Katz on the Business & markets desk. Claims checked by Ines Fairley, verification. Edited by Angus Burke, chief sub. Plate by Ollie Flash, picture desk.

1 source8 of 12 claims matched to a sourcefirst published
Meet the newsroomHow we workSubscribe